We talked last week about Bernstein Research, the research arm of Sanford Bernstein & Co, and its thoughts about Google turning its Kansas fiber operation into a US wide, profitable business, and this week it has offered more of its thinking to clients.
It said that unlike others it sees ‘a material chance that Google Fiber will expand to a large portion of the 34 cities it is currently considering over the next two years after Google’s CFO revealed that the Kansas fiber experiment was ‘very profitable.’
Bernstein offers two scenarios, one where Google Fiber deploys in most of the 34 cities, and this adds a further 3.3 million homes and 0.9 million small business locations over two years, to the 0.9 million homes and 0.2 million small business locations already in and around Kansas City, in Provo and in Austin, for a total of 5.3 million locations passed.
The second scenario assumes a subsequent, incremental 4 year build out passing another 15 million homes and 3.9 million business locations, to reach a total of 19 million homes and 5 million small business locations in 5-6 years and goes on to say that if that happens it could expand this to pass 25 million US locations within 6-8 years.
It then built a map by ranking the 3,400 cities mentioned by internal rate of return calculations so that Google will do the most profitable 15 million homes and lists all of these regions in its report. This sample has 661 cities taking it to 24 million homes by 2019.
It then assumes that Google will still continue to get 50% penetration, which is what it has achieved to date in Kansas, which means it will have 10 million residential customers in 6-8 years from now.
It has further mapped this against rivals and says that if Comcast Time Warner Cable took the brunt of this, there would only be 5 million of these homes in its territory, and that assuming that 70% of Google customers came from Comcast TWC, then it would still only lose 3.5 million homes over 6 to 8 years. So Bernstein doesn’t think there would be a huge pricing reaction from cable companies.
This does represents a 10% attrition on Comcast’s TWC’s 30 million homes, and given that to date Cable has only ever ‘gained’ broadband subscribers, we are inclined to disagree at this point.
Bernstein says that across the US this would result in 31.2 million customers for Google Fiber, driving revenue of $34.4 billion after 10 years. The cost would be $45 billion of free cash flow over that time, at roughly $9 billion a year and by the end of that period it would be throwing off around $8 billion of cash each year.
It still looks like a radical change of business for Google ‘ hating AT&T and Comcast enough to become one of them ‘ but we do like analysts that at least ‘think different.’