Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 June 2014

US cable operators more unpopular than ever

Efforts by the leading US MSOs to reverse a long standing decline in customer satisfaction appear to have failed dismally so far. At least two quite different surveys report high levels of consumer frustration with both TV and associated Internet offerings, which gel with other recent US consumer trends that are unfavorable for MSOs, such as greater willingness to cut the cord and fast growing penetration of connected TVs.

Comcast tried to shrug off the American Customer Satisfaction Index as being out of date after its Xfinity Internet service was ranked at 234 out of 236 and its TV service landed at 232 in a list of leading brands spanning all retail facing industries for customer satisfaction, including Coke, Campbell Soup, Nissan, Allstate and Verizon Communications. But it has come out just as badly in the Brand Vulnerability Index (BVI) compiled by management consultancy cg42 based on a survey of over 3,000 current customers, which rated the operator as the most vulnerable US MSO to churn. Time Warner, which Comcast is taking over, was ranked second worst, followed by Charter, Cablevision and Cox Communications in that order. Time Warner’s Internet service was rated bottom of the 236 companies in the American Customer Satisfaction Index, although there its TV service did much better, coming 25th.

The cg42 BVI will cause most concern for the five leading US MSOs in general, since it forecast that a total $7 billion revenue was vulnerable to churn. Only a small portion of this total was likely to be recirculated among these five operators, according to cg42, with the rest going to the two primary satellite competitors, DirecTV and DISH, as well as streaming options and other emerging contenders.

‘The astronomical levels of customer dissatisfaction we’ve found in the cable industry are unmatched by any other industry we’ve ever examined,’ said Stephen Beck, founder and managing partner of cg42. ‘With more customers exploring other options, it’s critical for traditional cable providers to understand how their frustrating services and policies are impacting customer behavior ‘ and ultimately their balance sheets.’

The cg42 BVI survey examined four components of brand vulnerability: frequency of customer frustrations; customer sharing behavior such as disclosure of frustrations on social media; the impact of frustrations on likelihood of churn; and the uniqueness of frustration to a particular cable provider. The survey found that 53% of all cable customers are frustrated by their providers and would churn given the chance. Then, significantly in the light of the Comcast/Time Warner merger, 72% of consumers are concerned that their service will get worse still if their cable provider gets bigger.

The only positive was that the majority of consumers would prefer to have one provider for all content rather than using multiple operators, which perhaps explains why churn is not higher than it is.

Meanwhile a study by the Leichtman Research Group has found that 49% of US households now have at least one TV set connected to the web, up from 38% in 2012 and 24% in 2010, which itself increases the probability of churn to OTT providers from traditional pay TV operators. This survey, which admittedly counted TVs attached via a video game system, Blu-ray player, or stand-alone device like Roku, Apple TV, or Google Chromecast as connected, found that 24% of adults watch video from the internet via a TV, at least weekly. This compared to 13% of people two years ago and just 5% four years ago. It also found that connected television is heavily skewed towards Netflix subscribers, which is largely a US phenomenon. Now 49% of US Netflix subscribers watch video from the internet via a connected device weekly, compared to 8% among non-Netflix subscribers.