The launch by Sony America of a device that can compete with the Apple TV and Roku boxes in the net top space, bringing OTT video to TVs in the home, may finally begin to turn the giant ship that is Sony. I know it seems unlikely but hear us out.
E3 is the pre-eminent annual games event that is universally used as a launch pad for anything to do with gaming, and Sony is used to dominating its headlines. But as much as Sony has dominated headlines in the past decade, it has failed to dominate its own core markets since the first signs that all was not well in the state of Sony, back in 2003. It was that year in what was called at the time the ‘Sony Shock’ that all of its core markets soured and nothing that any of its leaders have done since have changed this direction. Whenever it has made a move, smaller, more nimble competitors have moved first and taken all the market awareness.
Over the past 11 years Sony has been overshadowed by Apple and Samsung particularly, as the global consumer electronics leaders, and we have seen Sony depart many key markets, most recently making PCs, while its dominance of gaming has been threatened initially by Microsoft, then Nintendo and finally by the casual touch based games that can be found on the Apple App Store and increasingly on Google’ s Play.
But the move by Sony to introduce PlayStation TV to the US, small as it may be, could herald something new for Sony, a new genre of product that many have talked about, but which Sony has somehow reached first.
The PlayStation TV was initially launched in Japan under the name PS Vita TV, announced in September last year and delivered in November. It was described negatively back then as a PS Vita that was not handheld, and given that one of its most appealing features is connection to the PS4 and that the PS4 had not then been launched in Japan, the fact that sales were so-so in Japan is probably not an indicator of US success. It’s European launch is also imminent.
For the past 4 years we have heard discussions of the PS4 and the Xbox 360 becoming platforms for OTT and IPTV video , as well as gaming. That’s all very well, but for homes which do not currently own one, the prospect of spending $300 plus to buy a box that will mostly be used for playing video is unappealing.
That’s because the Net Top market, initially spawned by companies like Aple and later joined by Roku in 2007 and 2008, at a sub $100 price point, has undermined any benefit consoles can get from adding video. It’s fine to stimulate greater use among established gamers, but console video ability will not reach out to new audiences.
Finally the addition of HDMI sticks that puts much of the OTT video function into a tiny processor that can plug into a USB port, has further fragmented the market, raising questions about Net Tops and whether or not they would have any elongated existence. News this week that Chromecast sales have turned down, seems to suggest that people want a box, as long as it’s small enough to carry to their friend’s house, rather than an HDMI stick.
The critical combination that changes all this is putting an established catalog of gaming favorites, including action titles with heroes and backstories, not just casual games, and putting that out with a strong collection of video content on a sub $100 OTT box. This is something that has to come from either Microsoft, Nintendo or Sony, because no-one else has control of sufficient titles of sufficient quality. These are not casual games remember, just about anyone can do that, and ActiveVideo has partnered with Cablevision in the US to offer casual games which get 1 million loads per week, but that’s not PlayStation class games.
But the new PlayStation TV adds another dimension, one that would be really hard for anyone else to add, unless it had acquired one of the cloud gaming companies, that became so popular over the past five years or so. There are just three GaiKai, acquired by Sony, OnLive that has been acquired by the ActiveVideo chairman and lead investor Gary Lauder. The last one is 40 man Israeli start up PlayCast, which sells only through operators, such as Bouygues in France.
Sony paid $380 million in July 2012 for GaiKai, we suspect after having been rebuffed by OnLive, and it is only now that it is bringing it to bear as a weapon in the games market. The cloud gaming concept allows something as powerful as a PS3 game to be rendered in the cloud and sent as a video stream to any device that which render video and which has a return signal for controls. Certainly a $100 device can play them and possibly even a HDMI stick, which after all is run on an Arm device (Chromecast for instance runs on an ARM architected Marvell chip).
So PlayStation TV should be able to play PS1 and even some PS2 catalog games, rendering on the device, and it can also play the rest of the Ps2 archive and PS3 games by rendering in the cloud. We’re pretty sure that these games were not all available when the device launched in Japan.
And it can play TV series and Movies in multiple OTT formats. It seems automatically more compelling than Apple TV, which can only work with iOS devices, and only show content from iTunes.
We have talked before about PlayStation gaming being able to drive sales for Sony and back in 2011, Sony began the job of putting gaming into a phone and tablet, starting with its Xperia Play PlayStation phone. It should have been a strong move, but it has failed to the extent that we can’t actually find out how many Sony actually sold. Sony has made great strides with Xperia devices, but do not break out the individual device shipment numbers.
But PlayStation as a console brand has always been stronger than its portable versions. The key thing here is that a far back as three years ago Apple was said to be working on something like this and in every subsequent announcement by Apple, the idea of adding games to Apple TV has raised its head. That of course was after we spent 5 years talking about Apple introducing an OTT service which had 30 TV channels and could compete directly with Cable TV in the US. (We have also spent 5 years expecting Apple to launch its own TV and for its executives to walk on water).
And this is the heart of our point. Apple has NOT done those things. Sony is glacially slow at a) seeing a good idea and b) coming up with something that can effectively exploit that idea. So much so, that if Apple had done a half-hearted job of launching games on Apple TV, it would have won by now. But Sony has launched this in Japan, taken a look at it, improved it and now feels it is ready for the big stage. A launch in China is also on the cards.
Apple is no longer an innovating monster that keeps changing the rules. This is partly because it doesn’t have to be and partly because it doesn’t want to be. Instead now it wants to stay on top of the markets it owns, and so it wants a decade of dominating those markets purely by brand and design envy.
Which is why things have stayed still long enough for Sony to actually get something off the ground, something that was obvious the day the first Apple TV came out in 2007. Someone at Sony must have said, ‘Hey we could do that, but put games on it,’ but it’s just taken this long.
The reason that Sony is so glacially slow is because the company works in multiple segments, almost autonomous from senior management and from one another, and they have often shown they are unable to work closely together on a single project. PlayStation TV may not get privileged access to Sony movies or TV series from Sony Pictures, in the same way that the PlayStation took years before any of its features were allowed into a phone. However if Sony put Netflix and Hulu on this box straight away, and the software already exists, then this should help a lot.
What the youth of today actually think of the Sony brand is hard to be certain of. Perhaps Sony is an anti-brand among the young? One that drives them away from products, rather than towards them. We will soon find out. This device should sell in droves as long as it has shelf space and actually works. Let’s see if Sony can conspire to screw this up.
The clues that suggest that Sony might be learning is that it has managed to buy a company in GaiKai, and keep its team in place and place the idea front and center in a new product line. That’s not the sort of thing that Sony usually does, that has undertones more closely associated with Qualcomm.
Sony said that the PlayStation TV has been continuously evolved since its launch, through software updates and content enhancements. It still uses the same chip sets and system software as the PlayStation Vita, and is 6.5cm ‘ 10.5cm and it supports 1080i video.
The main features of the PS TV system includes PlayStation 4 remote play support for the PS4 remote play and wireless dualshock controllers. The GaiKai system has been renamed PlayStation Now and will shortly launch in all markets where the PlayStation TV is sold.