Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 June 2014

Regulators focus on excluding video services from cellular caps

Regulators are zooming in on zero rating of data as a growing number of operators introduce services that do not count against the subscriber’s allotted monthly data plan.

One country, Chile, banned the practice completely four years ago, but there are no signs as yet of such network neutrality purity gaining statutory backing elsewhere. Even the European Union has allowed scope for ‘specialized services’ within its supposedly strong network neutral proposals that would outlaw favored interconnection agreements like the one between Netflix and Comcast in the US. The implication is that such specialized services cannot include OTT video but perhaps non-Internet apps like messaging.

Such non-Internet apps or services constitute a clear category in the mobile data universe when it comes to zero rating. A second class is content or apps that are delivered over the Internet and free to the end user, including social networking and numerous applications both commercial and non-commercial ranging from mapping to health advice to advertising in all its forms. On the social networking front Facebook has been actively pursuing zero rated data deals with operators, not always with success so far. Vodafone earlier this year turned down Facebook’s request that data to its site should be zero rated in some developing countries, with the riposte ‘what’s in it for us?’ Facebook argued that offering zero rated access to it in markets where there is widespread concern over the cost of mobile data would attract customers, but Vodafone replied that it was doing nicely anyway without subsidizing Facebook usage.

The third category of mobile data is associated with paid Internet content or apps, which of course includes Netflix, Amazon, Hulu and a host of other lesser OTT video offerings, as well as music streaming sites such as Spotify. This is where the confusion has come in, since there is little to stop an operator zero rating data for these services under any conceivable net neutrality framework.

A mobile service provider could offer extra free data to any customer signing up to say Netflix without contravening any rule. There would be no priority given to the Netflix traffic and no zero rated data by the letter of the law. But the operator could measure firstly how much data on average is consumed by Netflix customers over a month and add that amount as a free offer to the data plan of each customer subscribing to the service. The operator could even go further and monitor each individual subscriber’s Netflix usage and fine tune that user’s allocation, changing the free data offer each month accordingly to ensure that the amount consumed by Netflix data is exactly equal to the extra given in the plan, so users still have plenty for their other activities.

This would be zero rating by the backdoor and could be said to violate the spirit of net neutrality, in the sense that in practice such offers would likely be confined around the larger OTT players. There have certainly been suggestions that zero rating would enable major Internet players like Facebook or Netflix to become even more dominant, especially among emerging Internet users who might be less aware of what is else is out there on the web. The same argument could be made about offers that top up data plans to allow for specific OTT services.

Regulatory scrutiny could ensure that basic data plans are not squeezed by such offers as operators seek to steer their customers to sites from which they derive revenue by reducing available data quotas for general Internet usage. There is a grey area perhaps regarding services offered by carriers themselves in competition with third party offerings. Such carrier provided services are not strictly OTT but they are supposed to be subject to the same net neutrality laws as those from third parties. It could then be said that if they came with offers of free data of the sort we have just mentioned that is an abuse of net neutrality, but in a sense there is no difference between favoring your own service in some way and that of a partner. Either way the carrier is gaining revenue as a result.

This point is of interest in the context of recent announcements and launches by major carriers. AT&T is a prime mover here, having first launched its Sponsored Data scheme in January 2014 and then followed up with announcement of a $500 million investment to develop its own video streaming service in competition with Netflix.

AT&T had already under its Sponsored Data program zero rated data generated by several customers’ services, including ad platform Aquto, business apps developer Kony Solutions, and UnitedHealth Group for streaming educational health care related videos to mobile devices. The question naturally arose whether AT&T would zero rate data for its own online TV service to its mobile subscribers.

This question has not been answered yet, but has become even more poignant while regulators are debating its $49 billion offer for DirecTV, the world’s largest DTH operator. AT&T has already floated the idea of offering DirecTV’s National Football League Sunday Ticket service, which averages over 19 million viewers a week, to its mobile customers. AT&T has even hinted it might zero rate NFL games in line with its Sponsored Data, suggesting it does plan to do this with its OTT TV service. But it seems premature and a little unwise to be mooting the possibility at this stage before the DirecTV takeover has been approved.

Similar considerations apply to Telefonica, which has launched various OTT services incorporating SVoD and TVoD (Transactional Vod) as pure OTT services to complement its existing IPTV offerings in several markets. Telefonica has been losing cellular market share in Spain for some years with just 34% now, but aims to capitalize on its content rights to reverse this. It has gained exclusive rights in Spain to all 546 matches between European teams in the qualifying stages for UEFA EURO 2016 and the 2018 FIFA World Cup and may decide to zero rate these to mobile subscribers.

It may seem odd that operators are looking to zero rate OTT services at a time when they appear equally desperate to offload video data to WiFi. It is certainly true that the effect of 4G/LTE in some cases has been to cause congestion on cellular backhaul infrastructures that have not kept pace with the extra radio access capacity. But the traffic operators want to offload whenever customers are within suitable hotspots is third party OTT traffic generated by YouTube for example, from which they derive no revenue. They want to differentiate between these and offerings from partners, which they would then route over their own cellular infrastructures.

Another factor here is the fate of LTE Broadcast, which on the face of it could enable mobile operators to deliver a few premium channels at guaranteed QoS without upsetting even the most diehard net neutrality zealots. The problem is that the business case for LTE Broadcast has yet to be established beyond big events at major venues when there are significant numbers of people in a given cell viewing the same video content simultaneously. For the time being then LTE Broadcast does not really feature in the debate relating to mobile zero rating.

Ironically, given Chile’s ban, it is in Latin America where zero rating is proving a particular hit with both operators and consumers, along with some other developing markets.

This is because 80% of mobile customers in Latin America are prepaid and particularly wary of incurring data costs. Operators are therefore trying out zero rating to entice subscribers into using data related services and apps in the hope they will be willing and able to pay for them in future.

Both Facebook and Twitter have been involved in such offers and appear in some cases to be contributing towards the bandwidth costs. Facebooks’s Messenger app, which is the parallel offering to WhatsApp, positioned as a platform for more sophisticated added options such as payments, is now available either free or discounted in at least 14 countries. In a sense emerging markets are ahead of developed countries in that mobile already accounts for a higher proportion of Internet usage in the absence of widespread fixed broadband networks. In India over 50% of web traffic now originates from mobile phones, despite the relatively low cellular bandwidth available to many people there. Zero rating and sponsored data are seen as critical in such countries to gain market share in a given sector.

More generally all the current conflicts and contradictions revolving around zero rating reflect the wider debate over who should pay to go on developing the wireless and underlying broadband infrastructures that will underpin all mobile and fixed line services.