Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

3 July 2014

US gets serious about choking ad revenue flow to OTT pirates

The US content industry has welcomed the latest measures announced by advertisers to cut off the ad revenues streams that have been fuelling and sustaining OTT piracy and deterring rights holders from making premium assets available online in early windows. But this has only come after extensive lobbying and disappointment with earlier steps taken last year by leading ad networks, which were criticized for lacking teeth and leaving too much of the burden for tackling piracy on content owners themselves.

The key change is that good intentions have been transformed into actions or at least firm initiatives that look like falling into line with the general campaign against piracy of OTT content, focusing on real time network surveillance and forensic watermarking. The aim is to enable offending streams to be taken down almost immediately, rather than waiting to identify culprits, by which time serious financial damage may have been done.

It was in July 2013 when major US ad networks formally signed up to a voluntary plan aimed at curbing online piracy. This included 24/7 Media, Adtegrity, AOL, Cond’ Nast, Google, Microsoft, SpotXchange, and Yahoo, supported by the Interactive Advertising Bureau, all committing to a set of best practices aimed at reducing the flow of ad revenue to operators of sites engaged in significant piracy and counterfeiting.

This won the immediate support of the Obama Administration, which issued a blog expressing strong support for these voluntary efforts by the private sector to reduce infringement. But it was criticized by the Motion Picture Association of America, whose Chairman and CEO Chris Dodd dismissed these ‘best practices’ for advertising networks to combat online piracy and counterfeiting as just ‘an incremental step forward’ that addressed only a small subset of the problem. He argued it still left a disproportionate burden on rights holders to tackle piracy of their assets.

These companies had signed up to the Best Practices Guidelines for Ad Networks to Address Piracy and Counterfeiting. The key best practices were firstly to ‘maintain and post policies intended to discourage or prevent, as far as practically possible, websites that are principally dedicated to selling counterfeit goods, engaging in copyright piracy or otherwise violating laws from participating in the ad network.

Secondly ad networks pledged to ‘accept and process proper notices from rights holders regarding websites alleged to be principally dedicated to selling counterfeit goods or engaging in copyright piracy and to have no substantial non-infringing uses.’ This last fine distinction has to be made because there are quite a lot of bona fide websites from which users obtain content and then infringe copyright laws through illegal retransmission. Such sites are ruled authentic if the majority of their users are authorized.

The networks emphasized that these best practices were intended to ‘encourage and supplement, not replace, responsible and direct independent actions taken by intellectual property owners to enforce their intellectual property rights and are not intended to impose a duty on any Ad Network to monitor its network to identify offending websites.’

This caveat, combined with the rather wooly nature of the document, led the MPAA to express its concern. These concerns have now borne fruit, since content owners are taking a much more favorable and optimistic view of anti-piracy measures being taken by the advertising industry. In a letter to representatives of the three major advertising associations, CreativeFuture, a coalition of over 250 film and TV companies and organizations, praised its recent pledge to do more to stem the flow of ad money to pirate sites.

Now the advertisers have backed up their words with tools and teeth, as well as a more solid organizational structure for dealing with ad pirates. The problem arises in large part because of the growing use of automated ad placement against OTT services, which makes it harder to keep track of where the ads go. This problem will get worse, with media forecasting unit Magna Global predicting that automated ad placement will account for 83% of all online ads placed by 2017, compared with 53% in 2013. Given its substantial base today it is not surprising automated ad placement is already being exploited by pirates. Almost 30% of websites that carry large amounts of unauthorized movies, TV shows and music are now incorporating ads for premium blue chip brands against this content. The total annual revenue from such pirated ads has now reached $227 million at an average of $4.4 million a year for each of the 30 largest.

Such data has helped galvanize the advertising industry to respond and come up with the more concrete actions now welcomed by CreativeFuture. These include real time monitoring tools that block adverts from being streamed with content that has itself been identified as being pirated. The industry has also gone beyond those initial best practice guidelines by developing a set of what it calls ‘Core Criteria for Effective Digital Advertising Assurance’, as well as the Interactive Advertising Bureau’s recently announced ‘Trustworthy Digital Supply Chain Initiative.’

The ad associations promised to produce an initial document specifying these core criteria during this summer and then publish a final version in the early fall (autumn). These are likely to dovetail with parallel efforts to combat OTT stream piracy of the assets themselves around which ads are being illicitly placed. The aim is to apply network forensic techniques to track down illegal streaming within minutes of it starting, for otherwise it is too late in the case of live sporting events, where nearly all the revenue is gained during the immediate live broadcasting. Taking such a stream down even an hour later may be too late and in any case tracking down the ultimate pirate may be impossible if stolen credit cards were used to make what appears at first like a legitimate purchase. Techniques for identifying illegal retransmission of streams ‘legitimately’ acquired can be as simple as recognizing that a device permanently tuned into a single premium sports channel is likely to be illicit.

Forensic watermarking will play a big role here by uniquely identifying each instance of a stream at the server level, without relying on the cooperation of devices, which can be tampered with. It is likely that watermarking systems will be adaptive in that they will be capable of detecting attacks on themselves and respond by changing the codes or triggering some action against the source of the attack.

Dealing with advertising against such pirated streams is crucial because this is becoming the principle source of revenue for many pirates. People tend to be unwilling to pay much for OTT content at the best of times, never mind when it comes from dubious sources and so pirates have been turning to adverts.