Just as soon as we published details of the Nokia Networks experiments in using LTE to deliver broadcast TV programs to televisions last week, there were a swathe of stories that said that the European Broadcast Union came out with an 89 page paper explaining why LTE was not ready to be used to replace the existing DVB-T standards.
Interestingly this did not, in any way shape or form contradict what Nokia was saying or what we wrote. In fact it had a lot of common details, so much so that we wonder if perhaps Nokia Networks wasn’t reading different conclusions from the same results and that the Nokia trial as announced last week, came about precisely because of this work by the EBU. Perhaps they would have been better released the other way around. ‘LTE is not ready, so let’s have a trial to improve it ,’ makes a lot more sense.
But while the EBU paper raises a number of issues that are quite important if you were trying to retain the status quo, the paper can also been seen as making it abundantly clear that LTE can become an alternative bearer for broadcast TV, as long as you accept that business models have to change.
One of the key points the EBU paper made was that in order to get broadcast TV over LTE, it would need to be delivered by each of up to four separate MNOs which compete in each territory. It wants a solution to this. It suggests that having 4 separate companies using spectrum, even if that spectrum is slightly more efficiently encoded than existing broadcast spectrum, would mean using almost four times as much spectrum to do the same job.
Now that is true if you want to make sure that every home can get free to air TV delivered to it that has been created by independent third parties, but if what you wish to do instead is delive a TV bouquet whether free or paid, to the customers of a single MNO, then that takes that objection out of the way.
The EBU paper talked about having some kind of common directory service, like an EPG, showing each handset and tablet, which piece of LTE spectrum the TV channels are on, so that everyone can find them. It talked about markets which are segmented by territory in cellular and those segmented by service, and talked about solving these problems. What this really amounts to is broadcasters not wanting to pay three or four separate MNOs to host its TV channels. They want to pay one.
A different model, one which could allow for pay TV, where the channel took some of the money and the LTE operator took the rest, might well work with eMBMS as it is, with the additional changes that Nokia is testing, including improved signal synchronization helping to achieve a robust Single Frequency Network.
Looking at how LTE networks are developing, there is every chance that neighboring LTE networks will be in spectrum that is not close enough to rival networks for the same radio to be used. And carrier aggregation in particular means that sometimes the downlink data will be delivered in very different spectrum from LTE, which make delivery mechanisms such the new Tower Overlay, which uses carrier aggregation, even less suitable.
The likely business model is that free to air TV delivery is contracted to a specific operator, and that operator then sells SIM cards to local set top makers who become authorized TV providers and go to market via retail. This would be very similar to the way Amazon in the US delivers ebooks over mobile broadband, initially over the Sprint network and then later over the AT&T network. It only sends the books over one network and that chip is built into the ereaders.
And this is another important part of what the EBU was saying and where Nokia was saying something very different. The EBU is talking about set top delivered content alongside handset delivered content in the same breath, as if a single eMBMS service would provide both. But as we discussed last week, very different screen definitions need different codecs and for the most part different carriers ‘ the TV signal has to be sent once for set tops and TVs and a second time for tablets and phones.
And again as we pointed out last week, tablets and phones can be provided by the same signal, but only if the codec is split into two signals, once very dense and another not so dense signal ‘ both being required for a HD TV set and one being sufficient for a tablet. Nokia is really talking about building a testbed to test these issues over the next one to two years, which is the sort of timeframe the EBU is seeing for LTE to be ready to carry TV.
And any TV channel that wanted to move to LTE being its carrier, really would be looking at dual delivery for the next 6 or 7 years anyway, while a TV upgrade cycle took place.
The EBU report also talks about encrypted content, and how this can only be delivered to receivers with a SIM card, using the cellular channel for the entitlement messages. In a set top, the decryption keys can be embedded within a secure part of the CPU chip.
The other thing that worried the EBU was how LTE can be used in broadcast mode for some TV channels, but in unicast for others, with all of the decisions being carried out dynamically. This ability has been shown hand coded many years ago, but is now part of the standard, and the EBU says it has never been demonstrated. We think that is trivial.
The EBU even goes as far as saying that spectral efficiency in the range between 1 and 2 bits per Hz seems achievable using an inter-site distance up to 5 km (very similar to cellular). It claims that a Low-Power-Low-Tower network topology as used by LTE may require less spectrum than a High-Power-High-Tower topology as used by DVB-T2.
To Faultline the answer is clear ‘ broadcasters will continue to look for the cheapest way forward for broadcast TV delivery, as long as they can reach most devices and more customers. Meanwhile usage will shift slowly to tablets, which will adopt more and more On Demand and catch up mode delivery, i.e. unicast. That delivery will require WiFi, rather than LTE until LTE Advance d is widespread (if it ever is).
At the same time more and more content delivery will happen over the internet, and the method of delivery over the internet will shift from Adaptive Bit Rate, to fixed bit rate versions that are more reliable, such as those offered using Multicast UDP by companies like Octoshape. That makes the network behavior more predictable for cellular.
Once a really large amount of TV content is being internet delivered, broadcasters will look to move away from expensive DVB-T2 services, and begin to look at multicast deals with LTE operators as long as they are cheap enough. That service will only be there if companies like Nokia do the R&D for improving eMBMS, and if other services such as live sports events, have already gone down this route.
At the key moment when broadcasters are looking for a cheaper way of getting to, what by then could be the most common viewer, the Tablet owner, LTE Broadcast may look succulent.
And by then this will not be about a lowly broadcaster deciding what is a good delivery method, but an MNO deciding if it can deliver TV exclusively on the go, purely to its own customers, using video to differentiate between its services and rival MNOs. Thinking about it the other way around is the tail wagging the dog.
That is when MNOs will swoop on broadcasters and buy them for competitive advantage. But that won’t happen while broadcasters are making aggressive statements about how poor LTE is publicly and it won’t happen anyway until LTE broadcast is well understood and widespread and both of these outcomes are 6 or 7 years away.