Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 August 2014

Apple and Samsung stop fighting, notice Chinese creeping up

It would be remiss of us not to at least cover the sad and sorry Apple Samsung saga, now that it is all but over. We’re sure they felt good (the aggressor) and bad (the suit recipient) in equal measure during the campaign, but litigators have to learn from this lesson ‘ you cannot invade an industry full of innovation, and make one or two key changes, and then try to sue everyone that copies you. It just doesn’t work. Although you could argue that Apple has made it work financially, but not through the courts.

Faultline has maintained from day one that while Apple’s look and feel was perhaps copied illegally (not that important given that the UI is different) the features that Apple brought to this market were simple ideas, like using gestures to control applications ‘ and these we would argue can be freely copied and are unpatentable. They are unpatentable in Europe, and with recent changes in the Supreme Court’s handling of many software patents, probably should not have been awarded in the US. They are obvious.

At no stage have the Apple patents been challenged and at some point a Markman hearing was bound to have found that not only did Apple not own half the patents it claimed to own due to prior art, but many of them are not defensible in a court of law. The industry has spent 30 odd years inventing the core technology within handsets and Apple, as far as we can work out, has only ever paid Nokia money for using them. If you trace back touch technology, none of it was patented by Apple and many of the gesture inventions have prior art. What was it that Apple patented anyway, that would have stood the test of time? We thought not much.

The genius of Apple is in two things, in getting AT&T to take the iPhone exclusively, creating a gold rush for the product, when other manufacturers had been sent away with a flea in their ear, being told that ‘touch screens and tablets will not work in the US,’ or ‘if you build that it has to be just for us,’ something companies the size of Nokia (then) and Samsung (now) could never agree to.

Let’s face it everything Apple learned about the mobile market it got from working with Motorola and everything it invented was facilitated by its own software smarts, and that makes it largely copyable as we have found out with Android.

Around $1 billion has been awarded to Apple from Samsung, but only in its home courts, and no current device has been forcibly withdrawn from the market. Apple fundamentally misunderstands what patent law is there for ‘ so inventors get to make money off licensing, not to prevent licensing and control a market.

Now Apple and Samsung plan to withdraw patent litigation except the cases running in the US. We cannot see why Samsung would have agreed to that unless Apple agrees not to sue any more, even in the US. The US suits have to be continued so that Apple can finally get paid its court awards.

However we suspect that Samsung will put up a strong defense and in the end these too will yield far less than Apple wishes.

What has happened here is that two major phone companies took their eye off the ball and focused solely on one another. As a result in china, this has given local players time to get up to speed, in an environment where suing an incumbent is not yet possible and may not be for some years. Samsung figures out last week show that Samsung is losing market share to incumbent players.

Both Apple and Samsung should have spent more time inventing and less time litigating and in the end they will pay for that with market share losses and a loss of their technical lead.

Apple and Samsung will now have to abandon suits in Australia, Japan, South Korea, Germany, Netherlands, the UK, France and Italy. Last week Samsung’s shipment numbers were down for smartphone, as some of its older rivals began to steal market share. Apple is pinning this year’s results on the launch of its next iPhone in September, but it continues to dominate mindshare, for the pure excellence of the design, the strength of its App Store and the belief of developers, even though the world is dominated now by Android devices.

But design excellence is not manufacturing excellence and nor is it differentiation and Apple’s famous margin is always being squeezed in successive quarters and this will continue to happen, in what is once again an homogenous smartphone world, where all devices look much the same.