Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

31 July 2014

MLB wants Comcast TWC merger scrapped

One of the surprise opinions to be presented to the FCC over the merger of Comcast and Time Warner Cable comes from Major League Baseball, which is naturally heartily in favor of net neutrality being retained as a principle.

The opinion filed in response to the Notice of Ruling making that the FCC circulated, and we delivered on July 15th and just discovered this week by US news sources, berates the FCC for planning to offer to meet ISPs halfway by allowing a ‘fast lane’ for some internet edge suppliers.

It says, ‘Fast lanes would serve only one purpose: for Broadband ISPs to receive an economic windfall. American consumers would be worse off as the costs of fast lanes are passed along to them ‘.’

And added, ‘Fast lanes would create new economic barriers for start-up entrepreneurs and innovators that have been critical to the growth of the Internet economy… fast lanes would necessarily mean there are slow lanes, they would amount to “picking winners and losers online,” with Broadband ISPs acting as fast lane “gatekeepers.” It goes on to say that the Comcast TWC combination would have 40% of US broadband by number of lines, but closer to 55% if you only include fast lines.

MLB points out that ISPs enjoy 60% plus margins on tens of billions of dollars in revenue and they have plenty of capital to invest in their systems. MLB then declared that it was the nation’s largest Edge Provider of live event video.

Put quite simply the US has got itself in a mess over broadband and it has a single chance to save itself. In the first instance it has to block the Comcast TWC merger, in the second instance, it has to fill the void left by recent court defeats, either by passing legislation, or by the FCC insisting on no fast lane ISP services, and find a way to get its rulemaking to stick.

Broadband is one of the most profitable businesses in the world, and yet ISPs constantly moan that Over The Top road-hogs such as Netflix, Hulu, YouTube and Amazon, are set to take away much of those excessive profits, due to the simple fact that they offer video services and video services eat bandwidth.

In the rest of the world, successful unbundling has meant that there are plenty of rivals in broadband. This brings down prices, and prevents any single broadband entity offering ‘fast lanes’ which essentially means ‘blocking’ rival services, which keeps network neutrality intact without legislation.

Litigious US operators, backed by judges who are not so much sympathetic, but who are constrained by the wording of a variety of US Acts, have kept the US in the broadband dark ages, strangling competition. It was Verizon that litigated in 2003 when the FCC tried to impose unbundling rules, which included specified pricing, and when the court agreed, that the FCC could not price wholesale for Verizon, the rules fell back to those in the 1996 Telecom Act. Overnight Competitive Local Exchange Carriers died off.

In the rest of the world regulators had been given sufficient power to stave off legal threats, and went about making core networks treat local ISPs the same, whether they were another division of the same company or an outside company, and created internal charging mechanisms that were realistic and that could also double as a wholesale pricing mechanism.

That allows two forms of competition ‘ from other telcos using parts of your own network, as well as other companies using totally different technologies, like cable and FTTH.

The next wrong turn the US took was to take the defeat laying down and the FCC agreed with Verizon and AT&T that they would never have to ‘share’ fiber if it went within 500 feet of a US home, which was taken to mean the wholesale fiber market was dead before the US telcos even laid an inch of fiber. Admittedly AT&T has mostly only brought its fiber to within 5,000 feet of US homes, but the agreed rulemaking has the effect of making it impossible for any alternative supplier to offer broadband to a home that already has fiber to the curb or cabinet. On the other hand Verizon can shut out virtually any challenge in its FTTH homes, giving it exclusive access.

Finally Verizon has sued to get an appeals court to retract the Network Neutrality rule making, the so called Open Internet Order, which the FCC tried to push through. The court said it had over-stepped its powers. That meant either re-framing the rules another way, or using its powers to redefine ISPs as Title II common carriers which have to provide service to the general public without discrimination. The FCC probably does not even know if it has the power to make the internet Title II stick and anyway someone would sue and a court would tell the FCC that it had over-stepped its remit.

The MLB case raises a number of issues. If network neutrality is not upheld, then Major sport can be forced into an auction between broadcasters and pay TV providers to get any kind of a route to market. If some of those same companies can block, slow or in any way make unenjoyable the same content over the internet, then that brings down the price of any such auction. Will Comcast, Verizon and AT&T go to MLB and tell them that, like Netflix, they have to pay for a direct connection to their networks? It is only a matter of time.

And if that prevents one sport from OTT delivery, then it will shortly become the standard way of managing a negotiation with all US sports, making them permanently attached to TV broadcasters and unable to take control of any direct to consumer OTT activity.

All of these stories are part of this week’s Faultline service, and you are invited to request a FREE four week trial to the service by emailing [email protected]