The silly season is an expression used by journalists to convey how little news there is around public holidays and in particular in the heart of August, when most announcements are delayed, because so few people are there to receive them, as many people are on holiday.
One of the things that happens in silly season is that people take an old story and refresh it, better still a story that has not yet run its course and just update it with a tweak.
As this year’s silly season comes towards its end, we have had claims from Bloomberg that the European Commission has more or less agreed the merger between Liberty Global in the Netherlands and cable market leader Ziggo. While in the US we similarly have the large consolidation plays of AT&T and DirecTV, being also seen as ‘more or less done’ in a rumor that began in the reliably inaccurate New York Post, while other sources simply sum up the latest blows fired in the merger of Comcast and Time Warner Cable (TWC).
The New York Post story talks about the $49 billion merger and says that the Justice Department is about to give it the go ahead, according to insiders. As is usual in these cases, the only insiders tend to be wishful thinking members of the two companies, as the guarded Justice Department processes may allow junior individuals (who might be persuaded to go off the record to a newspaper) to make recommendations, but the final decisions are only made at the highest level, where there is a duty of care NOT to leak the information before the merging companies get to know the decision and prepare for it.
Even though at Faultline we have made a point of saying that AT&T buying DirecTV represents far less disruption in the US market than the purchase of TWC by Comcast (which affects concentrations of broadband, pay TV and Telephony), because it really only represents a concentration of interests in pay TV, taking the combined company to around 25.9 million pay TV customers.
There are MANY of the issues surrounding this deal that also surround the Comcast TWC deal ‘ concentration of content buying power, the ability to prefer AT&T or DirecTV video when sent OTT, over the AT&T networks (wired and wireless) ‘ and the use of data caps to manipulate content value ‘ but there is no equivalent of broadband dominance, which is the most worrying aspect of the Comcast TWC deal, not to mention telephony.
A merger gives Comcast TWC 47% of the US broadband market, while its nearest competitor would be AT&T, with just 23.8%. AT&T would continue to have the largest US share of fixed line telephony at 27.7 million lines, but the new Comcast TWC would close the gap., jumping from 11 million to 16 million with the deal.
In pay TV terms they would be neck and neck, with Comcast proposing to get rid of a number of homes to Charter in a complicated swap that would leave it with 27 million, after taking it to over 34 million initially. The AT&T DirecTV merger would be closer to 25.9 million. Since there are almost exactly 100 million US homes subscribing to pay TV, that gives them 27% and 25.9% respectively of the market, with the exception that Comcast would still own a share in the spin-off company (described as Spin Co), effectively giving it even greater market control.
Also it is important to note that the Comcast merger was agreed first and so should be settled BEFORE the AT&T DirecTV can be fully examined. If the Comcast deal goes through, then nothing can stop the AT&T deal, because AT&T could cry ‘foul.’ On the other hand the Comcast deal should be seen as a step too far, and then afterwards, in the light of the deal being blocked, it would be far more difficult for the AT&T deal to obtain public acceptance, appearing as it would to give preference to the old incumbent.
At the lower level within the Justice Department, it is perfectly possible for these deals to be examined without reference to one another, purely on their legal and economic merits, but further up the hierarchy it is impossible to separate the two, and opinions may be canvassed upwards to the very top of both the Justice Department and the FCC, if not beyond.
While the New York Post story cannot be taken seriously, it doesn’t mean that the paper did not get someone important to say that they thought a deal could be worked out. The issue is whether or not that person was sufficiently in the know to understand the full interconnected condition of the two deals.
And in many ways the deal between AT&T and DirecTV can be seen as a way of breaking the Comcast deal. Internally at AT&T the executives may have been saying, ‘we want to do this deal,’ but they may have equally been saying ‘if Comcast can do that deal, then we HAVE to do this deal.’ The dialog may have been even more complex, because they may have said, ‘If we announced a deal to buy DirecTV, then they will look at what happens to the market if BOTH deals are done,’ and if they turn us down, they will have to turn that one down.’ So it is possible that this deal may have been done precisely to bring down the Comcast deal, although that’s not an opinion that the usually precise and thoughtful US press have brought up.
Because the condition of the US market AFTER such a deal will leave 53% of the entire US pay TV market in the hands of two companies and over 70% of the broadband market, along with 38% of fixed phone lines.
The FCC this week seems to be anticipating what has appeared to be a constant flow of localized rhetoric against the Comcast deal, by calling for more information from Comcast. This new requests relate to web traffic management practices and the tools that Comcast uses for that traffic management.
In a letter sent to Comcast the FCC asked, for all documents relating to decisions whether to block, stop, throttle, slow, favor, congest or otherwise hinder the transmission of any online video distributor service or other content, including priorities given to its own competing service. It also sought detailed tables on interconnections with other parts of the internet. This is a little like giving Comcast a rope and asking it to prepare itself for a hanging.
There is a mood in analyst and media coverage in the US, that this deal will happen, but with concessions. But we’d like to remind everyone that around the time of AT&T buying T-Mobile we said that it ‘might’ happen but probably shouldn’t. One of the colleagues that we helped in the US financial markets refused to even voice this idea because, in his words ‘The market has accepted this and anyway these people aren’t stupid, they must have checked out the legality of this deal’.’ But the true position was that AT&T had done no such thing.
In ranking order of how much market distortion each deal would bring, the Liberty Global Ziggo merger in the Netherlands is the most outrageous deal, with the Comcast TWC deal a close second. The AT&T deal is perhaps potentially okay, but AT&T has had too much latitude in prior mergers, getting back to where it is today, for this to be an entirely rational decision.