It was just before IBC in 2011 that Cryptography Research announced that it had managed to get its CryptoFirewall built into the leading set top chips of the time, the ST Micro 7108 and the Broadcom 74XX HD chips. Now it has gone one better on the eve of IBC once again and tells us that it is built into MStar TV chips.
While not many companies openly confess to using the CryptoFirewall to offer both hardware support and a hardware cryptographic engine, buried out of touch of the operating system, in 250,000 gates of a CPU, but Verimatrix was the first company at the time to happily admit it used this as a hardware core, to base its VCAS system on. We have heard that many others have also used it, but they are less forthcoming with the news. It was as if CRI had taken a smart card and put it in a hidden section of the CPU – away from prying eyes and pretty much tamper proof as well (since CRI owns many tamper proofing patents too including DPA countermeasures).
But now anyone who wants hardware based security on a Smart TV, given that MStar along with its parent MediaTek, has about 80% market share in that market, will be able to secure it with CryptoFirewall, as long as the TV manufacturer allows developers access to the chip.
That means that what was once a software only security environment, can be upgraded to a truly secure environment and that is likely going to make it possible for a whole new generation of CRM specialists to operate freely with UHD content on smart TVs, as these chips proliferate. Now just because CRI has this core on the smart TV chips, does not mean that it owns all the security silicon there, just as it didn’t on the set top chips.
Broadcom had implemented systems from NDS and Nagra long before the CRI ASIC core was considered, but the difference is that the CRI core is available to any DRM provider to write too and is not security by obscurity. The NDS and Nagra cores are solely for their software, and there is no open documentation on how to use them.
While UHD content was not mentioned in the release, it is clear from the Movielabs specification for next generation video, that in order to handle UHD content, equipment vendors have to add both hardware based security AND forensic watermarking, and this solves one of those problems. We can see a lot of licensing of watermarking systems happening over the coming months as companies position their offerings for UHD content.
When this was implemented in the set top chips, CRI said that it would charge $1 for each device which turned the capability on, which is a likely indicator of the type of charges that will be associated with this announcement. We would expect Samsung, LG, Sony and Vizio at a minimum to sign up for this over the coming months, whether they do it in secret or openly.
The Chinese TV companies will almost certainly be happy to license this piece of silicon, because it will stop them having to buy into a non-Chinese piece of intellectual property for the DRM itself, and local DRM suppliers will perhaps embrace it both within the Chinese borders and in shipments from Chinese companies. It is also a precursor for any pay TV environment that does not have the clout to push its own silicon core, because simply implementing their system on the CRI core, means they have ported to multiple Smart TVs.
“Increasingly, consumers want the convenience of viewing all their preferred content from their connected TV. To enable this flexibility, connected TVs must work with multiple operators and OTT distributors using different CAS and DRM systems. The CryptoFirewall security core supports this complex requirement in a unique and innovative way,” said Wayne Tsai, Marketing Director, MStar. “The CryptoFirewall security core delivers both strong hardware security and multi-operator flexibility in our next-generation chips and seamlessly integrates with MStar’s TEE environment.”
However the real battle that is set up by the MovieLabs proclamation that all UHD content must be hardware protected, is on the tablet. Most tablet providers and CPU providers want to see how Apple behaves in this market before they show their hand. If Apple builds in its own hardware security environment or licenses something like the CRI block (we think unlikely) then it will lead to a stampede for other tablet makers to provider something similar, and here CRI is up against the Trusted Execution Environment (TEE) being championed by ARM and its partners Giesecke & Devrient and Gemalto who formed the Trustonic joint venture. We have heard conflicting reports about just how secure that environment really is, so could see it losing out to CRI or others in the long term.
However MovieLabs could squander this entire position if UHD video content is allowed on Apple devices with software only protection, or if it fails to set up professional device security audits to grant its approval. More may very likely be heard at IBC on this subject.