An EU report designed to unite broadcasters and mobile operators behind a common strategy for radio spectrum below 800 MHz has been broadly welcomed by the European Broadcasting Union (EBU).
The report effectively split this spectrum in two, the so called 700 MHz band between 694 and 790 MHz and the lower sub 700 MHz band between 470 and 694 MHz. The EBU applauded the report’s recommendation that the sub 700 MHz band be retained for broadcasters until at least 2030, but expressed concern over the suggestion that the 700 MHz band be given over to wireless broadband services in 2020, plus or minus two years.
Yet given recent events and trends elsewhere in the world, where the whole sub 800 MHz band looks like being sacrificed at least partly to mobile operators, the EBU and European broadcasters ought to be pleased with this report, which has clearly been influenced by their strong lobbying. If the EU does accept the report’s findings, then it will oppose any moves to hand over the whole sub 800 MHz band to mobile broadband at the next World Radio Conference (WRC) in 2015.
The EU report was commissioned to end the rancor between broadcasters and mobile operators and develop a common European approach to spectrum until 2030 so that all parties can plan for the foreseeable future. It was chaired by former European Commissioner and WTO Director General Pascal Lamy, concluding that “the EU should adopt a common position against the co-primary allocation of the core audiovisual band (470-694MHz) to the mobile service at WRC 2015”.
Lamy’s proposal is for a formula aimed squarely at reconciling broadcasters’ needs with the EU’s mission to roll out mobile broadband as part of its Digital Agenda for Europe. But the report probably would not have been produced, but for the surprise move at the last World Radio Conference WRC2012 by African and Middle Eastern countries to allocate the 700 MHz band to mobile services in ITU Region 1 with effect from 2015, after this had been reserved exclusively for DTT at the previous WRC2007.
This was designed to match other world regions where the 700 MHz band was already allocated on a shared co-primary basis to mobile services. This band represents an opportunity for globally harmonized spectrum for mobile broadband, offering economies of scale and roaming with any next generation mobile technology (LTE2 and beyond). But the key point was that for current mobile networks to have access to this band, terrestrial broadcasting networks would have to clear it, because the two network types cannot coexist in the same frequency band with today’s technology.
This led to the fear that mobile operators would go on to attack the lower sub 700 MHz band at WRC2015, which for now remains the exclusive preserve of broadcasters in ITU Region 1, the one covering Europe, Middle East and Africa.
This is because mobile operators will need these lower frequencies with their greater range to serve large sparsely populated rural areas cost effectively. For much of Africa and also the Middle East, mobile services are emerging as a major medium for video distribution in the absence of substantial DTT infrastructure and this factor has led to the tension within ITU Region 1. But it now looks like the EU will side with broadcasters in defending any co-allocation of the sub 700 MHz band to mobile services until 2030, so although the EBU may still be bleating about early release of the 700 MHz possibly by as early as 2018, it will be satisfied with the report’s outcome.