Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

4 September 2014

AT&T patent troll, casts jealous eye at DOCSIS, Voice and DVRs

Fe Fi Fo Fum, which is the biggest patent Troll of them all. Well it depends when you are talking about. Apple has been recently, but before Apple began suing Samsung and other phone makers despite owning no patents in cellular, it was Qualcomm who tried to take everyone for a pretty penny over CDMA.

But thinking back AT&T and Verizon have been as bad as anyone, coercing VoIP pioneer Vonage and its shareholders, out of virtually ALL the cash it had in the bank and temporarily halting the assault on its own fixed line customer base.

In fact is was Sprint who began that particular affair suing Vonage in 2005, and Verizon and AT&T repeated the trick in 2007, despite none of them using VoIP themselves. They thought it was clever to discover cheaper ways of offering voice to customers and then NOT use them, and use the patents to prevent anyone else from using them. One patent related to how the VoIP system connected to the billing record of the telcos, which of course should never have been allowed to go unchecked.

Now AT&T is at it again and has put its toe in the water around cable company Cox Communications and how it offers VoIP. It has issued a legal action this week claiming patent infringement on a wide range of patents, some including how Cox treats video and some over how it treats VoIP. It says it has been talking to Cox since 2009 about licensing.

Given that Cox, along with all the other US cable companies, adheres to the technical ambit of CableLabs, it is likely that if one cable operator is found guilty of patent infringement, so will all the others. AT&T wants to prevent the erosion of its fixed line hegemony, by increasing the cost of doing business for the cable operators. The net result would be to increase the cost of fixed lines across the US.

AT&T says that Cox hasn’t even bothered to give it reasons why it should not pay, and so it has resorted to legal action. This time it is unlikely that its legal shenanigans can have any effect on cable taking away AT&T’s voice lines. AT&T had 52.4 million lines in Q2 2009, today, five years later it is down to just 22.55 million, almost 30 million less. And while getting $39 million out of Vonage at the time was almost the nail in its coffin, after three other successful litigations, Cox could pay such a fine out of small change.

AT&T claims Cox violates seven patents one relating to how DVRs resolve potentially conflicting program recording requests and another which lets a single device tune both analog and digital video. We would have thought that the patent defeat at the hands of TiVo would have lessened AT&T’s legal team’s taste for DVR based actions.

Another three of the patents relate to VoIP, but one covers transmission of data using multiple RF channels over modems in the CableLabs DOCSIS 3.0 standard and there lies a hugely controversial step. Can CableLabs really have come up with a technical approach which creates cable’s entire edge in broadband, which is beholden to AT&T for how the technology works?

It is OFDM and QAM, pure and simple, and no-one has successfully made a claim to own either, and QAM is almost certainly out of patent range in terms of how many years it has been around.

If this is the thin end of the wedge in a pending patent war with AT&T, it is likely to find itself in deep trouble and the counter suits will tie it up in court for years and in the end it will not win, because it did not invent any of these ideas.

We will expect Cox to beat AT&T up in the preliminary hearings and eliminate all DVR and DOCSIS patents from the dispute and then perhaps settle for a small amount. We think this may even be a case of the lawyers acting independently of the senior management, just looking to justify their existence.