Leading infrastructure and encoding vendors are all piling into SDV (Software Defined Video) as part of the drive towards IP cloud based virtualized services that are best suited to multiscreen delivery.
Harmonic as one of the leading all round players has stolen the limelight by making a major play at IBC, along with a key appointment to lead the charge, but Envivio and Thomson Video Networks have also made announcements. Meanwhile other major players, notably Cisco, Ericsson, Comcast’s thePlatform and Ooyala (currently being acquired by Telstra), are all major forces in this area.
Harmonic’s claim that its Electra XVM integrated software package, unveiled at NAB in April 2014, is the industry’s first software-based, fully converged, broadcast-ready media processing platform, would be contested with some justification by all these vendors, most certainly Cisco and Ericsson.
These last two can match Harmonic’s all round coverage of the video infrastructure field and have already made significant moves around cloud delivery, such as Ericsson’s Virtualized Encoding launched in March 2014, to utilize multiple encoding resources regardless of platform. This is not confined to Ericsson encoders and just a month later in April Elemental came on board by announcing that its video processing software had been fully integrated into the Ericsson Virtualized Encoding solution. Elemental in turn took pains to emphasize that this conformed with its infrastructure-agnostic approach, working with other key players where appropriate.
This brings us back to Harmonic, which unlike most of the others is not talking about agnosticism, but aiming to deliver all the critical components of virtualized infrastructure itself. It argues that this is because unlike the others it is not just virtualizing the encoding as in the Ericsson solution, but all aspects of media processing, into a single architecture. This it sees as a differentiator, rather than focusing on best of breed, which might inhibit the move to a fully virtualized infrastructure.
It is worth considering here what we are talking about with SDV, which like cloud and virtualization has come along from the enterprise data center world, highlighting broadcasting’s conversion into a branch of IT. It started as SDN (Software Defined Networking), which was at first hailed as a “Cisco killer” because it promised to replace dedicated IP routers and switches with a networking fabric based on commodity hardware from many vendors, at first it was typically ASIC based, but increasingly using generic silicon.
But this ignored the fact that Cisco had long ceased to be a predominantly hardware company and was actually well placed to capitalize on the SDN trend with its IOS operating system and associated software. Certainly Cisco CEO John Chambers has waxed lyrical about the virtues of SDN on numerous recent occasions, citing advantages such as the ability to apply common policy throughout the network as far the edge.
Such policy can include traffic shaping, which under SDN can be accomplished from a central control console without having to interact directly with individual switches. An administrator can change any network switch’s rules on the fly as required, for example prioritizing, de-prioritizing or blocking specific packet types at an application or stream level, with very granular control.
This is particularly advantageous in a cloud network because it allows the traffic loads to be managed flexibly, conferring this mythical agility that vendors so often talk about. It also allows less expensive, commodity switches to be used, with more control over network traffic flow than ever before. All this carries particularly well over to SDV, where the advantages of centralized and automated traffic shaping are especially great, given the amount of bandwidth consumed and strict latency budgets, above all for live broadcasting.
This provides the foundation for higher level workflow functions such as transport stream play-out, caption support, monitoring and scheduling, which Harmonic is virtualizing with its Electra XMV platform. It is also extending the virtualization to contribution at IBC, with the introduction of DSNG (Distributed Satellite News Gathering) contribution encoders that support relevant standards such as DVB-S2X and DVB’s Carrier ID protocols. The latter is an anti-jamming measure which works by providing uplinked signals with an ID, so that unwanted signals can be excluded.
Harmonic has underlined its SDV ambitions by appointing Bart Spriester as senior vice president for video products. Spriester will lead the virtualization drive, having been vice president and general manager for Digital Media Networks, a business unit focused on global service providers and media companies and before that managing director of Cisco’s EMEA Video Division.
Thomson Video Networks (TVN) is also targeting contribution with its as yet unnamed cloud platform for Internet media transmission to be unveiled at IBC. The company will highlight how its ViBE CP6000 contribution platform supports broadcast-quality video transmission over unmanaged networks, including the public Internet.
TVN, which emerged from the wreckage of the French Thomson technology group that also spawned Grass Valley and Technicolor, is aiming both at emerging OTT players and traditional operators with an offering that can blend on-premises and cloud-based resources for traditional live broadcasting over cable, DTH, and DTT, as well as IPTV and OTT, on multiple devices. The company’s own compression portfolio includes products for both premium content and low value long-tail material.
The basis for TVN’s cloud platform is its existing MediaFlex video operating system for the ViBE transcoding range, which now supports virtual machines and cloud-based video processing components. It enables multiple platforms to be used at once, for example combining a group of dedicated on-site TVN products acting as a typical compression headend, with a separate group of virtual machines provisioned in a private data center for rapid deployment of broadcast services on demand. This could be for a one off sporting event. Then further compression services could be deployed in a public cloud infrastructure.
Meanwhile Envivio, which like Elemental has for some time championed software encoding, has co-opted the French word for cloud, Nuage, for its virtualized SDV platform. However another company got there first, California based Nuage Networks, which offers an SDN platform targeted at enterprises. This has been combined with Alcatel-Lucent IP networking technology to create the VSP (Virtualized Services Platform), aimed at smaller Telcos as well as enterprises. It will be confusing if Nuage Networks enters the video arena.
For Envivio, Nuage expands its ambitions beyond multiscreen video encoding into the larger SVN or software-as-a-service arena, bringing it into competition with thePlatform and Ooyala in particular. Envivio’s main pitch is that Nuage is a hybrid solution and reduces costs by avoiding the need for separate integration of support for the many devices, streaming standards and content protection platforms. Nuage supports both live and on-demand premium-quality video, including 4K/UHD.
Nuage is a public cloud product, running over Amazon Web Services (AWS) and so complements Envivio’s existing private cloud services it runs on behalf of major clients. Envivio has yet to name its first public cloud customer, but claims it has a big operator in Europe lined up that is already using a hybrid approach. To date Envivio’s notable customers for multiscreen encoding are in the US, including Comcast and Time Warner Cable.
The big hitters like Ericsson that already have major Telco clients are building on existing virtualized platforms, which have already decoupled network management from the underlying functions. Another term, Network Functions Virtualization (NFV), is sometimes used in the Telco arena to describe this partition between network control and the underlying switching or routing, but amounts to much the same thing. The main difference is that NFV came first and relies on existing data center virtualization techniques to allow network functions to be distributed across commodity servers. SDN is a more recent development and brings some new techniques optimized for high performance networking, with sharper separation between the control plane and the underlying data. Put simply, an NFV deployment could serve as the fabric for SDN, but not the other way round. Ericsson coming from a Telco background is running with NFV for video, while vendors purely on the broadcasting side are pushing SDN.
Currently Ericsson is trialing NFV with Telstra, Australia’s largest Telco, for a virtual home gateway service called Virtual CPE. This enables pay TV as well as broadband services to be delivered without a set top or gateway. The aim is to enable users to have just one subscription for all services and locations, served from the cloud via NFV, although SDN would do exactly the same job. As far as SDV is concerned, the SDN and NFV concepts are essentially interchangeable.