Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

4 September 2014

Video games – part 3; Creating a Netflix for gaming

In the previous two installments of this series, we looked at the evolution of video games from their origins to the present day, before discussing whether cloud gaming could replace gaming hardware in the near future. While the technology for cloud gaming exists today, the biggest roadblock is the quality of the internet connection between cloud server and end device. But in this last installment, we will look at shifts in the future market, before looking at the technologies and products that have not or have only just made it to market.

In the past few years, video gaming has become an increasingly digital-first affair. Evidence of this shift towards digital distribution can be found in a DFC Intelligence report, which found that 92% of PC game sales in 2013 were digital downloads, meaning only 8% were purchased as physical discs. In 2010, NPD estimated that downloads accounted for 48% of PC game sales, and the growth to 92% will be on the back of improvements in internet download speeds as well as the general growth of the online platforms like Steam, EA’s Origin, and smaller outlets such as Good Old Games and GameFly.

This is radically different from consoles, which have yet to embrace a digital distribution platform like Steam largely due to Sony and Microsoft’s complex relationships with the developers that create games for their hardware platforms. On console games, physical sales still dwarf digital downloads at something like a ratio of 80:20 for the flagship titles – with EA saying that “full game downloads” account for only 10-15% of its sales.

And this year, there was something of a quiet revolution in the static gaming market, as PC game sales surpassed console game sales for the first time. This is being attributed to the popularity of freemium and free to play games such as DotA 2 (Defense of the Ancients II) and League of Legends. The level of micro-transactions in these games is enough to support a live video gaming tournament that was broadcast on ESPN. The International is run by Valve, the company behind the Steam platform and DotA 2, and the 2014 event had a total prize pot of $10.93 million, with teams of players competing for the grand prize of $5 million.

An audience of fans watched the contest on Twitch, Amazon’s recent $1 billion purchase, and also on ESPN2 and ESPN3. Valve claims that the event had 20 million unique viewers during the entire playoff process, with a maximum peak viewership of 2 million – not including the 11,000 fans that attended the final in Seattle’s KeyArena. ESPN said “viewing figures exceeded expectations across the board,” and the Xbox was the leading viewing platform (notably a console on which the game cannot be played, but one that is usually hooked up a large TV in the home).

The International was such a success for ESPN that it said it planned to increase its eSports (video game contests competing for cash prizes) in the future. The official line is that the company has not committed to any future coverage, but the Daily Dot cites sources close to the company that contradicts the party line. While ESPN3 is an online service, the ESPN2 coverage of The International comprised a documentary on the cable channel. eSports are on the up, with the New York Times dedicating front page coverage of the International last Sunday.

In that article, the paper cites data from SuperData Research that says 70 million people watch eSports globally, and notes that South Korea (an early adopter of competitive spectator gaming largely thanks to the quality of its broadband infrastructure) has a dedicated TV channel for eSports.

This year’s League of Legends World Championship is on track to sell out a 45,000 seat stadium in Seoul, with last year’s final drawing 32 million unique viewers and a peak concurrent audience of 8.5 million viewers – around four times that of the International.

Activision, the publisher of flagship console title Call of Duty, has also sponsored a $1 million tournament for its first person shooter. Coverage of that was also hosted on ESPN’s online service, but the aforementioned Daily Dot sources suggest that the licensing process was far more complex than coverage of the International.

But these audience figures are a lucrative option for marketers to attack. This shift to mass spectatorship that supplements and sometimes surpasses actual playing is another way in which the video game business model is shifting. Micro-transactions, downloadable content and the advertising revenues all represent the move towards a multi-year consumer/product relationship, with many potential transactions to prolong the product lifecycle as opposed to the old model of a one-off up-front fee.

But the transition from the one-off payment model to one with lower but more frequent transactions has begun to incorporate a monthly subscription flavor. Both Microsoft and Sony have begun charging a monthly fee for their online services, effectively extending their revenue streams by multiple years (potentially) beyond the initial purchase price. Microsoft was charging a monthly fee in the previous generation of consoles, but now EA has become the first non-manufacturer to move into the monthly model on what appears to be an experimental basis.

The ‘EA Access’ subscription has come out of beta on the Xbox One and now offers subscribers unlimited access to ‘The Vault’ of EA titles, which initially includes 4 games with promises of future expansion. It costs $5 per month or $30 a year, and requires users to download the games to the Xbox’s hard drive. The subscription also includes a 10% discount on all EA digital downloads, and up to 5 days’ early access to upcoming titles – effectively allowing subscribers to trial a game before committing to the full purchase price.

And this is because while the 4 launch titles are fairly new, it is extremely unlikely that in these early stages the subscription model will replace the model of buying a game at launch. EA still makes the majority of its revenue on these launch titles, so the two-time winner of the ‘Worst Company in America’ award won’t be shooting itself in the foot to push the subscription model at the expense of its margins.

But the service is very similar to SVoD platforms – essentially a Netflix for games. You pay a lot less than buying the cost of the library, but then enjoy unlimited access to a library of content that lags a little (and occasionally a lot) behind the release cycle– hindered only by the bandwidth and download restrictions of your ISP.

And this model could solve the biggest gripe with DLC – that of feeling like you’re being nickel and dimed after purchasing a $60 game for additional content, which 5 years ago would have been included in the game as standard. Suddenly, DLC purchases for one of these Vault games are comparatively affordable, especially since EA will likely only add games to its Vault after they have gone through the traditional product cycle and been purchased by those willing to pay the sticker price. This means that consumers who wait a year will have access to games at a fraction of their launch price.

Of course, the other flavor of strictly digital distribution is cloud gaming, which renders the game’s content in the cloud and streams it to a player’s device – removing the need for powerful and expensive gaming hardware at the user-end. We looked at this model last week, but it’s worth noting that the answer to EA Access and its Vault on the PlayStation platform is actually a lot more expansive. So while EA currently has no subscription model for the PS4, given the depth of the Sony model, you can appreciate why EA is in no rush to take Sony on.

The service is called PlayStation Now, and costs $9 per month. Additional content can be accessed by additional payments, but Sony promises 100 games including some of its flagship titles. While still in a public beta and currently only available on the PS4, the service will make a library of titles available on the PS4, PS3, PlayStation Vita handheld, Smart TVs, tablets and smartphones – eventually including non-Sony devices.

This subscription is in addition to the PlayStation Plus subscription that is required for the online features of the PS4. A Plus membership costs $50 per year in an annual membership payment, or $54 per year in quarterly installments, or $120 in monthly installments. This model means that over the course of a 6 year product lifetime, Sony could make $300 per user on a PS4 that sells for $400 just for the Plus membership. Adding on the $108 per year that a PlayStation Now membership would add means that every console user who purchases and uses a PS4 for 6 years with both a Now and Plus membership is worth $1,348 to the company (400 + [6×50] + [6×108]). However, numerous teardowns have shown that the BOM of the PS4 comes in at around $381.

This means that Sony makes a small loss on each console after R&D, distribution and advertising are factored in, so we should ignore the $400 figure and instead focus on the subscription revenues. This means that for every gamer Sony can entice into the Now platform for the entire 6 year product lifecycle it is worth $948 – revenues that simply didn’t exist on earlier generations of consoles.

The $948 figure also doesn’t include the revenue generated by the sales of additional Sony hardware (controllers, webcams, keyboards, remote controls) or the cut that Sony will receive from the sales of games on its platform. Essentially, this time around, because the loss incurred on selling each console is negligible now and likely to fall, Sony will be making profits as soon as the buyer subscribes to one of its services or begins buying its games.

Cumulatively, the maximum potential worth of each 6-year gamer to Sony under this subscription method is likely north of $1,200. Back-of-the-napkin calculations of a conservative estimate of a $700-per-console 6-year worth, using the 10 million units sold so far, gives a total revenue of $7 billion, or $1.16 billion annually on average. If the sales replicate those of the PS3 (80 million), that figure climbs to $56 billion, or $9.3 billion per year over the 6 year period.

To put this in perspective, Sony’s 2013 annual report listed gaming sales as $6.7 billion and operating income of $16 million. This was at the end of the PS3’s lifecycle, and really before the PS4’s, but in a subscription based model, there’s no reason for the revenues to tail off near the end of the lifecycle – because in a hardware agnostic platform, there is no end of lifecycle.

Ben Cousins, in a report and presentation given at GDC 2012 called ‘When the Consoles Die, What Comes Next?’, estimates that Sony lost $4 billion on the PS3 platform, with Microsoft losing around $3 billion on the Xbox 360. Cousins said this was due to selling the consoles at substantial losses ($300 per PS3 thanks to the high cost of the Cell processor and associated chips) but this time around, thanks to the simpler design (which some still criticize as being underpowered) both consoles will probably not incur any significant loss per console sold. This means the subscription models are exponentially much more lucrative.

Which is important for an industry in which major players have seen their share price plummet in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis. As pointed out by Cousins, between 2008-2012, while the NASDAQ’s total worth rose 25%, EA lost 61.77% of its share price by, Activision was down 33.34%, Sony lost 46.42%, and Nintendo lost 71.28% – with the global gaming retail industry sales dropping 20% of its value in that time.

Cousins summed it up by saying the Old World of gaming is “large but shrinking fast,” with investors not showing confidence in large traditional publishers, Sony and Microsoft showing losses on their console divisions over the past decade, Nintendo in disarray, retail sales dropping year on year since 2009. The traditional gaming sector is losing out to the rise of mobile, which was deftly illustrated when Cousins observed that Call of Duty: Black Ops, the biggest selling console and PC game at the time had sold 25 million copies, while Angry Birds had been downloaded 500 million times.

So moving to a subscription model could provide a lifeline for an industry that operates at much lower volumes than mobile. This is of course the best-case scenario, as it remains to be seen what percentage of users opt for the subscription model, given that in the current pricing scheme a Now and a Plus membership would cost around $14 a month. Without the Now subscription, Sony has still squeezed an additional $300 over six years for the Plus membership that it wouldn’t have seen with the PS3, and if Sony were able to make its library completely screen agnostic, it wouldn’t have to add in the hardware costs – further improving its margins, especially if it can successfully market the benefit to the consumer’s wallet made by not having to spend $400 on a console.

And while freemium mobile gaming’s rise has been swift, dwarfing traditional static gaming, there are signs that this Wild West of flagrant copyright infringement and underhand (and some might say anti-consumer) practices will shortly be more tightly regulated. Both Apple and Amazon have been successfully sued by parents for purchases made by their children in-game, and are adapting their app store rules to prevent further litigation.

And speaking of children, there are also moves towards dedicated consoles and platforms aimed at children. There’s the LeapFrog LeapTV, which is an Android console with a locked down ecosystem geared directly at the children of parents who want to ensure no unauthorized payments and downloads can be made – and want to avoid the major consoles for those very reasons.

Then there’s the approach taken by the Skylanders franchise, owned by Activision, which has taken the decision to include an iOS and Android release of the latest ‘Skylanders Trap Team’ title at the same time as the console releases. Skylanders is a hugely popular game among children, with sales since 2011 of $2 billion, mostly due to its tactic of selling physical toy action figures that can be added to the video game – allowing kids to play as their favorite Skylanders character once they plug the toy into the Portal of Power NFC adapter that is bundled into the game. Total cost of ownership: 1 full price game ($60), as many action figures as your children can squeeze out of you ($10-17 each, 175 to collect), and 1 Portal of Power, with a Bluetooth controller for the mobile versions. Thankfully you get something of a discount when you buy the $75 starter pack.

So the LeapFrog approach could be adopted to divert revenue associated with children from the major consoles, and at least one major games franchise has now opted to treat tablets as equals to consoles and PCs,

Virtual reality is also raising its head again, as Facebook’s $2 billion acquisition of Oculus VR creeps ever closer to realizing a photorealistic virtual reality experience that could be plugged into static gaming platforms. In partnership with Oculus, Samsung has just released its Gear VR headset, which is essentially a headband with buttons, which holds the Galaxy Note 4 in front of a user’s eye to replicate the experience provided by systems like Oculus’ Rift. This approach could easily be applied to other smartphones and is perhaps more exciting than its static equivalents, because it could be used outdoors – in environments potentially mapped by a technology like Google’s Project Tango. You only need to imagine an Augmented Reality laser-tag experience to get a little excited about hardware like the Gear VR.

We’ve covered both the Rift and the Gear VR in previous editions of Faultline, and with technologies such as Leap Motion – a hand and object tracking system that eliminates the jarring disconnect experienced by having to use a controller to interact with a VR world – we are not very far away from a stunningly immersive VR experience, that thanks to the power of cloud computing, could be easily playable on a smartphone.

Which explains why large companies are moving into the gaming industry. The aforementioned Facebook buy augmented its already massive browser gaming ecosystem, although it’s unlikely that we’ll ever see a Farmville VR release. Amazon bought into Twitch for just shy of $1 billion, and released a net top Fire TV with a heavy gaming focus and a dedicated development studio to support it.

So ultimately, gaming seems destined to become a hardware agnostic experience, with many separate and distinct elements that are divided more by the genre of game than by the platform on which they are played. That is to say, gaming is only a few steps away from becoming a universal experience that can be enjoyed and monetized on any platform and hardware. This ubiquity presents great synergies and savings for developers, publishers and advertisers, as well as a market full of products that can be sold to the emerging, and frankly massive, volume of mobile gamers looking for an ever-increasingly exciting experience.