Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 September 2014

Party may be over for DTH as cloud descends

Satellite has been the most successful TV sector over the last decade with Sky gaining ground consistently in the UK, Germany and Italy, while DirecTV has been rampant in Latin America and consolidated its number two position to Comcast in its domestic US market. But the next decade or even five years are going to be far more challenging for the sector, with the partial exception of developing regions where broadband coverage is patchy.

This sets the scene, for it is the maturation of fixed broadband and in future mobile too that is throwing down the gauntlet to satellite, allied with the growing stampede towards the cloud for video processing, storage and UI rendering.

Satellite operators might intone that they have the biggest cloud of them all, but this is a bit of a joke given that is a one way cloud requiring integration with the terrestrial Internet to enable network PVR and interactive services. The whole point about the cloud movement is that it virtualizes functions previously executed in a gateway or set top box so that services can be extended to multiple screens, while being capable of turning on and upgrading much more quickly and affordably.

DTH operators therefore face the dilemma of whether, and if so how quickly, they migrate their primary pay TV package to the cloud. We have one or two early signs of that, with Sun TV Network, owner of India’s largest TV network, in October 2013 announcing a partnership with OTT infrastructure provider Cloudio TV to migrate its satellite subscribers in Europe and the Middle East to the latter’s cloud platform. Cloudio TV now delivers Sun TV’s linear channels to European subscribers, primarily people of Indian or Tamil descent, and is also developing network based VoD services.

Sun TV is more of a broadcaster than satellite operator not committed to any medium and the likes of Sky or DirecTV have no plans yet to move away from DTH for primary services. But they do all now have OTT offerings to combat Netflix and other pure play online operators and here they are running into some issues over quality.

In the UK for example it is not rare to encounter users on chat forums disgruntled with the quality of service for Now TV when accessing HD content via a third party broadband service such as Virgin Media or BT. This is despite the fact that the headline bit rate is usually far more than adequate for HD and Sky cannot blame these other broadband providers for discriminating against its traffic. The problem must either lie with the connection between Sky’s network and the ISPs or interaction between them. This issue is likely to diminish as bandwidth continues to increase and OTT streaming delivery advances, but does highlight the need for satellite operators to establish a strong position in broadband in order to have end to end control over IP delivery. In the US DirecTV’s position will be improved if its merger with AT&T does go ahead, but the latter has only about 20% of the country’s broadband market with just 16.5 million subs, second to the leading MSO Comcast on 21 million. In the UK Sky is in a similar position with again only 20% of the 20 million strong broadband market, while BT is the leader with over 30%.

Cable companies are in a much stronger position on the cloud front because they have a coherent IP migration strategy now increasingly centered on the RDK (Reference Design Kit) originated by Comcast to commoditize common software functions in the set top or gateway. MSOs can run traditional broadcast alongside IP video over DOCSIS over their HFC infrastructures, gradually migrating channels to the latter and deploying cloud DVR at the same time.

It is partly for this reason that the relative prospects for MSOs against DTH operators are better than they have been. In recent years MSOs have been lagging behind in developing markets especially where they have often been hampered by relatively poor and low capacity analog networks while satellite competitors have been flying with all-digital, scoring with ubiquitous coverage and often superior content. In Latin America this has been the case for DirecTV with its World Cup rights helping gain ground, but more particularly its marketing and coverage, now totaling over 18 million subs across the whole region, making it by some distance the largest operator in the region. DirecTV has profited there through a general under penetration of pay TV, especially in Brazil, along with an expanding middle class.

DirecTV’s Latin American operations comprise Sky Brasil, of which it owns 93%, Sky Mexico where it has a minority 41% (the rest held by Televisa) and PanAmericana, which it owns totally, covering other countries including Venezuela, Argentina, Chile, Colombia and Puerto Rico. Its compound growth rate across Latin America has been running at around 25%, but is now slowing fast as a number of countries including Brazil run into economic problems. The company has revised downwards its growth forecasts there.

One factor telling against satellite in developing markets, especially densely populated areas, is the maturation of cable.  As a result growth in cable services is likely to match that of satellite in India over the next few years, on the back of overall pay TV expansion. According to a report just published by the Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) and compiled by PricewaterhouseCoopers, India had about 129 million TV-owning households (60% of the population) in December 2013, of which 64 million were analog cable TV subscribers, 30 million digital cable and 35 million DTH subscribers. The CII report predicts that by 2017 the DTH number will be 56 million, rising to 64 million by the end of 2018. Cable digital subscriber numbers will rise to 85 million in 2017 and on to 90 million during 2018, while analogue cable will slump to 5 million by that time 2018 as digitization continues. So while satellite looks set to gain on cable as a whole it will actually lose ground to digital, which is forecast to triple over the period.

Back in the developed markets, DTH operators face competition not just from a revitalized cable sector, but also the increasingly competitive OTT lobby led by Netflix, Google with Chromecast, Android TV and YouTube, Amazon with Instant Video and Fire TV, while there are strong contenders locally. DTH operators will have to compete with these OTT players on three fronts. Firstly the pure play OTT players are offering very competitive deals and satellite operators have had to respond with TV Everywhere offerings like Now TV in the UK, getting content rights for those platforms and risking undercutting their primary DTH service.

At least, to-date, satellite operators have held the big trump card of live sporting rights so that competition has been largely confined to movies and TV shows. But as these OTT services scale up and derive increasing revenues, there is the prospect or even likelihood that Netflix, Google and others will start bidding for rights with Sky and others. So far such activity has largely been confined to local Telcos, such as BT and Orange bidding for sports rights. But there is every reason to expect the global OTT players to start bidding for rights in selected markets and then the gloves will be off, opening a second competitive front.

The third front is original non-live TV content where Netflix is already competing with the House of Cards and other shows, as is Amazon, while Google has just announced an initiative to help retain leading content creators on YouTube to stop them defecting to erstwhile rivals such as Facebook.

Satellite operators have likewise been investing in original content to compete and ensure that they will derive revenues from third party distribution as well. DirecTV recently expanded its content lineup to include a comedy with 10 episodes of Things You Shouldn’t Say Past Midnight, while buying US rights for the BBC’s comedy Uncle. The intensifying battle over content is good news for program makers, but is tightening the screws on DTH operators. The upshot is that these operators are going have to play as hard as they have been just to stand still and retain their existing subs bases. And this is even without considering the upheavals they will have to undergo if all broadcasting does move to the cloud.