A few weeks back we took issue with a report that said that traditional Conditional Access would become a shrinking market, suggesting that there were so many new screens and video in the cloud, across a plethora of device types that the increase in complexity and the number of network instances which require decryption, that we argued the instead, the CA market was about to flower and change, not subside.
We earned a few plaudits for saying so from customers and almost immediately to order we saw that Verimatrix launched a new unified version of its VCAS system, and at IBC more or less all of the DRM and CA specialists, with the exception of NDS, buried as it is within Cisco, all made announcements to address this complexity.
A little like multiscreen encoding and packaging, the trend a few years ago was to get a system that worked even if it meant a parallel stream from existing pay TV. And the trend now, in CA as well, is to put it all back into a single box, and tidy up some of that complexity. But there are other trends. More and more of this needs to be done in the cloud, and so that’s where the protection needs to reside. Also there are two major types of devices; – those which are controlled entirely by operators and those which have their own definition, think all Apple products; where security is something that has to be downloaded and installed with a software only base.
Right now there is also the Movielabs insistence that nothing will go to 4K without the security having hardware underpinnings.
Nagravision at IBC was no different, dubbing its new system anyCast, but this is not so much a single system for all situations, more a clarification in its marketing about what system is right for which type of customer.
We spoke to Chris Schouten, Director of Product Marketing for Pay TV at Nagra, “There are different types of services, some low value, and we are seeing more and more FTA networks insisting on encryption, all the way up to 4K. So there is no more one size fits all and our new AnyCast product line is an umbrella brand, a series of products where you can take into account a specific risk profile.”
AnyCast Enable is a software client, but one that can be secured with Nagra on a Chip (NOC), which he says is now “available on a System on a chip from 12 different silicon vendors. NOC secures the root of trust, not just a key ladder, but the CAS itself is in software above that. Two way environments also have the benefit of random frequent authentications where only a single instance will be supported by one key, so they are inherently easier to secure.
“We have introduced AnyCast Protect for embedded content protection for medium-value services, again using NOC hardware either on smart cards or SoCs, and this will come out at the end of 2014.”
The next level is AnyCast Guard and this is based entirely on a smart card, and is for use when content goes through 100% Nagra end to end, and there are no generic off the shelf chips involved.
AnyCast Command is perhaps the newest idea designed to prevent control word sharing in older devices. We know that control word sharing happened because some older devices have the control word in the clear. Nagra has moved all control word processing inside its own Smart cards, in Schouten’s words, “in this version we are certain that the control word is never in the clear because we use a new type of smartcard where the entire transport stream passes through the smartcard, so this will work with legacy based systems.”
This helps its existing customer retrofit systems that will be capable of handling 4K streams, without danger to the content and is the version being launched next year with Dish Networks and EchoStar in the US.
“In the SoC and Smart card versions, we want the ability to have one party take responsibility for the security – Nagra, not multiple parties, and that means faster integration for set top designers.” Effectively this approach requires almost no integration, and eventually Schouten sees the smart card simply designed into the Motherboard of the device as a companion chip and later that same logic put into the SoC.
“Forensic watermarking will be added on the server side, and multicast and unicast solutions are also coming,” said Schouten.
We asked how Apple devices might one day be allowed to join in the 4K protection world, given that when HD came along, Hollywood simply relaxed its specifications to fit the iPad in. “We believe Apple will let operators gain access to its Fairplay DRM, which is secured on its hardware, and we have already seen other platform based security systems such as Playready and Widevine enabled in this way.”
We shall have to see just who Nagra partners with for forensic water marking, but if it has tighter control of the encrypted stream and it is only manipulated on its own Silicon, then it can design whatever it needs to work with a watermarking partner, such as Civolution, again without troubling the set top maker too much.