Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 September 2014

Huawei needs to put meat on the bones of its skeletal video plans

Huawei this week made an exceptionally weak announcement about a converged video product line which said almost nothing. Reading between the lines it was supposed to say, “That Ericsson announcement about MediaFirst last week is nothing, anything they can do Huawei can do too.”

We already dismissed the Ericsson announcements as mostly vapourware, not yet ready, while other companies are currently installing systems. The truth is that right now all the major suppliers want to talk about 4K, but really cannot deliver it, they all want to speak about modern UIs and recommendation systems, and of course multiscreen and TV Everywhere. But the lack of details just leaves us to guess what they have really launched.

What everyone has done initially is create one path to take high quality content to a set top and a parallel one to take it to multiscreen. The second uses ABR systems, supports all the popular ABR protocols and both systems can have an element of cloud. But that’s where the claims end. The devil, as always, is in the details, and we have requested some from Huawei and from Ericsson, but holding your breath on that front would appear suicidal.

The Ericsson system is supposed to be a multiscreen system, presumably based on its Azuki purchase, which is somehow integrated with Mediaroom. The Huawei system must therefore be assumed to be a multiscreen system that is now also integrated with its IPTV system, which is installed in parts of China and the Far East, but about which we have very little detail.

At least the Ericsson system cites some partners, iWedia for UI and Azuki it has acquired and a few new cloud businesses to throw into the heap (see last week’s issue).

The truth is that neither Huawei or Ericsson can allow anyone else into their mobile heartlands and want to cover all bases, but like so many large businesses, their products are partly products and partly “certainly mister customer, whatever you want, we can build it,” so it is ill-defined.

Here is the issue in a nutshell, if people are watching more and more video on phones, and these two provide the systems that speak to phones, then they had better provide the systems which drive the sources of video. That means that someone has to come up with a system that offers, as Huawei says in its release this week, video@home, video@move and video@enterprise, or to put it in plain English, video over a managed network, video over unmanaged networks, video over LTE Broadcast, and video over both LTE and WiFi, both in the workplace and on broader WiFi systems. And it is claiming here is a single cloud based source of infrastructure that can feed them all, and supply services to them all from the cloud, such as video recommendations.

As far as we can see this just needs cloud encoding, cloud based management and reporting tools, as well as measurement and monitoring that works in the cloud, and which, especially in un-managed networks, gives an understanding of the Quality of Experience that the customer is getting. It also means just in time packaging in the cloud, and that requires some design focus around the CDN – it should have a way of supporting multiple protocols and multiple screen resolutions from somewhere close to the access network.

If anything, Huawei is currently trusted more by its customers, in dealing with video, than Ericsson, which is why Ericsson had to take a gamble and purchase Mediaroom, to gain more credibility and a modicum of market share in video delivery. One of our readers came back to us last week and said that we had drank the Kool aid from Alcatel, and then suggested that its cloud delivery systems for video was held together with string, while Faultline had said it was a global leader. The two statements don’t have to be at odds, and both can be true, perhaps Alcatel’s solution is not hugely integrated, but it is a set of point products that have market share and are installed. Cisco can also claim to have this to some extent, but Ericsson has very few pay TV installations on its own accounts and has acquired the rest from Mediaroom and in those Mediaroom accounts, the clock is ticking, in that the operators want to get onto a more modern, integrated cloud system during 2015, not later.

Huawei called its system its IP Video Solution 2.0 and said it supports OTT content, and digital video broadcasting over cable, satellite or terrestrial and is multiscreen, and works on both fixed and mobile. Huawei did refer to service quality management tools that analyse big data, but surely if it had these, it would explain them, and take the confidence that this would give. Instead it is a throwaway line in a catch all press statement.

One concern it talked about is that five times as much content was being consumed over 4G LTE networks as 3G. Video traffic volume on LTE networks grew by seven percentage points to 52% during the past 12 months, it says.

Huawei said it has been working with a range of operators on LTE broadcast networks, including a trial of the technology with EE for the Commonwealth Games in Glasgow and a demonstration during the Kieler Woche boating event in Germany with Vodafone.

Huawei claims it supports a single convergent platform that it also supports multiscreen, from either the cellular network or home WiFi, and that it has open APIs and an SDK to help operators build an open eco-system.

Saying that it can also handle 4K, does not solve the issue of how access networks cope with 4K, all Huawei is saying is that when that happens, its systems will be able to cope.

But one area of mystery to us is that Huawei talks about facilitating collaboration in OTT in the Business to Business model. There are so many thing that this “might” mean that we hesitate to make a stab at it.

Huawei claims it is the global market leader for IP Video solutions, with over 54 commercial deployments worldwide, supporting 40 million subscribers. The trouble is that most of those subscribers are in countries where quality TV is either new or still has not arrived and it has yet to supply video into a US or European operator, and while it has a way of managing to land deals in the cellular space, taking on the video eco-system, as Ericsson has found to its cost, is a far more long winded affair, with less guarantee of success.

Our take is that this is a “me too,” statement and that it will be a while before Huawei has a US or European video reference account.

Meanwhile ZTE, which is one of the home grown thorns in Huawei’s side, has just signed a partnership with Entone, the US Cloud TV and set top maker that has a number of US clients. ZTE makes a similar claim to Huawei that it is the global market leader and has 50 worldwide deployments and a user base of over 20 million subscribers. Quite clearly it is some way behind Huawei and also behind Ericsson, but it is learning fast.

It must be said that we have heard some horror stories about ZTE in the TV market, which suggest that it is not yet a rival to these larger firms. But Entone is as smart as they come, and with a significant market share among US incumbent telcos it might add the kind of know-how that ZTE is lacking.

The two this week announced the integration of Entone’s hybrid devices with ZTE’s IPTV platform so that ZTE partners can launch OTT services, taking it towards a Cloud play. Entone might be ripe for acquisition if it brings enough of the solution to ZTE.

The combined ZTE and Entone platform will enable operators to offer the next generation of advanced hybrid IPTV services that combine live TV, cloud-based (OTT) services, video-on-demand (VOD), whole-home DVR, and multi-screen applications, i.e. the same function that the others are talking about.