Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 October 2014

EU inquiry into Apple’s Irish tax arrangement, another blow to Cook

The politically and ethically charged topic of tax avoidance has raised its head again in the tech world, as the European Commission is set to accuse Apple of receiving “illegal state aid” in the form of Irish capital allowances from Ireland’s government over the past three decades. The EU has now launched a formal investigation into Apple’s international offices in Cork in 1980, where it continues to employ 4,000 staff.

Apple is not alone in seeking Ireland’s comparatively low corporation tax rate of 12.5%. Many large US firms have opted for headquarters in the Emerald Isle, including Amazon, Facebook, PayPal and Twitter. These firms choose Ireland to avoid paying a larger proportion of their earnings in tax to the US government – which currently claims that $124 billion on US treasury debt is collectively held overseas by Apple, Cisco, Google, HP, and Microsoft.

But the EC’s latest charge stems from the fact that according to a US Senate investigation last year, Apple is only actually paying 2% tax – a rather cozy deal that has apparently been approved wholeheartedly by the Irish government, and has now drawn the charge of “receiving illegal state aid” from the EC, due to the anticompetitive arrangement and its tax evasion implications.

The US investigation found that the Irish Apple core businesses (comprised of 3 subsidiaries) could hold 60% of Apple’s profits – which would present a lucrative source of tax revenue for both the EU and the US. If the EC can prove that the arrangement is illegal, the EU is set to pursue back payments of billions of dollars in unpaid taxes from the last decade at least. According to the US Senate’s Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, Apple’s Irish operation earned $22 billion in revenue in 2011 but only paid $10 million in taxes to the US.

“The facts are abundantly clear: Apple developed its crown jewels – lucrative intellectual property – in the US, used a tax loophole to shift the profits generated by that IP offshore to avoid paying US taxes, then boosted its profits through a sweetheart deal with the Irish government,” said Senator Carl Levin chair of the subcommittee.

According to the EC’s competition commissioner, Joaquin Almunia, “in the current context of tight public budgets, it is particularly important that large multinationals pay their fair share of taxes. Under the EU’s state aid rules, national authorities cannot take measures allowing certain companies to pay less tax than they should if the tax rules of the member state were applied in a fair and non-discriminatory way.”

Both Apple and the Irish government evidently have some explaining to do. While Apple will be busy funneling its profits into Ireland to pay the lower tax rate, the Irish government will have to show that it did not provide preferential treatment to Apple – otherwise it will be violating the anti-competition rules.

And that would be bad news for Apple – which would see the EU claim the taxes owed, to the tune of the amended payments for the duration of the period concerned, i.e. billions of dollars.

Not that Apple can’t afford a few billion dollars in fines. The company recently returned $8 billion in dividends in Q3, and listed its total assets at $222.5 billion, with nearly $13 billion in cash and $68 billion in current assets versus its current liabilities of $46 billion and total liabilities of $101 billion.

But the news will certainly hit Apple’s stock price. The company has not had a good few weeks, after the much-overhyped iPhone bending saga, and then the bungled launch of the bug-plagued iOS 8 with its radio-killing 8.0.1 patch. Conspiracy theorists also point to CEO Tim Cook’s offloading of $35m in shares before the launch as proof that Apple knew about the problems ahead of time and yet continued with the plan – much like the Apple Maps fiasco at the launch of iOS 7.

But this zero-day trend of problems seems to have been the cornerstone of Cook’s reign as CEO, and without a full audit it’s hard to say whether it’s his fault or not. The traditional Steve Jobs narrative that might explain the change is that Apple staff were too terrified to slip up and release a shoddy product, or that Jobs himself was too attentive to detail to release a product that didn’t affirm Apple’s premium aesthetic and self-affirmed reputation.

And without a thorough insider’s perspective, from the outside at least, it appears that Cook has let the brand image slip a little. While #BendGate was certainly not the fault of Apple, which has so far reported only 9 bent iPhones returned to them, the buggy iOS releases can be squarely aimed at the company’s quality control division. Heads should roll if a much-vaunted and signature app (Health) doesn’t work at launch, so we must ask whether it will be Cook’s that leaves the building at the behest and pressure of shareholders.

This was meant to be Cook’s first big product launch since he took the reins in Job’s wake. While the iOS 7 launch can’t be pinned on his shoulders, the new iOS 8 one certainly can. These could be a rocky few weeks for Cook at the Apple helm.