Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 October 2014

Nielsen Adobe alliance tries to preserve TV audience measurement

The recently announced alliance between Nielsen and Adobe has great long term significance in setting the broadcasting industry on track towards a more accurate and scientific way of measuring TV audiences as video delivery migrates to all-IP infrastructures.

For now the alliance will accelerate adoption of a digital ratings currency, allowing advertisers to allocate marketing budgets more effectively across device platforms, while enabling media companies to benefit from insights into the performance of TV and other digital content across multiple screens. This itself is a huge step forward, since it means desktop, laptops, tablets, smartphones, gaming consoles, and OTT boxes will now be incorporated into Nielsen’s ratings. It also means that Netflix, Hulu, Amazon Prime, HBO Go, and for that matter YouTube will at last be accurately incorporated into the world’s leading TV ratings system.

In the longer term this ratings currency is likely to extend to all broadcast TV and replace the current antiquated combination of panels and crude in-home measurement devices. Currently Nielsen, along with some other lesser ratings agencies around the world, measures TV audiences using a rather ill-fitting combination of three clunky methods. The principle one is the long standing panel in which a sample of people are asked to self-record their viewing habits in a diary and send them to Nielsen for data quality control and then aggregation.

This data is then adjusted and expanded through integration with data from so called set meters, which are small devices connected to set tops or home TV sets to record viewing habits, transmitted nightly through a “Home Unit” usually over a land line. The third source of data are “people meters,” also connected to set tops or TVs, to record and transmit a single person’s viewing habits once that individual logs in. The latter is designed to sift crude household data into separate demographic groups, but has had limited success to date, largely because it relies on users actively participating, which in turn leads to bias.

The system still relies largely on the statistical power and validity of self-reporting within a panel, which studies have been shown to be unreliable in a wide range of contexts ranging from how people vote, to choices of consumer product, or even levels of sexual activity. Choice of TV viewing might seem quite innocuous, but is still subject to self-reporting bias. Yet TV ratings are crucial for the industry, helping broadcasters determine which shows to renew for another season and which to drop, as well as setting the prices advertisers pay for spot ads. In the US especially Nielsen’s ratings provide the foundation for the whole business model around TV advertising and much the same holds elsewhere.

Against this background a system moving towards the digital measurement already widely used on the web, yielding far more accurate and precise metrics on usage, must be welcomed. For TV such metrics will be refined and aggregated to produce data that can be used as trading currency around viewing and this is where the Nielsen/Adobe alliance comes in.

Nielsen’s digital audience measurement products are now being integrated with Adobe Analytics and Adobe Primetime. The companies will then jointly market the service under the rather cumbersome brand name brand “Nielsen Digital Content Ratings, Powered by Adobe”, delivering analytics and content metrics designed as a trading currency.

Adobe might sound a surprising partner for Nielsen as it has been a declining force in streaming media, with its once all-conquering Flash gradually being replaced by HTML5 among its leading customers like YouTube. But Adobe has become a major player in analytics and while Primetime may not be its best known product it is used by the likes of CBS, Major League Baseball, NBC, Comcast, Shaw and Bell Media in Canada as their platform for online TV delivery and monetization. Nielsen’s measurement data will be embedded in Adobe Primetime to enable broadcasters and pay TV operators to measure audiences and viewing behaviors across multiscreen devices in near real time.

Nielsen was also attracted by the availability of the Adobe Marketing Cloud as a way for brands to exploit its audience data to optimize marketing campaigns.

At the same time Adobe Analytics customers will be able to activate Nielsen’s insights and link their own analytics data to generally recognized currency-quality metrics to target specific audiences. The integration could also open the way for more effective trading of personalized ads.

The two companies have mustered a bunch of well-known media companies, broadcasters and advertisers to pioneer to use of the “Nielsen Digital Content Ratings, Powered by Adobe”, starting in 2015. These include ESPN, IPG Mediabrands, Sony Pictures Television, Starcom MediaVest Group, Turner Broadcasting, Univision Communications and Viacom.

ESPN’s Senior Vice President Global Research and Analytics ESPN highlighted the challenge of integrating specific online device data with traditional summarized audience measurement. He hoped that Adobe and Nielsen together would help resolve the current “lack of alignment between site analytics and syndicated measurement data”. For Starcom in a similar vein the attraction was to measure total TV viewing across digital platforms.

For Sony Pictures on the other hand, the main draw was the potential to show advertising customers their true ROI (Return On Investment) from multiscreen campaigns.

Meanwhile Howard Shimmel, Chief Research Officer at Turner Broadcasting, hoped the alliance would accelerate development and adoption of a single digital currency, which would become increasingly necessary. This is because tablets and other devices are accounting for a rising proportion of primary TV viewing, creating a need for a ratings system that gives content viewed through even a smartphone much greater recognition, even if it does not carry the same weight as a large UHD flat panel on the wall. It should be possible for individual operators to adjust viewer ratings in recognition that although all devices should be counted they are not all quite equal.

An interesting question will be whether the new ratings system will lead to reassessment of viewing patterns. There is after all a historical precedent for this involving Nielsen itself. Until 1991 in the US, sales of vinyl records and CDs were tracked by the music industry trade magazine Billboard merely by calling stores and asking them. But then Nielsen SoundScan began tracking sales data using computers. This revealed that genres previously regarded as marginal, such as alternative rock and hip-hop, had much higher sales than had been indicated by the ad hoc polling of stores. The shift altered the Top 40 radio lists and was a significant boost to relevant artists like Nirvana, Garth Brooks, and Metallica.

Nielsen’s move is also timely as it has come in the same month that Time Warner’s HBO and broadcaster CBS announced their plans to launch standalone OTT packages for watching their programming without a cable or satellite subscription. It was also hot on the heels of the purchase of Civolution’s audio watermarking division by audience measurement firm Kantar Media, which is both a rival and partner of Nielsen. This gives it a leg up in another emerging aspect of audience measurement around second screen activity.

Nielsen itself is already in that game to an extent through its relationship with Facebook announced in July 2014. This enables Nielsen to track data from mobile devices that have downloaded the Facebook app, although only on an aggregated basis and not linked to a particular Facebook account.

Nielsen is also facing competition in online TV measurement from other rivals such as TRA, Rentrak, Tivo and comScore, but its partnership with Adobe signals its intent to maintain its dominant position in TV audience measurement in the IP era.