Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 November 2014

Obama plays Bogey man and outlines stark idealistic Neutrality

When an  unpopular US president, in his second term loses the senate and Congress to the opposition, he is referred to as a lame duck. When Lame Duck presidents make speeches on complex issues like Net Neutrality, they are assumed to be “going through the motions” and while everyone is polite, they know it is safe to largely ignore them.

So the surprising and passionate statement on this subject has people confused, and we estimate that this is, by and large, its intention.

It was one of those “read my lips” moment that US politics is famous for, so we all need to clearly understand the two worlds that are possible going forwards and then perhaps look again at Obama’s words and try to re-interpret them. Because Net Neutrality (NN) is a poisoned chalice.

Already the share prices of Comcast and all the US MSOs have fallen dramatically, interpreting this onslaught as creating an backdrop against which the Comcast Time Warner Cable merger is impossible as well as putting a dampener on MSO future profitability.

Scenario A) The FCC fails to nail down a hard, working definition for NN and the Congress refuses to make laws around it.

Then every website in the world will get a second bill from EACH ISP, which says, we’re really sorry but you are in the slow lane to our millions of subscribers, if you want to be put in the fast lane you have to pay this much… etc, etc…. That immediately slams the breaks on every internet start-up, in the full knowledge that carriers cannot grow business as fast as Google, Facebook or Twitter, and that their future profits will be Taxed by the ISP industry. Eventually there would not really be a slow lane, as to be in this would be pretty much useless. There would only be a Fast Lane.

We are put in mind of  when Windows first became a workable operating system in around 1984/5. A million software houses writing PC software sprang up. Shortly after Microsoft began competing with them, and most of them died in a few short years. Innovation was fragile and was shortly over. To have the same result happen to the 20 years old Internet industry would be tragic and unlikely to be copied anywhere else in the world and be a disaster for the US economy.

Scenario B) NN is made sacred under Title II laws, and despite legal actions by ISPs, which take four or five years to hear, the Courts can do nothing about this. During this time and beyond there is an uncertain return on investment among ISPs, and this includes cellular operators, and the US market stagnates, as it did prior to MSOs picking up broadband, when US telcos hated unbundled local loop legislation. Broadband in the US fell behind and remains behind today, in about 20th place globally. Without sufficient investment in broadband, there would be less internet innovation because in the US anyway, there will ONLY be slow lanes. A different kind of disaster for the US economy.

So there HAS to be a scenario C. What Obama has done is balance the equation. Previously the FCC stood alone, with very few supporters, and no-one envying its task. Even the courts were sympathetic when they tried to give the FCC clues and hints when a court struck down the FFC’s previous Open Internet ruling.

All that Obama has done is to make the alternative clear, complete Title II regulation throughout the access network and the ISP network. It would take all the profit out of the business overnight. As the President, he may be a lame duck, but his voice still has considerable clout, and others who want to align with him, will offer him support for this in return for support for their own hot topics. It could happen.

Right now the US telcos are largely out from under the control of Title II, since it is really about fixed phone lines and their responsibility to make them universally available, for predictable and controlled prices. The internet and cellular have both been seen to be different services, easier to make money on, and both are growing markets, not quite yet saturated. The US telcos are increasingly operating outside Title II.

The Cable industry lives in that half world between providing broadcast video and the internet, defined today by the FCC as an information service, and so not part and parcel in any way to Title II.

Mobile phone companies have always been told that their precious spectrum capacity will be protected not only from Title II considerations, but also from NN generally, otherwise the next auction for spectrum may fall to the floor and lose the US government its ability to raise cash from airwaves.

So Title II, the section of the Telecommunications Act that creates communication as a utility, is just for the declining fixed voice part of the Telco business.

In US law as defined by the 1934 Communications Act and the 1996 Telecommunications Act, this is all about defining what a Common Carrier is, because that’s what Title II is for.

A Common Carrier is one that transports traffic for anyone, promises to get it there and keeps pricing and all its terms the same for everyone, and it has a regulator on its back, able to look into how well it does the job, who can impose changes in practice on its own say so. It must deliver to a known route, schedule and at pre-defined rates.

All of that is anathema to competition. What it defines is a controlled monopoly of the old, pre-1980 AT&T, where due care and attention is not applied to making profit, but to ensuring all the rules are obeyed.

Scenario C looks like a halfway house, and one such outcome is what was leaked last week by the FCC to the US newspapers, where Title II applies to how ISPs treat websites, in delivering their traffic, but not to how consumers get their Access network connections.

In our view at Faultline, the President knows that during his second and last term he cannot take on any major, all consuming piece of legislative reform, and cannot see NN through to its end. So this shot across the bows is really about underscoring what the FCC is about to do. He paints the worse possible scenario to ISPs and prepares them for the worst, so that when the FCC finds a middle route, it becomes more palatable, and meets less legal resistance.

In our view, eventually providing Internet Access has to become a utility. But that is a long way off and this comes about as the profit goes out of that business, as competition drives the prices towards the floor. This is what happened in electricity and in phone lines, before official monopolies were put in place. It is also true of public transport.

But right now being an ISP, and certainly a wireless ISP, is one of the most profitable business in the world, to change it overnight, would crash the technology sector of the US and global stock markets, and that is not a good thing, especially right now, in their current fragile state.

Obama said in his statement: “We cannot allow internet service providers (ISPs) to restrict the best access or to pick winners and losers in the online marketplace for services and ideas. That is why today, I am asking the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) to answer the call of almost four million public comments, and implement the strongest possible rules to protect net neutrality.”

The FCC says it has received a record four million comments on its neutrality proposals, mostly in support of NN, but until now the FCC seemed to concede that it could not prevent paid prioritization, and the chairman has verbally endorsed it.

This new Obama outburst perhaps gives FCC Chairman Wheeler the chance to move back to his earlier position on the subject of fast lanes and remove that endorsement.

The key elements of Obama’s wishlist are:

The ISP cannot block any legal content which a consumer requests

The ISP cannot intentionally slow down or speed up particular content

Net neutrality rules must be applied to points of interconnection between the ISP and the rest of the internet, not just the last mile (something for which Mozilla, in particular, has put forward detailed proposals this year)

There can be no paid prioritization. As Obama put it: “As I have before, I am asking for an explicit ban on paid prioritization and any other restriction that has a similar effect.”

This puts Wheeler in an even more difficult position, in that this Presidential outburst may make it possible for him to shift to a less pragmatic and more idealistic view on NN. But in the end pragmatism will win out, because ISPs have to feel that if they go to the courts they have as much to lose as to win and right now the hybrid approach offers the best hope of that.

It’s been a long time since cellular carriers were offered a way out being lumped in the with the other ISPs, and with LTE, there is enough capacity involved that it is unlikely that they can remain a special case for much longer, a point that Google was keen to point out in its submission to the FCC, and one we think that will be heard.