Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 November 2014

Copper wire Telcos are losing the speed race to the Cablecos

By Charles Hall

There is some urgency for telcos with copper-based networks to offer broadband speeds of 100 Mbps or greater because a) cablecos have started offering those speeds and higher — in many cases at no price increase to the subscriber, b) consumers want faster broadband — they think there’s some magic to “fiber” — and c) politicians and government regulators see 100 Mbps as the holy grail of broadband and think that they should cause it to happen.

There’s also the fact that a price war has started in UHD TV sets. Walmart’s Sam’s Club stores are selling a 60-inch UHD TV for the HD-like price of $998 and currently the only source for UHD content are OTT services. Even when compressed by HEVC, UHD video takes twice the bandwidth of HD videos.

Here’s what AT&T is offering in Baton Rouge, Louisiana (Where Rider Research is based), which has a metro area population of about 800,000 and is the state’s capital, near the center of the oil and natural gas industry and home to two state-run universities. Our point is that this is a place where AT&T should be trying to win customers.

AT&T’s U-Verse Broadband
3 Mbps down (yes 3, not 30 Mbps) $29.95/month
6 Mbps down (yes 6, not 60) $34.95/month
18 Mbps $44.95/month
45 Mbps $64.95/month
– 12-month deals
– Include access to AT&T’s nationwide Wi-Fi Hotspot Network
– Installation and activation are free.
– The subscriber can cancel in the first thirty days.
– AT&T gives new broadband subscribers a $50 rewards card.
Cox, AT&T’s competitor in Baton Rouge, has recently doubled its 50 Mbps service to 100 Mbps at no additional charge to the customers. AT&T’s fastest broadband service is 45 Mbps down.

Cox broadband only:
5 Mbps down $34.99/month
50 Mbps down $49.99/month
100 Mbps down $59.99/month
150 Mbps down $79.99/month
– The term is for one year
– Over 250,000 free Wi-Fi hotspots are included
– Cox Security Suite Plus is included
Why would a consumer pay AT&T $64.95 for 45 Mbps when they could get 50 Mbps for $49.95 per month — 5 Mbps more for $15 less. If there’s a frequent gamer in the house or residents frequently watch streaming videos, who are they going to call? If someone buys a UHD TV, who are they going to call?

AT&T’s Uverse with a top speed of 45 Mbps may be acceptable to occasional broadband users — email, chat, browsing, shopping — but the number of occasional users of the Internet is decreasing rapidly. And what is a Cox subscriber to do when an AT&T sales rep calls? Switch? Or laugh at AT&T asking him to pay more for a slower speed?