Faultline has followed and supported TiVo for as long as we have been publishing, since 2003 and always it was a highly relevant stock, because it had great technology that was undervalued. Today as the market digests its results, TiVo is no longer quite so exciting. There is nothing there, apart from its intellectual property and acquisitions which are new, and which take us to the next stage in TV technology. The company needs a fundamental re-invention.
But the results show that today it can be treated like any other company and valued on its fundamental outcomes, not its potential. It still has $851 million in cash and short term assets, as a result of its legal awards, and consumers continue to buy the technology – they love it, but we have been saying that for 12 years. We feel it is out of date and tough to move into the OTT world from where TiVo sits.
With that amount of cash this makes its enterprise value just over $600 million as it posted its results, but it then crashed crashing 7% overnight to $1.26 billion, making it worth just $400 million. Perhaps it is valued at 20 times historic earnings, but more importantly service revenues continue to climb at 37% over last year, so it remains hard to see where TiVo will be when revenues start to flatten out.
It has almost no penetration in Asia or Latin America, and even in Europe there remain plenty of smaller 1 million or under MSOs that need its help. And from its DigitalSmiths acquisition it is getting a revenue rise of 21%, without announcing any new design wins, and when measured sequentially over last quarter, as it continues to ramp its influence among its customer base. DigitalSmiths won 7 out of the top 10 US pay TV contracts for recommendation systems during the past 18 months and many of these only began with small trial installations on OTT services by the time the company was acquired for $135 million by TiVo. They were all likely to call down large numbers of TV homes, which will slowly be exposed to its recommendations. Contracts for recommendations systems rest on a combination of cash up front for an integration and tuning, followed by an amount for each new homes which is served recommendations, and a success factor such as how many homes follow those recommendations and what this does to the pay TV player’s revenue.
Digitalsmiths’ software has already been used with all the major platforms such as iOS, Android, Roku, Xbox, PlayStation and Kindle and multiple set-top boxes and last year it grew from 90 million transactions in July, to 150 million by December, relying on announced deals at Time Warner Cable and Bright House networks, but also other unannounced deals which we believe are at Verizon, Charter, Cablevision, DirecTV and Dish.
Now this is a system which doesn’t care if the screen it is recommending for is at the end of an OTT line on the internet or inside an operator’s closed proprietary system, so the DigitalSmiths side of the revenue will continue to grow based on sales success. Surely TiVo will introduce it to operators such as Virgin in the UK, Com Hem in Sweden and Ono in Spain, so that base of homes is likely to grow. Most of its early trials were, in fact, on OTT screens.
But this is not true of all of TiVo. Most of its customer base is in cable, which while they are all moving to the IP protocol, that is only one step as they shift to pure OTT environments in their TV Everywhere installations and beyond to full OTT function.
We see DVRs moving to the cloud, and TiVo, while following that innovation, is not yet making any money out of it, so the company is ripe to suffer disruption as others win out on cloud DVR. Certainly the intellectual property that has allowed TiVo’s recovery since its darkest days 7 or 8 years ago, will not drive the other part of TiVo revenue forever – the technology revenues, account for $51 million of its $118 million total revenues this quarter, almost half.
Many of these revenues are scheduled or deferred legal payments, in effect settlements, while some others are genuine license payments for its technology. Right now the number of in-home DVRs is going up pretty much all over the world, possibly approaching saturation in the US, but as cloud DVRs take over and the internet becomes more reliable, we think TiVo DVR licensing revenue is exposed at TiVo.
TiVo says that subscriptions are now past 5 million, up 32% with net income of $6.3 million, a figure that was moved downwards by a $0.8 million of unexpected interest and some unexpected tax. These things should never be unexpected, but TiVo remains a small company and is not the best at forecasting, so it can be forgiven for that. We would think that its rise in MSO driven subs will see TiVo becoming a favorite long before it runs into cloud issues.
This quarter TiVo added Canada’s Cogeco cable platform three months after the partnership was announced, showing that it has implementation down to a fine art now. Cogeco has around 1 million pay TV customers in Canada and the US which it can now start signing up.
TiVo also talked up its own subscriptions, taken direct with members of the public, which are more profitable, but really don’t have many drivers now that most pay TV operators license TiVo technology. It was partners which led to the net additions being up 328,000 in the quarter. The company said that it would buy back around a third of its shares in various initiatives over the coming 12 months and forecast service and technology revenues to be around $87 million to $90 million next quarter. Most coverage hinged on the issue of TiVo missing consensus forecasts by a fraction, and hence the 7% share price drop, but we see deeper problems at TiVo, which won’t be as easily addressed as this minor profit miss.