It looks like the stakes are rising in the British Telecom patent infringement case where it is defending itself against ASSIA, in a case presided over by the UK court of appeals.
BT has now switched off its “RAMBo” (Rate Adaptive Management Box) which provides dynamic line management to optimize broadband speeds. The alternative was to pay £250,000 ($394,000) a week, an amount requested by ASSIA and agreed as reasonable by the court, if only as an advance against final damages. That number is based on 10% of the rental revenue on the infringing broadband lines, which is likely to be higher than the level at which damages will eventually be set. Of course damages will go back to the date when the infringement took place, and while RAMBo goes back in BT Legend about 9 years, it is really when BT began building out its superfast broadband, likely a few years ago that will be the bulk of its patent infringement.
That court approved rate which would work out at something like $19.7 million per year and given that the patents have been in place for the past 2.5 years, and the appeal court has said that it breaches ASSIA patents, then even if damages are just restitutive (putting things back how they were before the offence) that might work out at over $40 million. We think that something under half that amount is the likely realistic end point for damages. However damages plus a forward looking 10 year licensing fee could easily end up at that level, though it’s best not to second guess a court really.
Most sane businesses in this position, get into a room with the complainant and don’t come out until they have a workable deal, but this has yet to happen between BT and ASSIA and this is because the dispute has been going back 8 years, when ASSIA revealed specific design information believing that BT was planning to license its technology. Chances are the dispute has become too personal. BT no doubt thinks that the ideas were obvious, while ASSIA knows that seeing its own system put BT years ahead of where it was.
If a final court imposed settlement is in that order of magnitude, and BT is one of several European Telcos that have built their own broadband management systems, then ASSIA could be in for quite a payday. The more likely outcome is that it would open the door for ASSIA to sign further straightforward licensing deals ahead of further litigation, at more like ASSIA’s usual terms. If you just take the UK it might line up licenses at TalkTalk, which has 4 million lines, and a few smaller ISPs. Virgin doesn’t use ADSL and Sky is already an ASSIA customer.
So far damages in this case have not yet been set, and BT will have to wait until the court is ready to set them next year, and that depends on whether or not it gives BT leave to appeal to the highest court in the land or not, and whether BT’s team thinks that is a direction worth heading down. We think BT would not have switched off its system if it planned to go to the UK Supreme Court and that now it plans to strip out the function which infringes on the ASSIA patents, and carry on.
But even this is complicated. BT has already described a workaround to the court for one of the core patents, the 790 patent, and the Court says it will pronounce on this before Christmas, presumably if BT wins on this count, it can just switch the system back on with the changes.
Noah Mesel, General Counsel for ASSIA told us, “Earlier in the case BT told us that if it switched off RAMBo it risked disruption driving through the entire BT broadband network.” So it makes little sense that BT would risk such a thing.
It will also put a new workaround for the other 495 patent and will put that in front of the court at some stage. Mesel seemed unconvinced that the methods described by BT to work around the first 790 patent would be upheld by the Court.
BT seems to think that it can cope by switching off the system, and our immediate reaction was to do a line test on our BT line and see if we still got 30 Mbps. That is the likely outcome for lines which use this, that some of them inexplicable slow down.
George Ginis, Vice President of Product Management told Faultline, “These types of management systems monitor lines and identify those which are under-performing, then the system selects a new configuration altering things like power margin and interleaving. If you switch it off, over a period of time a growing number of lines are likely to underperform. They can send an engineer out to each one, or they can switch the system back on.”
The RAMBo system was used on the “BT Infinity” superfast broadband service provided within BT’s Next Generation Access (NGA) network.
ASSIA was notified on Friday last week that BT had turned the system off but BT has yet to provide any proof that it has done so. ASSIA believes this action will inevitably have a negative impact on BT quality of service and speeds and result in masses of customer calls, costing BT more than the settlement would.
“It is time for BT to join companies such as AT&T, Verizon, Sky, and Bouygues, and license our software; otherwise BT should pay for infringing our patented technology,” said Mesel.
“If BT discontinues use of the NGA-DLM system, a significant number of BT customers will be affected. Broadband services to businesses and homes will experience over time degradation of speed and reliability. DSLs have to be ‘managed’ or performance suffers over time, in some cases drastically. The support costs for those problem lines will almost certainly be more expensive than licensing ASSIA’s patents or software.”