Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 November 2014

Aereo files for bankruptcy as courts shut it out of US pay TV

Following its June 28th Supreme Court Decision, Aereo has now filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in New York. The ruling meant Aereo had to pay retransmission fees to the rights holders of the free-to-air content that it captured and streamed to customers – a model that ran afoul of the courts.

In a letter to its customers, Aereo’s CEO, Chet Kanojia, said that Chapter 11 would permit Aereo “to maximize the value of the business and assets without the extensive cost and distraction of defending drawn out litigation in several courts.” It seems the pay TV giants’ plan has worked: sue the pants off the little guy to make him go away.

Justice Stephen Breyer wrote “behind-the-scenes technological differences do not distinguish Aereo’s system from cable systems,” and decided that the Aereo model constituted a public performance, which was subject to copyright payments. The company had always argued its model was more like running an extremely long extension cable to a FTA antenna connected to a cloud-DVR, but using the internet to move the data instead of a single hundreds-of-miles long cable – and therefore a private performance, not subject to the same copyright constraints.

Kanojia writes “a little over three years ago, the team at Aereo set out to build a better television experience for the consumer. We began this journey because we were frustrated with a system that we believed was broken and no longer served the consumer. When it came to watching live TV, the options were few, the products available were cumbersome and didn’t fit our increasingly mobile lifestyle, and costs were unreasonably high and rising.”

Aereo quickly drew the ire of the TV incumbents, who were quick to litigate the company out of existence. Aereo says the Supreme Court decision led to a climate of uncertainty, and “effectively changed the laws that had governed our technology.”

But the transition from FTA to OTT delivery looks like an opportunity that the incumbents have overlooked for years, and are only now beginning to embrace. CBS has just announced a $5.99 per month service for its live content and extensive back catalog. In this instance, CBS is monetizing its library as well as its catch-up content, and if consumers are willing to pay the fee then CBS can freely sell to consumers outside its current geographic reach – and this is even more applicable to cablecos.

OTT frees the likes of Comcast and telco rival AT&T from the restrictions of their fixed infrastructure: as their content can reach anyone with an internet connection. If Aereo has a pay TV legacy, it might that it  encouraged incumbents to take the OTT plunge – and perhaps also forced the FCC to change its retransmission rules.

Aereo laid-off almost all of its staff at the beginning of the month, keeping a small executive team on the books to handle its Chapter 11 filing – designed to shield the business from ongoing legal proceedings, while it tries to restructure or sell off its assets, which Bloomberg reports have already generated considerable bidding interest.

Given the ruling, it’s unlikely that we’ll see Aereo again unless it chooses to play a different hand in the pay TV market or the prevailing laws are altered. The US Copyright Office has so far not granted Aereo cable provider status, but it could change its mind down the line. As such, Kanojia’s post reads like a farewell, as he signs off on what was the biggest shake-up to US pay TV since Netflix.

“We have travelled a long and challenging road. We stayed true to our mission and we believe that we have played a significant part in pushing the conversation forward, helping force positive change in the industry for consumers. We feel incredibly lucky to have had the opportunity to build something as meaningful and special as Aereo. With so many shifts and advances in technology, there has never been a more perfect time to take risks, challenge the status quo and build something special.”