According to the Consumer Electronics Association (CEA) overall shopping traffic was down “slightly” this holiday compared to last year. We emphasize the word slightly, because two paragraphs into the press release, the reader is met with “in total, 113.2 million US adults (46%) shopped or plan to shop over the holiday weekend from Thanksgiving to Cyber Monday – down 18 million shoppers from 2013.” That’s not a slight decrease, that’s a drop of 15.9%.
But while the total number of shoppers decreased, the CEA reports that each consumer who did shop, spent more – with an average spend of $371, up 4.8% from last year. The CEA estimates Americans will spend $39.9 billion over the Thanksgiving weekend, with 45% shopping online (flat compared to 2013) and 77% shopping in-store (a drop of 10%), showing the shift in shopping habits among consumers.
The CEA Black Friday Report found that while overall shopping was down “slightly,” there was notable growth in reported spending per person and tech purchases. Clothes led the field, being found in 69% of shopper’s baskets, with tech in second place on 45%, and toys in third again with 43%.
“Black Friday and Cyber Monday were once relatively independent shopping days,” said Shawn DuBravac, chief economist at CEA. “But they have expanded into a 10-day shopping period. As such, a drop in shopping traffic over the holiday weekend is likely due to transactions being pulled forwards, as retailers offer more deals in-stores and online earlier in the week than in previous years.”
The CEA took the bizarre decision to publish its survey on the Sunday between Black Friday and Cyber Monday, meaning we have concrete figures for the former, but only predictions for the latter – where it predicts 30.1 million adults (12% of total population) to shop, an increase of 2.4 million over 2013.
Among the 51.2 million US adults who bought or were planning on buying technology products over the weekend, 37% planned on buying a TV, 35% were looking for a tablet, 23% were aiming for notebook computers, 23% wanted a videogames console, and 23% wanted wireless speakers.
“While TVs are always a popular item for shoppers during the Thanksgiving weekend, consumers showed a remarkable appetite for them this year,” noted DuBravac. He added that buyers were in a sweet spot, with consumer demand driven by “phenomenal deals across all TV categories, movement into a new upgrade cycle, and interest in new technologies like 4K.”
Outside of the CEA, IBM has also provided the world with its own insight into the holiday sales and shopping habits. According to its Digital Analytics Benchmark (DAB), 52.1% of online Thanksgiving shopping traffic came from mobile, surpassing desktop browsing for the first time, and up 22% compared to 2013. In 2010, the mobile traffic figure stood at only 6.5% – meaning the 2014 number represents an eightfold increase in 4 years.
Black Friday’s mobile traffic stood at 49.6%, lower than Thanksgiving but up 25% from 2013’s figure. Black Friday mobile sales accounted for 27.9% of all online sales – up 28.2% over 2013. Both day’s average order value decreased compared to 2013, with Thanksgiving at $125.25 (down 1.8%) and Black Friday at $129.37 (down 4.4%) – which IBM thinks could be indicative of consumer’s growing comfort with using digital coupons and rebates to get better deals.
Thanksgiving continued to eat into Black Friday sales, as 2014’s Black Friday was worth 63.5% more than Thanksgiving – a drop from the 70% recorded last year.
Smartphones accounted for 34.7% of all Black Friday online traffic, while tablets made up 14.6%. However, despite making up less than half of the volume of smartphone traffic, tablets totaled 16% of online sales, while smartphones accounted for 11.8% – meaning a tablet user was 35% more likely to make a purchase than a smartphone user, and generated an average sum of $126.50 per order compared to the 17% lower smartphone figure of $107.55.
When IBM looked at the role the mobile OS played in sales and traffic, it found that iOS accounted for 34% of all online traffic, 21.9% of total online sales, and had an average order value of $125.14. Android, meanwhile, accounted for 15% of total online traffic, 5.8% of total online sales, and had an average order value of $98.07.
The penultimate set of comparative numbers used to measure the holiday weekend come from ComScore, which reports that online spending from desktop computers increased 32% in a year, to just over a record sum of $1 billion on Thanksgiving, and $1.51 billion on Black Friday.
For the holiday as a whole, the National Retail Federation (NRF) found that the average person who was planning to or had shopped would spend $380.95 over the weekend, a drop of 6.4% from $407 in 2013. Overall spending for the weekend was forecast to reach $50.9 billion, down 11% from last year’s estimated $57.4 billion.
The NRF also found that the average person who would shop strictly online was only going to spend $159.55, down 10.2% from 2013 and less than half the amount the average shopper was planning to spend – and therefore significantly less than the average exclusively in-store shopper.
Cumulatively, the figures show that online shoppers still spend significantly less than their in-store counterparts. Despite the online traffic and sales percentages increasing, the holiday weekend as a whole appears to be shrinking in size – but whether this is a temporary blip or a sign that the Black Friday hysteria has begun negatively effecting sales remains to be seen – but an 11% total drop in sales can’t be ignored or swept under the rug.