The opening sentence from the CEO of software based encoder specialist Envivio as he announced this quarter’s results, was the exact opposite of what you’d expect and you have to say that the company is losing mindshare in the multiscreen encoder markets
CEO Julien Signes blamed macro-economic conditions in Europe and customer consolidation in the US for his company’s woes, as he announced revenues off by 23% sequentially
Envivio revenue for the quarter was $9 million, down 23% sequentially and pretty much the same percentage over this time last year. And Signes added, “Similar to our industry peers, we have also experienced customer caution on spending due to major technology transitions such as HEVC and Ultra HD.”
We are a little skeptical of customer caution over spending, although the only other US public encoder company presented in October and fell just short of the previous quarter and was 12% down on last year
HEVC is a reason to spend, as is UHD, but the operators do need time to test products before going to bulk orders. Arch rival Elemental was at the front of the queue for UHD and HEVC and its products have been through operators testing and we suspect it is way ahead on volume shipments, although because it is a private company, we cannot confirm that.
Envivio has been making strong noises about its customer wins and is right up against Elemental, which although it came out of encoding for multiscreen delivery of Live events, is now matching Envivio in its ability to go head to head for real time encoding and especially for cloud encoding. After Media Excel, Elemental was the second of the prominent encoder makers to ship a cloud product more than a year ahead of Envivio, which has only just got there.
But Signes had a little something up his sleeve, talking about a new Tier 1 US operator which has not previously been a customer, making up 10% of the quarter’s revenue, with more to come. “We believe this win from a highly competitive bid could lead to material business in the next 12 months,” said Signes. It is thought by some that his recent success is at one of the two major US telcos, and that his references to consolidation refer to the merger of AT&T and DirecTV, suggesting he has another win potentially there, rather than the merger involving Comcast, where Envivio is know to have some business.
Revenue was $9.0 million, compared to $11.5 million in the second quarter of fiscal 2015 and $11.7 million in the third quarter of fiscal 2014.
GAAP net loss for the third quarter of fiscal 2015 was $5.4 million, compared to a net loss of $4.1 million.
When this first happened two years ago, it was just after Envivio had gone public, and it went from growing faster than anyone, to hitting a wall. Now we have to assume that any long term trend is in these figures and that sales momentum will not recover.
The question is, what does anyone do about it. Signes either needs to invest in copying the GPU strategies of Elemental or in some new marketing initiatives, or simply get his team animated in the HEVC UHD market. If none of that happens he will not be long for the company, although changing CEOs at small encoding companies is usually asking for trouble.
Envivio had over $60 million in the bank after its IPO and when its sales collapsed, replaced the sales and marketing team. As of October 31, Envivio had cash and cash equivalents of just $37.9 million, more that $20 million less than two years back and the VC players that brought it to market are likely to act sooner rather than later.
Envivio has also just settled one class action lawsuit which came after its sales collapsed in the wake of the IPO, although it still needs court approval and so far says this has only cost $1 million over and above insurances. Right now Envivio is valued at less than the money it has in the bank, a value we would agree with.