Perhaps it was ironic that the WiFi Innovation Summit was held in Denmark, in fact in Copenhagen, where this week the Ministry of Trade once again highlighted the total lack of competition in broadband and therefore also in WiFi, throughout Denmark, due to TDCs 60% dominance.
The truth is that this is what happens when the incumbent telco is allowed to buy the strongest cable company, as well as build a lead in cellular. It has all the broadband lines (60%), 40% of cellular with a higher ARPU than anyone else, and some 53% of pay TV. And although TDC has moved to accommodate homespots and WiFi offload, it has done it half-heartedly because it’s not available to any of its rivals, at least not to the same extent.
TDC could have done with visiting the Innovation Summit where it might have met the WiFi cognoscenti of the world and update its ideas on how important, or otherwise, WiFi is in the scheme of things.
Essentially progress at this show, over the inaugural January WiFi Offload Summit show has been slow for some, with many of the presentations simply filling out on visions that were first iterated at the beginning of the year, on subjects such as paying for WiFi from advertising pre-rolls, and justifying retail WiFi on the basis of traffic flow data and real time coupon offers. While that story has continued to developed and while we can’t claim there is an out and out winner, the presentation from the UK’s Purple WiFi revealed that it now has two prestigious service resellers in Verizon, but only in Europe, and in Telstra in Australia.
Purple’s head of marketing, Kerry Wright, described the suite as Google Analytics for WiFi, and said that it had even been made to look a little like Google Analytics. The system is a combination of marketing, analytics and location data for anything to do with WiFi and really we can see little to choose between it from the other players present, like Cloud4Wi and Global Reach, but clearly doing a deal with two major tier 1 players, with the prospect of Verizon, if it likes it, taking it back into the US, means that Purple seems to be earmarked as at least one of the long term survivors in the new world of WiFi monetization.
But on a more fundamental note Sweden’s Birdstep, which specializes in providing and maintaining policy for ANDSF network selection, talked up a big move for WiFi and LTE integration. CEO Lonnie Schilling told us, “What we are working towards is a situation where an operator can look deeply into the condition of networks and choose the one that is best for the customer experience.”
We suggested to Lonnie that cellular operators tended to try to use as much cellular as possible and only offload to WiFi when the networks run out of gas, and Schilling told us, “What we are now seeing is that some operators want to “load balance” between the two technologies. It’s not so Knee jerk any more.” Faultline understands that Birdstep is expected to announce an alliance in Japan with a tier one cellular player which will adopt this type of approach.
Our immediate guess was Softbank, with the implications that a similar system might get re-imported to the US via Sprint, but things are very different in Japan. Both KDDI and Softbank have active “Homespot” programs for offload, but all three of the top cellcos there have a huge hotspot investments with over 400,000 public hotspots, with KDDI dominant with 200,000, and NTT and Softbank lagging behind with 140,000 and 100,000 respectively, so it could be a project with any of them.
Schilling added, “NTT tried to write its own software for the creation of homespots and it failed, but will try again during 2015.” NTT has total dominance in broadband in Japan with over 19 million broadband lines of various types and along with leased lines and ISDN data lines it offers something closer to 36 million connections, so it will dwarf the other two operators if it successfully builds a homespot operation.
Schilling refused to identify which player Birdstep is working with, but said, “Our new system will allow the operator to set a policy so that for instance it can decided to use the KDDI hotspots, which are often free for usage, and it can still provide all the credentials for log in, even though that’s a rival operator. But it will make that decision based on the bandwidth and throughput condition. It will continuously monitor the handset experience as well, with software on the handset, which means that when that condition changes, it will shift to another network.”
While little of this is really new, the new facts are that Birdstep is witnessing enlightened policies being set, which wrap in rival networks and which don’t treat WiFi like a pariah. This means that cellcos are finally “getting” WiFi and not simply seeing it as the enemy or an inferior network.
There was however at the WiFi summit the usual insults hurled at WiFi, by the LTE community, who delight in using emotive terms like “untrusted” and “best effort ” to describe it, and who then turn around and say that “No these are not emotional terms,” these are simply technical terms, because the network is not visible to its monitoring tools and because encryption that starts outside of its core has to be described as untrusted. The trouble is that this leads to the assumption that WiFi is both performing less well than LTE and is also untrustworthy by nature, which we won’t dispute, but time and time again WiFi, especially indoor WiFi, proves to be more reliable than LTE and far faster.
This then is perhaps the mission of events like this one, as well as companies like Birdstep and likewise Devicescape and AnyFi, and other software authentication companies – to bridge the divide between LTE and WiFi – to convince the cellular community that WiFi is there for heavy lifting, like playing video and that almost ALL sessions should begin on WiFi, and only shift to LTE when WiFi networks are out of range, and not the exact reverse.
Already from the speakers at this show, there were a host of estimates of how much of that heavy lifting WiFi is already doing, starting with one attributed to Cisco’s VNI at 57% and going upwards from there with Claus Hetting the conference organizer citing a number north of 80%, sourced from Mobidia, and every number in between. KPN the Netherlands telco cited 78% of handset data traveling over WiFi, and talked about how it has rapidly copied cablecos Liberty Global’s UPC and Ziggo, and has now reached up to 600,000 homespots across the country, out of the 2.7 million broadband lines it has, working with FON. We would expect that number to rise to 750,000 during the early part of 2015 and keep rising until it gets to around 1.65 million Homespots, and on a par with its cable rivals, some time in 2016.
KPN has already added some 1,500 new traditional commercial hotspots to the 2,000 that it had prior to this build out, and the creation of a specialist division focused on embracing WiFi. It has added a number of Gas stations, hardware chains and supermarkets over the past year, with a new approach of allowing the site owner their own portal, instead of using the installation as an advert purely for the glory of KPN. Already it has hijacked these homespot lines and the new Hotspots, for its mobile customers, although the 180,000 accounts that it has signed up in this way only get access to the FON network inside Netherlands, rather than the extended global network of 14 million hotspots.
FON in its own presentation admitted to a revenue level of just €30 million, with shareholders now including Qualcomm, Google, Microsoft, British Telecom and Deutsche Telekom, and says that its own consumer price of €15 for a 5 day WiFi deal, manks it is the best, low-cost option for consumers direct WiFi purchasing.
Next stop for FON is a move into the Internet of things, courtesy of a relationship with Qualcomm Allplay and a new kind of home hub which can either be the main home gateway or a second WiFi extender, through which it is selling Spotify subscriptions and which will have added to it the ability to speak to IoT networks like Zigbee and Z-Wave.
Getting back to that WiFi usage on a mobile device, the truth is that a device which is used, even part of the time, for 4K video, which will soon mean many handsets and tablets, will raise its consumption to 95% of its data when tethered to a WiFi connection, in a short period of time, and that’s something that cellcos would not want to change. It is the growing confidence that companies who can ensure that MNOs experience the feeling of control over performance and QoE, that will slowly bring WiFi into the acceptance of the humble cellular engineer.
Today that engineer’s boss knows the value of fixed line assets and WiFi, because while boardroom is hunting down WiFi and fixed line assets around the world to acquire. But at the same time the engineer continues to be encouraged to treat WiFi like the enemy. When that changes, networks will look very different and work far more effectively and suffer far lower Capex burdens.