Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 December 2014

TIA letter helps TV market stamp its foot over Net Neutrality

We won’t linger on this story, but practically ALL of our reader base and everyone with a vested interest in the video eco-system, has put its name to a letter to the FCC and anyone in US government that will listen, this week, bemoaning the effect of shifting the internet to Title II.

If you want to read the letter, go ahead it’s on the Telecommunications Industry Association web site, but what it argues is that making the entire internet Title II is a bad thing.

What the letter does not do in the slightest is say WHY it expects this to result in a lack of investment in the internet, only what will happen in the investment vacuum that is inevitable after such a move, and what it also fails to even contemplate is what happens if Title II is applied only to one  side of the internet, the journey from the website to the ISP, NOT from the ISP to the consumer. Because we all know from a variety of studies and sources that that this is precisely what the FCC expects to put on the table. So why does this letter NOT talk about that? The answer is simple. It is easier to point out what is wrong with something that no-one in their right mind would do, rather than actually discuss what may really happen, something infinitely more subtle than what this letter addresses.

At Faultline we would have mentally torn it up as “uninteresting,” but we forgot what a literal society the US CAN be. And if the President comes out and says the whole thing should be Title II (which is again not precisely what he said), everyone assumes that’s what the outcome is going to be. Well we don’t think so and it is a little embarrassing if these companies really think that the FCC would consider trying it.

Here is the reading between the lines version. It goes something like, “We know darn well that Title II is not going to be applied to the entire internet, but we could not get all these signatures behind this letter unless that’s  what we wrote about. But a number of us, those who pushed the idea of writing this letter in the first place, with the most to lose, are really worried about Title II being applied even to the back end of the internet, and although we are not addressing that, it’s only so this response then ends up appearing to represent massive consensus. Even though it actually doesn’t.”

We re-iterate that US policy in these matters is usually best conducted in a negotiating room with a handful of people, and best driven by a company that desperately wants something, talking to a regulator that wants something else. Comcast wants to buy Time Warner Cable, and the FCC wants Net Neutrality. And if the FCC and Justice Department were to sit Comcast down and say, that’s fine, as long as you dispose of this and that bit of content and offer this and that content wholesale. And you don’t ever block or slow down anyone’s content for 10 years, and you never demand OTT exclusivity in a content contract.

This would then be a series of “consents” which were achieved in order for Comcast to get its permission to do a deal. At this point you would have the dominant force in the US internet being tied to a Net Neutrality position (of course it would have to be policed). Anyone that wanted to go a different route, like rival AT&T, would risk losing customers to the enlarged Comcast. If the FCC could also get some commitments on customer care and over-aggressive sales practices from Comcast while it was at it, then it would really have done the US public a great service, and no legislation and no new rulemaking would need to be passed.

The letter was signed by some of the market leaders in IP routing, broadband, set tops, WiFi and video and advertising software including ActiveVideo, Adtran, Alcatel-Lucent, Arris, BlackArrow, Broadcom, Cisco, dLink, Entropic, Ericsson, Harmonic, Intel, Minerva, Nokia, Pace, Qualcomm, RGB and Rovi, who all clearly think that things would just be better if left as they are.