As Karl Marx might have said, all networks are neutral but some are more neutral than others. That captures the current tide of sentiment in the net neutrality debates on both sides of the pond, as prominent voices in both Europe and the US speak out in favor of differentiated services.
Most surprisingly perhaps Europe’s most influential leader, German Chancellor Angela Merkel, weighed into the debate this week by arguing that a totally neutral network would be against the interests both of consumers and innovation. Merkel contended that the Internet should be split into two tiers to accommodate special services because there was a fundamental difference between the requirements of real time services, especially high definition video, and other Internet applications such as email and general browsing. Both QoS requirements and levels of traffic generated differed so greatly between the two that it made little sense for them to treated the same within one common service tier, according to Merkel.
So she called for the Internet to be split into two, with one “lane” reserved for special services with greater demand, such as Netflix or HD TV, and another for all the other “best effort” services. Both would run over a common Internet infrastructure, but be segregated and subject to different traffic rules.
Internet freedom advocates reacted with dismay to Merkel’s sentiments, which contradict the general tenor of European net neutrality arguments, which have tended towards absolute equality. The fear is that allowing differentiated services will have the effect of discriminating against those unwilling or unable to pay. In one sense this already happens at the level of WiFi access in public places such as hotels, trains and airports, where there is a choice between a low grade free service and a faster paid one. The point is that expectations and requirements for Internet service constantly inflate, so that a QoS acceptable a few years ago is quite intolerable now, but may be all that free WiFi delivers.
However the Merkel argument is that QoS can be enshrined into legislation anyway and that having a two lane Internet merely recognizes the reality that some services are more tolerant of delay and bandwidth variation than others. Nobody is inconvenienced by an email taking three seconds to arrive but that same delay would render a video conferencing session completely useless.
But given the entrenched opposition to a two lane Internet in Europe the German government will face resistance within the European Parliament, which voted down a different two-tier plan in April 2014. For now Germany is calling just to explore a new structure and define clearly what new services would enjoy the benefits of a fast lane. But certainly Germany will have to do a lot of intensive lobbying to get proposals for a two tier Internet onto the EU’s statute.
Meanwhile the US debate took a rather parallel direction this week as a group of academics published a letter in the Washington Post urging the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to intervene in the increasingly polarized debate there over net neutrality, on the grounds that the FCC (Federal Communications Commission) is taking too rigid a line (even though as yet we do not know precisely which line it is taking). The 32 academics signing the letter come from a mix of Washington think tanks and universities and are more sympathetic to the needs of commerce and innovation than some of their peers. But even so it came as a surprise that academics presumed to be champions of Internet freedom should be arguing that allowing broadband services to prioritize traffic from some web sites in return for a fee could be good for some consumers, echoing the Merkel line.
The US debate is complicated by a political fight for control and influence between the FTC and FCC that is of little interest for the rest of the world. To date ISPs are regulated by the FCC but also within reach of the FTC on the basis that the Internet has now evolved to the point that it is absolutely pivotal for trade and commerce. The FTC is now intent on expanding its ambit to include more of the IT and communications industry and is more open to the idea of a two tier Internet, or at any rate to lighter regulations that allow the industry and its service providers more room to determine their own traffic policies.
Back in September conservatives within the FTC such as Republican Commissioner Maureen Ohlhausen argued that if the FCC takes aggressive action by regulating ISPs as if they were telephone companies that clearly must treat all traffic equally, the FTC would no longer be able to oversee them. This would invoke Title II of the US Communications Act, which applies to “common carriers” with no remit to differentiate between services. It does not seem logical to treat broadband providers as common carriers given the diversity of services they now offer, but that is what President Obama recently called for, in his bid to be seen as the champion of net neutrality. This would put ISPs beyond the reach of the FTC, which not surprisingly Republican commissioners oppose.
But while the debate has become more politicized in the US its substance is quite similar to Europe. Advocates of strong net neutrality naturally call for regulations that invoke this Title II on the basis that this would prohibit traffic discrimination. The FCC is considering whether to reclassify broadband companies completely under that part of the law or take some hybrid line. With Obama’s support for absolute net neutrality the tide had been flowing towards application of Title II, at least until the intervention of the Washington academics. That is why they decided to wade in now.
It is still all to play for in this debate, but it does look as if the more extreme forms of net neutrality will be sidelined. To some extent the debate hinges on the distinction between positive and negative discrimination between traffic types. It will be OK to ensure that HD video is prioritized providing that other traffic is treated equally and that there is sufficient capacity to meet acceptable QoS guidelines for all services. Or as Marx might also have said, “to each service according to its needs”.