Pay TV figureheads consistently point to piracy as being one of the biggest threats to their industry. Now, according to Dataxis, they have some numbers to back up their claims – at least in Latin America. If piracy were an actual unified business, it would be the third largest pay TV operator in the region, with 7.8 million homes to its credit.
That number accounts for 11% of the Latin American market, and Argentina, Brazil and Colombia currently contribute the majority of illegal users according to Dataxis. But there is good news for those who decry the pirates, as Dataxis forecasts that piracy “will evolve slower than the formal market,” and account for 8.5 million homes in 2018 – reducing its share to 8.8% of the total market.
Dataxis found that almost 60% of pirate viewers were using satellite options, and that these DTH options could account for 80.5% of the pirate market by 2018. A common practice was “neighbor plans,” in which legitimate pay TV set tops were shared among neighbors to share the cost of a single subscription between multiple households.
Given the prevalence of this method, it would appear that any business that can walk into an operator’s boardroom and flog them a system to better monitor and authorize their CPE would make a killing – but Dataxis warns that the piracy it detected was often seen to have great levels of sophistication, meaning that trying to thwart pirates might quickly descend into an expensive game of whack-a-mole.
This appears to be the case according to DirecTV’s own analysis, which was published in Mexican newspapers last week. El Financiero reported that piracy in Latin America was on the rise, with 23% of pay TV users receiving channels illegally – across satellite, cable and OTT platforms. DirecTV noted that operators were also pirating premium channels, and distributing them to their customers without paying. But DirecTV says that 60% of the 7.8 million pirate subs it has counted, access pirated content via a set top that has been modified to allow them access to premium channels from different satellite and cable operators.
DirecTV said that despite more complex (and expensive) techniques, developed by the operators in recent years, piracy levels rose from 20% of homes in 2013 to the current 23%.
There is a prevalent argument that is floated around internet message boards and comment sections frequently, that piracy is only so rampant because of a combination of geography and cost. That is, people pirate content because it is not available in their country, or is prohibitively expensive, or tied to a pay TV platform that a potential customer refuses to pay for. It will be a matter for the accountants and internal financial analysts, but some pay TV operators could win back sizeable amounts of viewers by making their offers more affordable – given that what piracy saves in cost it usually pays for with poorer quality and the tradeoff currently prevents users from jumping over to the legitimate version.
The traditional economic model of demand increasing as the price gets lower would hold up here, assuming that paying for a better picture and experience becomes a tolerable expense to the pirate household. Lowering the ARPU but increasing the houses served should provide a net gain – while spending millions of dollars trying to whack one of the most persistent moles in the world has proven so far to be a rather fruitless and expensive endeavor.
Piracy means that demand is no longer inelastic, as the operators have lost control of the supply chain and distribution, and consumers don’t have to stick with the legitimate avenues to access content. You either spend millions trying to regain control of the supply chain, carry on as usual, or take a gamble that lowering the ARPU will bring in more viewers.