The FCC is raising the minimum required fixed line speeds that will qualify for the Connect America funding. The increase will see the threshold rise to 10Mbps download and 1Mbps upload, up from the 4Mbps down and 1Mbps up that was mandated by the 2011 rules. Tom Wheeler seems to have made good on the promise he made back in September, to resolve the issue by the end of the year.
The Connect America subsidies were initially made available for fixed line providers to reimburse the costs associated with connecting less profitable areas of the US countryside to the internet. They have become big business for ISPs, who at the 4Mbps level didn’t have to go particularly far out of their way to meet the subsidy criteria in terms of equipment costs – and left the customer with an internet connection that is rapidly becoming obsolete in the world of OTT HD video.
Consequently, it looks like the FCC is raising the subsidy threshold before it gets around to reclassifying broadband to mean an internet connection that is at least 10 Mbps – a definition which it has floated in the past few months, to the outrage of AT&T, Verizon and the NCTA, which all claim that the 4Mbps connection is plenty of bandwidth for customers despite being less than the 5Mbps that Netflix recommends for a single HD video stream.
In its release, the FCC said that it “is an increase reflecting marketplace and technological changes that have occurred since the FCC set its previous requirements in 2011.” Wheeler has previously said that 25Mbps was quickly becoming “table stakes” in 21st century communications. “When 60% of the internet’s traffic at prime time is video, and it takes 4 or 5Mbps to deliver the video, a 4Mbps connection isn’t exactly what’s necessary in the 21st century.”
Undoubtedly, there will be a pushback, at least to the reclassification, from the ISPs, but the FCC is adamant on the subsidy issue, and according to recent data, rural consumers are vastly under-served compared to their urban counterparts. Its press release states that Congress has directed it to improve rural services, and that increasing the speed requirement will support HD video and multiple-user households.
“With the adoption of today’s order, the FCC is prepared to make offers of support totaling up to nearly $1.8 billion annually to a class of larger carriers known as price cap carriers in early 2015, which will potentially expand service to over 5 million rural Americans.” The FCC is also increasing its E-rate program’s annual spending cap from $2.4 billion to $3.9 billion, by means of a 16 cents a month increase on phone line charges, to fund broadband improvements in schools and libraries.
In addition to the speed requirement, other changes to the 2011 order include: increasing the terms of support for the price cap carriers from five years to six years, with the option for a seventh in certain circumstances; increasing the flexibility of the build-out requirements while still ensuring that previously unserved Americans are brought online; waiving certain universal service obligations in low-cost census blocks where price cap carriers don’t qualify for subsidies as well as in competitive blocks; and requiring that those who have already received Connect America support continue to deliver voice to high-cost census blocks until they are replaced by another subsidized carrier. Via competitive bidding, that is then required to deliver voice and 10/1 broadband – with new clearer consequences for any carrier that fails to meet it service standards.
While the larger ISPs are calling for a reversal, smaller ones such as Windstream have applauded the FCC’s decision, declaring it “another major step toward expanding robust broadband service to Americans in rural, high-cost areas.”
Meanwhile, the American Cable Association’s CEO, Matt Polka, has said that “the ACA may differ with the FCC on select aspects of the program, but it does not disagree with the overall direction, and we intend to continue to work with the FCC to ensure unserved consumers get high-speed broadband in an efficient and fiscally responsible manner.”