US DTH player Dish has always been a company that likes to launch things at CES and tends to save its best for this January event – which is why it has a rash of announcements, 4K devices, a new voice activated remote control, and the long awaited OTT pay TV service, which it now calls Sling TV.
It does not require any of the technology it acquired with Sling Media, so this is not a place-shifting service – Dish CEO Joe Clayton just seems to have liked the name.
The first reactions have been two-fold – straight out of the box it has been written off – $20 is too much to pay for an OTT service while Netflix and Hulu Plus are under $10 a month. And then it has been praised by reviewers, some of which already use Netflix and Hulu but are still looking for that tiny bit more, before they abandon cable altogether.
Already the stark differences between Sony Playstation Vue, a service on beta in New York since November, and discussed by Sony CEO Kazuo Hirai at his CES keynote on Monday, are on display – Sony has the free to air national US broadcast networks Viacom, CBS, Fox and NBC, Dish does not. But Dish has ESPN for sport, as long as you remember that Viacom has the smartphone rights to ESPN and so Sling TV customers cannot view this channel on a smartphone, nor pause or rewind this particular channel (it can do so with all the others).
Sony has its own depth of movies to show on demand, plus content from partner studios, and Dish has a compiled wide list of VoD, which is perhaps a little older. Both services offer 3 day catch up to the channels they offer, whereas in the rest of the world outside the US, OTT services tend to offer 14 day catch up – so perhaps this will be the US norm. Sony has not issued a price, Dish has set out its stall at $20 a month. Neither are planning to offer contracts and will let customers try the service and cancel after 30 days.
Throughout the Dish Network operation its execution is pretty good, and we suspect that the reason that reviewers already like its system is simply because it is already on a lot of devices – including Amazon Fire, Google Nexus Player, LG TVs, Mac and PCs, Roku and the Xbox One, with the big item missing being the PlayStation – and of course it actually works. Sony’s Vue will begin life only on a PlayStation, and broaden out from there to iOS and Android. Both will be launched nationwide in the first quarter. We eagerly await the first review of the PlayStation Vue system, but figure it could be just as impressive to explore as Sling.
There are more channel differences. Missing from PlayStation Vue are two major media conglomerates, Disney, which owns ABC and ESPN, and Time Warner, the parent company of Turner which offers Cartoon Network, CNN, TNT and TBS and of course HBO, which says that it will go it alone as an OTT service. Sling has ESPN, the Disney Channel and the Turner channels.
In a way this is a big find out process for the major channel owners, including the free to air players. We would expect them to initially pick sides, look at the effect on revenue, advertising and viewing figures, find their feet and then expand across a wider OTT footprint. And for HBO, its popularity is such that it can pick and choose and add itself as a premium channel to both services – which is what we expect it to do, almost immediately.
Dish also has content from online sources such as Maker Studios, now owned by Disney and already talks about premium chunks of channels for another $5 a month. So far it has a kids option and a News option – Sports is next.
So what we are seeing here is a first layer of channel unbundling – not all the way to a la carte, but a drift, as we have seen on cable TV, towards smaller collections of channels, for smaller amounts of money. Slowly we see this becoming full unbundling, but as we say, slowly. If everyone buys Sling TV just to get ESPN, then it is effectively a vote for ESPN. If everyone takes Sony for its free to air services, then that’s a vote in that direction.
In two years we expect there will be at least 5 “cable replacement” OTT services in the US, perhaps ten, which have full live channels with 3 day catch up, and they will have small clusters of channels which make service cheap enough to buy one cluster just to get one channel. Viewing figures will be absolute (such is the nature of OTT) and advertising rates will only attach to viewership, as they do on the internet.
But to understand the glacially slow approach of OTT, it will have finally arrived in its infancy in the first quarter of 2015. The technology was in place to offer OTT in around 2006, and we patiently waited for momentum to build. We have seen from Netflix that it is a slow process to attract customers in numbers, and either of these services may take off, or neither of them. The first time one of these gets to 100,000 customers we may hear about it, but Aereo arrived, caused a fuss and was closed down and this never got beyond 78,000 homes – barely a ripple in TV terms.
So expect OTT to continue to move in glacial terms, and take 5 years or more to drift to the standing that Netflix has today – and remember there are still people arguing that Netflix is NOT driving cord cutting, even after all that time, so expect the same here for the next five years.