Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 January 2015

FCC stance pushes legislators into another pass at Net Neutrality

It’s almost as if the US had to get CES out of the way before getting back to one of the key decisions of the internet era – how to legislate to ensure that the open internet is not killed off by greedy ISPs – by issuing some form of Net Neutrality ruling.

These things are never easy. Europe is freshly smug, having come up with a quiet, and rather innovative solution – using the Liberty Global – Ziggo merger in the Netherlands, to place obligations on Liberty Global which effectively mean that cable at least will adhere to net neutrality, without there even being a law in place. It also has some legal process starting to define a law, if needed.

Europe was already in much better shape than the US on this matter, in that when its regulators speak, its courts don’t intervene, as they both report to the European Parliament in the end, and with the same boss, tend to have joined up thinking.

What is hard to understand is that the US is particularly weak in terms of competition, which makes the rhetoric from Verizon of this weak “belly laugh funny.” It is citing two professors, who is has clearly paid to deliver a paper on the subject entitled rather pompously, The “Terminating Access Monopoly” Theory and the Provision of Broadband Internet Access.

The main thrust of this piece of “original” thinking is that Title II legislation was written in an era when the consumer had no voice and monopolies had no rivals, which it posits, is not the case today. Today is a hotbed of rivalry and breaches in Net Neutrality principles don’t hurt consumers, but instead worry companies like Netflix, who have their own voice, loudly pointing out underhand moves by tier 1 operators, which would lead to consumers swapping their supplier.

Given that the US quite often has regions with “zero” broadband suppliers, so much so that President Obama was obliged to offer $ billions of funding  to get local suppliers to come up with ways of bridging the digital divide with his National Broadband Plan, then this rhetoric is worse than useless. There are four nationwide cellular operators which offer a style of broadband which could never stand up against fixed line services, and for vast areas of the US, only overpriced satellite broadband offers any kind of connection at all. In large swathes of the US there is only one supplier, and often, even where there are two, there is only one that can offer speeds above 30 Mbps. In some Metropolitan areas there are 3, and almost nowhere are their 4 or 5 sources of broadband – something that is common across Europe.

So comments about the ability to invest being impaired, with investment only being possible when competition is the only limit to broadband, are wide of the mark. Verizon and AT&T were able to invest in broadband since 2005 or so, only because there is so “little” competition that prices are astronomical. Wake up America – countries as poor as Bulgaria have broadband which is 3 times the speed and a quarter of the price – simply because it has “some” competition. (broadband covers 93% of Bulgaria, 54% of households subscribe, 42% have 30 Mbps).

Only in the US could the largest Telcos threaten the government with “no investment” back in 2005/6 prior to Project Lightspeed by AT&T and FiOS by Verizon, and get away with it – waiting until they were confident that they would never be forced to unbundle if they made the investment and built out broadband.

Those of us with long memories and an ability to count know, that is was these mentally impoverished decisions, that left AT&T and Verizon in the awful broadband situation they are kin today – with the same number of broadband lines they have had since 2007, leaving ALL the fresh broadband cake on the table for US cable.

The two men responsible for the apologist rhetoric of Verizon are none other than Andres Lerner EVP at Compass Lexecon, and Janusz Ordover, a Professor of Economics at New York University. Ordover has among his credentials an association with the Bush administration on the subject of anti-trust, a subject totally alien to President Bush, since under his management AT&T was allowed to coalesce once again after the 1980 Justice Department engineered consent decree, agreeing that Southwestern Bell could acquire both AT&T and Bell South, which merged to create the telco duopoly that previous administrations had feared.

They throw about expression like “the significant competition that exists in the wireless broadband Internet” and fail completed to include the almost moribund telco fixed line ISP services in the debate, instead pretending that AT&T and Verizon suffer significant opposition from T-Mobile (which has no fixed lines at all) and Sprint (which has Clearwire and some long lines, but no consumer fixed lines either). This is especially dumb as the world finally realizes the value of home gateway based WiFi, which the fixed line companies own.

The industry can see that the ONLY debate worth having in this discussion is the competition in fixed line internet that is provided by US cable, and that without it the entire US landscape would be based on two Telco monoliths with separate fixed line service areas, which only compete in cellular. One single quad play push will turn the US into two monopolies, and unless Cable can create a wireless delivery service for Broadband, something which only the recent emergence of WiFi offload has created the opportunity for, otherwise the US could soon find itself under monopoly pricing once again.

For two men who are supposed to be professors, the trick of confining the debate not to the Internet, but purely to the Wireless delivery of it, shows a remarkable disregard for the intellect of anyone reading their paper. Pointing out that 93% of US consumers have access to at least two 4G LTE

services (Verizon and AT&T), and most have access to two more providers (T-Mobile and Sprint) is utterly irrelevant to a debate where UHD video signals are beyond both T-Mobile and Sprint and will be for some years.

It’s like the advice in the most famous of books, “Crossing the Chasm,” which says “Define your competition.” Author Geoffrey Moore then goes on to explain that by picking out weak competitors and naming them, and saying why you are different, a company’s marketing can avoid comparisons with the real competition. That’s fine in marketing, but not in legislation.

Sprint is more realistic in the letter it sent to the FCC this week, saying that whether Title II is used to bring carriers into line or Section 706 of the Communications Act, as long as they have room to move and differentiate their services, it doesn’t matter.

Verizon and AT&T in fixed line services, are one trick ponies that sue to get their way. They have shown they cannot compete in fixed line, but have dominant positions, through acquisition and good management, in cellular. So this is posturing to get the FCC to back away from more extreme versions of legislation to ensure an open internet, and instead adopt what?

Well it seems that both Verizon and AT& are in such a panic that their lobbying has led to a sudden surprise alternative, some Congressional action to phrase a law at the 11th hour, and this is really worth considering.

It comes in the form of an amendment to the Communications Act of 1934 which will ensure Internet openness, to prohibit blocking lawful content and non-harmful devices, to prohibit throttling data, to prohibit paid prioritization, to require transparency of network management practices.

It also says that broadband remains an information service and that it cannot be ruled using section 706 of the Telecommunications Act of 1996.

The interesting thing is that this comes from the Republican side of the house, which in the past has not wanted to entertain any Net Neutrality law. We feel this new legislation is seen as the lesser of two evils, and it is being rushed through, with a first reading as we write this, in order to beat the FCC decision expected in February.

Verizon and AT&T would both have to change practices if this becomes law but not very much, and we think they could live with it, and as such they may even lobby in its favor, if it means preventing the FCC from taking Draconian measures. If so, they will certainly make it clear it will get their backing in order to let the FCC back off, and wait for the law to materialize. Although if the FCC did back off, we’re sure this legal effort would also evaporate, leaving the status quo.

There have been various private bills over the past 8 or 9 years to push through this kind of legislation and they all failed to get passed. If both sides of the US political divide now agree that legislation is better than Title II and section 706, then this time it may be different.

The draft net neutrality bill has been circulated ahead of its hearing in the Senate Commerce Committee and the House Energy and Commerce subcommittee on Technology and Communications.

The only worry is if this blind-sides the internet services contingent – companies like Google, Amazon and Netflix, and leads to yet another dead piece of legislation. Those companies need to give this the thumbs up or the US will be back to a legal stand-off. Cable also has to go ahead and back the legislation and it appears that in the background they have already given their assent to this approach.

So we could end up with the US and Europe going their separate ways on Net Neutrality. With the radicalization of the FCC, upset as it was by a US court revoking its previous Open Internet Ruling, and buoyed by the support of the President, leading to compromise in brand new legislation and Net Neutrality making a comeback in the US. While Europe has dealt with the situation an entirely different way, getting merger consents from the largest European cable operator not to block content or charge content businesses for connections or to tie up content exclusively, with the result being keeping leading content off OTT services.

Will these two separate approaches lead to the same outcome? They might, in that today there are only a few breaches in the US in the principles behind net neutrality, mostly the idea of wireless companies offering a paid fast lane, and virtually none in Europe – you might be excused for thinking that there is no need for either solution – but as operator consolidation continues, Net Neutrality becomes more and more vital every second unless you want to see an abuse that kills the usefulness of the internet stone dead.