While a number of people metaphorically clapped us on the back last week for revealing that Ericsson has lost control of one of its major Mediaroom accounts at Deutsche Telekom, one or two called us up to ask what we knew about Ericsson at AT&T which they didn’t. Had it really given such a huge contract to Ericsson?
We took another look at the release Ericsson issued during IBC and this time went over it more carefully. This time we did not see things quite so clearly.
Ericsson has been asked to work with AT&T on the evolution of its satellite and wireline TV platform, to integrate best-in-class DirecTV and U-verse technologies.
You can take this two ways – it certainly does not mean that AT&T will use MediaFirst – but it could mean that either AT&T will offer Ericsson the integration contract for a diverse range of technologies, or that Ericsson is one of many companies that AT&T just HAS to work with, if it wants to get out of the mess that comes from merging a satellite DTH system with an out of date IPTV system. Yes Ericsson might want to push AT&T towards using MediaFirst, but since it hasn’t really been built yet, that is unlikely to happen.
Faultline has to admit that in the melee that is IBC, we wrote up the story as if it meant the former, that Ericsson has got the full rights to integrate the system, others are suggesting that since the technology contracts are not yet in place to upgrade U-Verse and look for common technologies with DirecTV, Ericsson can only have a contract to continue to provide what has become legacy support to Mediaroom while AT&T sorts this out.
The rest of the announcement was confetti. AT&T has signed something, probably a year ago, and it gave Ericsson permission to release it at IBC, but insisted on wording that makes it so vague as to be meaningless.
Interestingly the release said, “This evolution will utilize leading technologies from AT&T’s U-verse platform and AT&T’s DirecTV satellite platform to deliver a premium TV experience, serving customers across both satellite and wireline access networks.”
So very specifically it is about wirelines and satellite and NOT about wireless. We anticipate that AT&T’s next major strategic move in video is going to be to counter the Verizon proposition, Go90 and it is likely that this will be one of the most strategic steps of all in its video strategy.
If AT&T can harness LTE, WiFi and LTE Broadcast to create a credible video experience around content already contracted to DirecTV, which can be extended to mobile, then AT&T will have played a trump card over Verizon, and both of them will have created a Mobile First TV service which is the start of something worse than cutting the cord – moving the TV umbilical-cord from the home to each individual smartphone owner.
This is all about hurting cable where its money is. Cable in particular and DirecTV as well, have inflated the cost of getting a decent TV service up to around $136 a month in the US. Keeping as much of that revenue alive at DirecTV, while the average rate of US OTT video services has been set at under $10 a month, despite the occasional service at $20 or $50 by Sling TV and Sony.
If Mobile First TV services promulgate, then an additional $10 for each of 3 or 4 different services per household, averaging one for each smartphone owner, will take $40 of that $136 TV budget directly from existing pay TV services, which will get added to the mobile bill each month.
AT&T’s problem is doing this without also destroying the DirecTV ARPU (average revenue per user) as well, which stands at around $107 well below that of Comcast’s combined ARPU of $136.
AT&T is known to have worked to create its TV Everywhere system, its U-Verse App, with Canada’s Quickplay Media, and while that doesn’t make Quickplay its long term technology partner of choice and it could always abandon it, AT&T has given the technology problem away to someone else, so why would it take it back just to give the problem to Ericsson to solve all over again. It uses Akamai for its CDN, Freewheel for its advertising decisioning and uses some aspects of Jinni in an in-house constructed recommendation system. There is a multi-DRM system run by Quickplay that takes in Widevine, Inside Secure DRM Fusion and Microsoft PlayReady, and it’s in play and working.
DirecTV for its part also has a DirecTV Phone App driven by voice commands, and offers its DirecTV Sunday Ticket sports App and its 4K Movie service, with more on the way, for instance an Hispanic service is planned and a Kids service was added in May 2015. These use Elemental Technologies encoding and packaging, and Cisco protection technology (Cisco VideoGuard Everywhere DRM). It can hardly say it will look at the technologies used by AT&T U-Verse and DirecTV unless it chooses one of these two options. Cisco would kill for this contact, as it is the premium US account, and it is one of the only two US majors in this market, the other being Arris. That system uses Limelight Networks for a CDN, Gracenote metadata, a cranky old in-house CMS, and Freewheel for its advertising decisioning.
That’s kind of hilarious in that the only sensible advertising system that AT&T can use is the one that it is using on both its existing OTT services, and that turns out to be from a company owned by arch-rival Comcast – in Freewheel.
This is only the OTT part of the equation. The other broadcast side – the DirecTV set top can be built in two variants, one for either IPTV or simply OTT, and a hybrid DTH version. The OS could be the same, the suppliers and second source could also be the same. If AT&T were to use something like RDK, it could drive down its costs and still keep control of its application layer.
It might opt for Zenterio, as Deutsche Telekom has, or SoftAtHome as France Telecom has, but we suspect that a simple Linux or Android TV device will be preferred unless it can adapt RDK for both systems. This is because those companies are not US in origin. It will also want to buy from Technicolor and Pace to keep its set top relationships intact. We have said in the past this was both the reason for the Technicolor Cisco set top deal, to keep it poised for Technicolor devices and Cisco cloud services; and for the Arris Pace deal – AT&T wanted to keep working with the old Motorola team, and it had no DTH option, enter Pace as the DirecTV second source.
So where is there room in all this for Ericsson. We don’t see it except supporting legacy Mediaroom and if that’s how it ends up, then Ericsson will have bought Mediaroom for nothing.
We also have to ask about DirecTV south of the border down Mexico way. AT&T now has Mexican cellular interests that can be partnered with DirecTV in Mexico in the name of Sky Mexico, a partially owned DTH service there.
Many think that AT&T’s broadening interest in non-US assets is a whim, and that it’s not serious, but to us it is a perfect opportunity to start once again on the issue of going global.
We think that AT&T will replicate whatever strategy works in the US and use that to target further telecom assets in Latin America. And Pace is virtually a household name in Latin America, once having 50% of the continent’s set top market.
AT&T has also contributed to a $500m investment in OTT content, courtesy of its relationship with the Chernin Group and various deals that link back to China and Youku Tudou as an investor. But we think that this is way too small an investment in OTT content, and that the real investment has been in buying DirecTV and that AT&T will leverage its content relationships to build a very traditional smartphone TV service. It already has experiments in LTE Broadcast, so if that makes up Verizon’s edge in this market it can match that.
But we can see just how far ahead of plan Verizon is with its Go90 service than AT&T. It announced this week that it has landed a $50 million commitment in advertising which includes an upfront deal with French player Publicis Groupe during the fourth quarter. It will bring 10 of its brands to advertise on Go90 and its considerable client list includes American Express, AstraZeneca and Citigroup, Coca Cola and Best Buy, Diageo, Heineken, Honda, Kelloggs, McDonalds, Proctor and Gamble, and Walmart, to name but a few.
AOL is also launching its own Live service this week, offering end-to-end production, streaming, distribution and monetization of live events using the company’s owned and operated properties, including AOL.com, The Huffington Post and TechCrunch plus 1,700 publisher partners across mobile, digital, over-the-top, and linear TV.
So right now the entire Mobile First TV is a priority for AT&T, and DirecTV is likely to take over its U-Verse TV services, and homogenize them, and perhaps Ericsson has a contribution to make here. It has always been a strong supporter of LTE Broadcast, but we cannot see a home for it in pure OTT video delivery.