The new Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella seems to be able to forgive and forget, and has shut down all of the patent legal actions – most of which were offensive, rather than defensive – against Google. This continues a trend of Microsoft working alongside Google to strike at Apple and other interests.
Their litigation went back years to when Microsoft was trying to use a huge swathe of software patents, many of them unworkable outside the US due to differences in legal frameworks, for basic operations on a device, initially targeted against Android handset vendors, kicking off in 2010 when Apple sued HTC, and it signed for Microsoft patents for protection against that suit. Much the same happened a year later to Samsung. Microsoft also sued Motorola in a suit that Google has acquired when it bought the company. Motorola naturally counter sued.
By 2011 Android was seen as a “FREE” handset operating system, and considered the biggest threat in the market. It was sufficient of a threat that a group of anti-Google players ended up paying $4.5 billion to buy out Nortel’s patent hoard when the company faltered and went under. This consortium included Apple, EMC, Ericsson, Microsoft, RIM and Sony and they won 6,000 Nortel patents, a move which stole the patents out from under Google’s nose, which after all was only hoping to use the patents defensively, to defend against Android in lawsuits from most of those same companies.
This was an unprecedented step in that all of these companies collectively own these patents, and they were all lined up against Google, with Apple paying the largest check at $2 billion. This was so that it could get a handle on LTE patents, and a seat at the table whereby Apple didn’t have to pay any, or at least not so much, royalty for LTE. Apple had been humiliated back in 2010 by its patent clash with Nokia, which it lost on all counts and ended up losing huge quarterly royalty payments from Nokia.
Microsoft was rumored at the time to have put $1 billion into the pot that bought out the Nortel patents to ensure that Google could not outbid them.
It was all of this that triggered the $12.5 billion purchase of Motorola, later that same year, a company Google has since sold on, keeping the bulk of its 17,500 patents, so that it finally achieved that defensive position it was after, whereby it could disrupt with impunity.
Now Apple is seen as the biggest threat to the industry, controlling key technology points such as HLS, in the OTT video eco-system, and refusing to bow to global industry standards. When one company is winning a technology fight, the combined response of its rivals is to build standards which level the playing field and for the market leader to resist the shift to standards. In most tech markets enterprises or operators could make a stand, but in a technology market dictated to by little more than consumer fashion, Apple has become destructive, has given up all attempts at innovation, and is in a struggle to maintain its margins purely by pushing technology which is proprietary in nature in order to bring it to market first. This is not only happening in video systems, but also in payment systems, SIM design and things like fingerprint recognition.
Just a few weeks ago we saw Microsoft and Google, along with other industry giants, Cisco, Intel, Netflix, Amazon and Mozilla, backing a new royalty free encoding group called AOMedia, which plans to get a system out which outperforms HEVC within 18 months and will update it every 18 months or faster. That same grouping wants to get to grips with other “proprietary” areas such as HLS, and replace it with a standard based on MPEG DASH, removing just in time packaging from the list of jobs needed in OTT video systems. There are almost certainly other areas that the two want to co-operate on. Apple, for its part, has been seen as central to the licensing of HEVC patents, alongside Samsung, as the two companies which ship the most devices. Apple is one of the companies listed by the MPEG LA on the HEVC patent base, while we struggle to see how it suddenly has patents which are essential to codec development. Apple and Samsung entered the patent arena for video by becoming licensees in the prior H.264 codec, but their patent contribution has never been broken out, nor the level of royalty share.
Interestingly companies like Microsoft and Cisco are not on the new MPEG LA list of essential patents for HEVC, despite most of the technology steps in H.264 being more or less identical. This is usually when companies “refuse” the terms of such a patent pool and walk away.
Microsoft and Google must have been finding it hard to co-operate with one another against a background of mutual patent hostility, and in order to make their internal teams open up, this step of killing off patent litigation was necessary.
Microsoft and Google have now dismissed all patent related actions which amount to some 20 lawsuits targeting technology in mobile phones, WiFi, web video and video game systems including all those that began with Motorola.
The companies have pledged to work together in other ways related to intellectual property, and will lobby for specific rules on a unified patent system throughout Europe.
We feel that Microsoft and Google have pretty much established where their respective market boundaries (hegemonies) lie, and for the time being will come ever closer together, for as long as they perceive Apple as a threat to PC and handset operating systems.