Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 October 2015

FCC’s concerns over nascent OTT biz killed Comcast-TWC deal

By Charles Hall

It was the FCC’s concern that a large and dominant broadband service provider, which was also a content owner and pay TV service operator, in the form of Comcast-Time Warner Cable, would hold back the growth of OTT services. In particular it might crush Netflix, Amazon, Hulu, YouTube et al including a myriad of startups. This prompted the FCC to turn thumbs down on Comcast’s acquisition plans and Comcast politely withdrew its offer and looked elsewhere for expansion.

FCC general counsel Jon Sallet said the FCC’s opposition to the Comcast-Time Warner Cable deal was caused by the combined companies’ ability to “throw sand in the gears” of online video distributors (OVDs or OTT services), which is still a nascent industry. The FCC never made public the details of its opposition because Comcast withdrew its offer before the FCC announced its findings. However, the FCC has just briefed the companies on its findings.

Sallet also made remarks on September 25 to the Telecommunications Policy Research Conference, according to a prepared text supplied to Multichannel News, “The core concern came down to whether the merged firm would have an increased incentive and ability to safeguard its integrated pay TV business model and video revenues by limiting the ability of OVDs to compete effectively, especially through the use of new business models.”

He cited Dish’s Sling TV service and HBO and CBS stand-alone service launches as the type of thing the Comcast-TWC would try to stop.

Sallet said, “We understood that entrants are particularly vulnerable when competition is nascent. Thus, FCC staff were particularly concerned this transaction could damage competition in the video distribution industry by increasing both Comcast’s incentive and its ability to disadvantage OVDs and thus retard or permanently stunt the growth of a competitive OVD industry. In doing so, consumers would be denied the benefits that innovative competition could bring.”

One of the FCC’s main concerns was the ability of a Comcast-Time Warner Cable to deter OTT services from accessing their networks by imposing onerous terms.

Sallet said, “The question was not only whether a single kind of action – access to devices, or data caps or interconnection or video programming terms – by itself would degrade competition. It was also whether the merged company would possess the toolkit that would allow it to put sand in the gears of competition through the totality of its efforts.”

Sallet said the FCC staff concluded that “the verifiable benefits of the proposed transactions – such as faster broadband speeds for TWC customers, cost savings, enhanced competition for business customers – were viewed by staff as incapable of outweighing the potential harms” of disadvantaging OTT services.

He said the improvements that Comcast would have brought to TWC’s broadband service was not sufficient to overcome the FCC’s other concerns.

This first ran in Rider Research’s Online Reporter