In a rather cynical move, Amazon has stopped selling the Apple TV and Google’s Chromecast streaming dongles through its online marketplace, claiming that the move is intended to reduce consumer confusion. With such clear branding, that excuse doesn’t hold much water, and this is simply an example of ruthless market practices – which should surprise no one. As of November, you won’t be able to buy a Chromecast or Apple TV through Amazon.
With the absolute failure of its Fire smartphones still ringing in its ears, Amazon is undoubtedly doing its utmost to protect the sales of its Fire TV net top and Fire Stick dongle, which both act as gateways to its Prime Instant Video service. But this protectionism seems a little paranoid, as early signs suggest healthy sales for the Amazon hardware.
Perhaps things are rather different behind the scenes, especially in the wake of the launch of the latest versions of the Apple TV and a redesigned Chromecast, as well as the newly announced 4K-ready Roku 4 box – a significant leap forward in the realm of micro set tops. It’s worth noting that other Prime-friendly devices, such as the Xbox One, Sony’s PlayStations, and the Roku family, haven’t been delisted.
In the last few weeks, news creeped out that Amazon would be withdrawing support for the Prime streaming application for both Apple TV and Chromecast, with Amazon justifying the removal of the products from its store due to them not interacting well with Prime – again, a pretty poor excuse for protectionist policies, given the ease of developing streaming apps. Make no mistake; despite the posturing, this is Amazon choosing not to make the Prime app available on those rival hardware platforms.
What’s more confusing is that this policy only seems to increase the cost of using Prime in the first place, as Amazon is voluntarily preventing owners of Chromecasts and Apple TVs from churning over to Prime via the devices – the installed footprint of which already outstrip Amazon’s offerings.
So Amazon apparently sees hardware as the key to its SVoD ambitions – a move that flies in the face of the wider industry consensus, in which hardware functions are widely being replaced by software, at each end of the process, from encoding all the way down to applications running on smart TVs or adapters. The industry would laugh at Netflix attempting to get into the hardware game, and Amazon should certainly not get a pass from apparently prioritizing hardware for its roadmap.
One possible explanation is that Amazon sees Amazon-branded CPE as central to its future strategy, likely as part of a smart home offering. With its Echo audio system acting as a gateway to the Siri equivalent, Alexa AI (and more importantly to the Amazon market), perhaps Amazon envisions its net top becoming the heart of a smart home, with the TV acting as a central UI.
Amazon is also looking to increase the proportion of its online customers that hold Prime memberships, and consequently have access to its video service. Currently, only about 20% of Amazon customers hold the annual Prime membership, which provides them with discounted and faster delivery, as well as the video service. Figures show that Prime members are significantly more valuable, and go on to buy a lot more things from Amazon, so perhaps Amazon thinks that boosting the sales of its Fire devices will help inflate this percentage.
The new Fire TV itself is a pretty capable unit, supporting HEVC and 4K video at a $99 price tag. That sets it apart from both Apple TV and Chromecast, which don’t support 4K resolutions. The Fire Stick doesn’t support 4K, but does come with a voice-enabled remote control, which brings the Alexa AI into play. Amazon also has a Gaming Edition of the Fire TV, which we don’t anticipate gaining much traction. Nonetheless, Amazon has gone as far as acquiring a gaming studio to provide content for the platform, which will likely prove a necessity, given the chicken-egg nature of developing games for a platform with no current market share, and a very small chance of ever achieving double-digit percentage share.
Amazon was also at the center of a very public dispute with publishing house Hachette, over its tactic of making certain physical books hard to buy through its marketplace, in an attempt to boost its Kindle e-book division. Strong parallels are being seen here between that book strategy and SVoD. It’s worth noting that Amazon never stopped the sale of rival e-readers though.