It is not too surprising that prior to the merger of Charter, Time Warner Cable and Bright House Networks getting the go ahead that we anticipate, we were bound to hear some dissenting voices and they started coming in this week led by Dish Networks and the National Association of Broadcasters (NAB) in response to the September 11th call for comments from the FCC.
Dish is in an unenviable position and has been trying to position itself vis-à-vis a broadband return path for as long as we can remember. Being a one way satellite network, it is now out on its own – DirecTV becoming a subsidiary of AT&T it now finally has the potential for fiber return paths from AT&T’s broadband arm. Dish unfortunately still has this issue to solve and has been talking about solving it with LTE Advanced, sometimes in the future on spectrum that it owns, but has yet to build out, or partner over.
This is why perhaps it is one of the first US pay TV operators to offer a full paid OTT service including live TV channels in Sling TV, partially to position itself as the “most affected” OVP by broadband dominance within cable.
And really that’s all that Dish has to say about these mergers, broadband dominance would give Charter a vested interest to prevent OVPs coming good. But that’s what more or less sunk the Comcast TWC merger, so perhaps it figures it needs little more. We think this is a matter of extent – we see a healthy rival to Comcast as good news.
At the end of its submission Dish listed 4 potential remedies, which it wants in place for the next 7 years. These are to bring in mandatory wholesale of broadband and to unbundle the Charter broadband business from the MVPD business (so now triple or quad play); to get New Charter to refrain from restricting third parties from granting online video rights to its rivals, bullying them with its massive buying power, much the same as Liberty Global was limited in Europe; make Charter offer its own video bundles alongside rivals bundles; and finally to agree to abide by open internet provisions for 7 years – so not engage in paid prioritization, or block rival services, and not to impose data caps and provide settlement-free interconnection
For our money we cannot see the FCC being half as strict as that with its remedies and really expect the FCC to see that this deal is the best way for the US to consolidate cable power.
AT&T, as you might expect, having just been allowed to complete one of the largest mergers in pay TV history, is less negative about the deal and merely called on the FCC to “review the transaction carefully and consider the impact of cable consolidation and coordination on emerging competition.”
Meanwhile NAB took a rather more circuitous route to asking the FCC to block the merger – it wants the entire deal suspended until the FCC completes a review of media ownership in the US.
This is another task set for the FCC by Congress which the FCC has seen as a poisoned chalice, better to delay than to embrace. If it creates a new rule on how many TV stations, newspapers and pay TV providers one company can own, then it may have a yardstick to measure and prevent the consolidation going through the industry, argues NAB.
Under the Telecommunications Act of 1996, the FCC is obligated to complete a review of its broadcast ownership rules every four years, and repeal or modify those rules that are no longer necessary in the public interest as the result of competition. The Commission failed to complete its 2010 quadrennial review on time and announced it was combining that review with its 2014 quadrennial review, which the FCC has scheduled to complete in 2016, making the gap 10 years.
“If the pending merger is approved, then the top four MVPDs will control 79% of the nationwide MVPD market, with the top 3 controlling two-thirds of the video delivery universe,” said NAB.
And its point is well made, that all these mergers have put local TV stations at a competitive disadvantage – but then again the shift to online video providers being allowed to qualify as MVPDs – a move that the FCC has long hinted at and saying it approves of, means that there is the potential for new organizations to emerge that challenge the cablecos, at least in pay TV.
“The gross regulatory disparities between the pay TV and the free TV industries are illustrated in any number of ways, including the sheer size of MVPDs compared to TV broadcasters,” said the petition. “The market capitalization of the combined AT&T-DirecTV, for example, is more than 200 times larger than the market cap of several of the most sizable broadcast TV companies.”
And NAB makes the point that broadcasters live purely on advertising but have been prevented by the FCC of selling advertising in a joint effort in the same market. However a merged cable company is allowed to do this.