A new report from the Video Advertising Bureau (VAB), exclusively citing Nielsen data, has come to the laughable conclusion that TV still retains 90% of viewing, even among millennials – and therefore is still a very valuable medium for advertisers. There are a number of reasons why this is wrong, as well as the larger issue at hand that TV advertising is scraping the barrel for statistical interpretations that can convince managers and shareholders that all is well with the industry.
You don’t have to go farther than the About Us tab on the VAB website to spot the bias: “the VAB is an insights-driven resource for advertisers, committed to quantifying the selling power of premium multi-screen TV content, overseen by our esteemed board of directors comprised of Ad Sales presidents from our member networks and MVPDs.” We’d argue that perhaps relying solely on Nielsen doesn’t really count as having an industry insight, and the report seems to prove us right.
We’ve long thought that the Nielsen numbers don’t give an accurate presentation of the market, and the rise of rivals and subsequent contract wins tacitly suggests that neither do the operators. However, some operators and advertising firms still cling to their inflated figures, as a higher number of reported viewers increases the value of their slots, and subsequently the price they can charge to their clients.
The report itself claims that TV remains the dominant platform across all demographics, with live TV still comprising the bulk of the viewing. It also concludes that 80% of millennial video viewing is on TV, and that the smartphone is stealing viewing from PCs.
Based on the Nielsen Total Audience Report, the VAB report lists total Q2 2015 TV viewers as 284 million, unchanged from Q2 2014. Computer viewers were down 8% to 134 million, and smartphone viewers had increased 16% to 132 million.
On the time spent breakdown, TV averaged 138h50m of monthly viewing, with PCS at 12h36m and smartphones at just over two hours. The report concludes that this gives TV 91% of total video viewing, with PCs on 8% and smartphones at 1%.
Even if those percentage figures are accurate, which we doubt is true, remember that the industry needs to know the value of the adverts, and not the total amount of time that video is being watched for. Declaring the TV the winner simply because it is powered on for the most time is misguided, as the important figure here is the value of the adverts, not the total minutes watched.
Another rather prominent issue arises later in the report, where the VAB lists time spent with multimedia devices (PCs, smartphones, net tops, streaming sticks, and AV viewing sources) connected to the TV as just under 29 hours a month for the 18-24 bracket – but an average of just over 23 hours for the combined brackets.
This means that the percentage breakdown of non-TV viewing among 18-24 year-olds is actually more like 25%, and while a 75% hold on the market is still dominant, we still argue that measuring in minutes still doesn’t convey the actual value. What’s more, that calculation doesn’t match up with the figures provided elsewhere in the report that focus on young viewers – in which the 18-24 bracket is listed at 80% TV, 17% PC, and 3% smartphone.
In addition, the report also doesn’t make it clear what proportion of TV viewing is attributable to ad-free OTT viewing. With these services, the high TV viewing time is worthless to advertisers, as that viewing is taking place inside ecosystems in which they can’t place their adverts.
In terms of each demographic, the VAB believes that TV accounts for 80% of the 18-24 bracket, with the same figure at 85% for 25-34, 90% for 35-49, 94% for 50-64, and 97% for those older than 65. We think the upper end of that scale is likely accurate, but without meaning to sound mean, we frequently walk in on elderly relatives napping through hours of TV viewing that these Nielsen figures would be classing as valuable.
And that’s the same problem you encounter with the logic displayed at the younger end of the scale – that since 80% of 18-24 viewing is on TV, TV must be the best way to engage them. Viewing time is not a suitable metric to judge engagement and the consequent value of TV advertising: we aren’t sure how many times that has to be repeated.
Even if a TV is on for five hours a day in a communal living room, if no one is paying attention to that TV and the adverts playing in the gaps between the content, then the value of those five hours must effectively be zero – as the advertiser derives no value from it. In order for these sorts of reports to hold weight, you have to be sure that the viewer is actually watching and absorbing these advertisements.
Even if viewers are actually watching the screen, instead of using the TV as background noise, we are well into the age of the smartphone, in which advertisements can’t hope to hold the audience’s attention while there are social media feeds to check and update, or notifications to dismiss. This isn’t a new paradigm either – the trope about electricity and sewage usage spiking during halftime exists for a reason, as viewers don’t hang around for the adverts.
But even during the most valuable video content shown on TV, the likes of Game of Thrones or the Super Bowl, TV viewers are using other screens to improve their viewing experience – to pull up facts or filmographies, engage with friends in real-time on social media platforms, or increasingly monitor the progress of their fantasy teams. The presence of these second screens immediately and fundamentally devalues the advertising on the TV.
The main point here is that five hours of TV viewing is not five hours with a captive audience. This is an audience that has grown accustomed to time shifting content and fast forwarding through the adverts, or simply negating advertising entirely through SVoD platforms like Netflix and Amazon. These OTT services rarely have adverts, and are increasingly popular – and there must be a considerable chunk of viewers who value the advertisement-free experience.
Ever since the first manipulation of JavaScript that lead to the invention of the popup ad, web advertising has been widely hated. Radio advertising is oft-critiqued for its obnoxiousness, and there are many anecdotal and personal accounts of the shift in TV advertising towards content that has to recapture the attention of the viewer from their smartphone. Can you imagine the popularity of an ad-blocker for TVs?
You can spot elements of the misguided thinking in the report being applied to other statistics, especially where the VAB concludes that growing smart TV penetration is an “impressive” sign of consumers investing in higher quality TVs – whereas it is really just a part of the natural TV refresh cycle, as new TVs are increasingly sold with internet connectivity as standard. That’s not a sign of shifting consumer demand, it’s simply a part of the refresh cycle and an improved feature set.