Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 February 2016

Internet TV looking more welcoming to NFL

By Charles Hall

The NFL is warming to the idea of delivering live American football coverage to fans online. After its historic free no-pay-TV-subscription-required live stream of a regular season game last October on Yahoo, rumors have been swirling about NFL’s future on the Web.

Last week, the annual NFL Super Bowl game was delivered online directly to TV sets for the first time ever, marking a new chapter in the transition to Internet TV. That game drew 4 million unique viewers online to watch the game, and the average viewing session for the game was 101 minutes. That’s an outstanding number, compared to the 1.3 million that streamed last year’s Super Bowl via NBC. Last year’s live stream had a Nielsen equivalent of 800,000 viewers per minute; this year’s game had 1.4 million viewers per minute.

The number of viewers watching video online grows each year. eMarketer estimates half of Internet users in the US – that’s 164 million consumers – now stream video online on a monthly basis. By 2017, eMarketer predicts that number will jump to 205.7 million consumers, representing 75% of the country.

Among Millennials and Generation Z viewers, online viewing is far more pervasive than traditional TV.  Internet TV is already nearing saturation levels among these viewers. According to eMarketer, 93% of Millennial Internet users are now streaming video on a monthly basis, and among viewers aged 18-24, 96% regularly watch Internet TV.

The NFL confirmed last week it was looking for a digital partner for the Thursday Night Football games. Apple, Verizon, Google and Amazon are interested in the job, according to a report in Variety, and AT&T and Yahoo, according to Bloomberg. Yahoo seems to be an unlikely bidder, as it’s in something of a tailspin financially and is rumored to be looking for a buyer.

Verizon probably has the best chance. It has been delivering NFL games to its wireless subscribers on their smartphones for years now, part of a special deal of mobile-only rights that Verizon acquired in 2012. It’s up to renew those rights after next year’s Super Bowl has concluded, and rumor has it NFL is looking to tie that deal to a Thursday Night Football deal.

AT&T could become an important digital player here: after acquiring DirecTV, it has rights for Sunday Ticket package; and the company has been touting, for a few quarters now, an upcoming Internet TV product that it’ll deliver to subscribers online and across devices.

To be clear, the Thursday Night Football digital rights aren’t exactly exclusive, as those games will also air on broadcast television – CBS and NBC are splitting up the schedule this year, with each network airing 5 games, and the NFL’s own pay TV network is airing all of Thursday Night Football games, too. It’s clear the NFL is looking to cast the widest audience (and content licensing revenue) net it can for the new season. But it marks the first time the NFL has invited an Internet TV partner to the table.

Alphabet’s Google has been interested in NFL rights for years, but it’s not clear how NFL Thursday Night Football games might fit into its global, Millennial- and Generation Z- focused Web TV programming strategy. On the other hand, offering NFL games would be a great way for Google to jumpstart adoption of its subscription tier of YouTube, called YouTube Red.

Last week’s Super Bowl raised yet again the perennial question about live streaming linear TV: how was the QoS – that is, quality of service?  And in the words of Brian Rolapp, NFL’s VP of media, “Can the Internet right now sustain 30 million concurrent viewers consistently?”

The NFL has a lot riding on the answer. It wants to deliver more football games online to viewers who are gradually moving away from broadcast television, and it has spent the past few months testing out live streams of its games.

The first test came in October last year, when it live streamed a game on Yahoo’s Websites and apps to viewers around the world for free. There were reports of pixilated images, pauses and buffering during game play, etc. Next, the annual Super Bowl game was live streamed last week directly to TV sets for the first time. Overall, the quality of CBS’s live stream of the Super Bowl was much improved over last year’s Super Bowl live stream quality. The live stream was delivered to TV sets via apps on Roku, Chromecast, Amazon Fire TV, Android TV, Apple TV, and Xbox One. And next, the NFL is looking for a digital partner to stream more games and work out the kinks of delivering live video online to large audiences.

As more live content become available to viewers to stream online, and as more viewers become interested in and comfortable with live streaming video content, the need for IP multicast will become more apparent. Events like last weekend’s Super Bowl highlight what Mark Ramberg, VP of business development at Akamai, refers to as an ‘OTT 1.0 experience.”

“There’s a consumer expectation being driven into our industry that over-the-top TV will be at least as good as cable or satellite. That’s a pretty tall order to deliver on a non-managed network,” Ramberg said at panel earlier this year. “In order to achieve those broadcast-quality experiences or better, that’s going to require a much different solution. As more and more content gets pushed through the Internet across this unmanaged network, and the demand for that continues to rise, the back-bone of the Internet is really going to be the bottleneck.”

One solution is IP multicast. It enables content to be delivered to multiple end users while only taking up the bandwidth needed to deliver that content to one user along the pipeline. IP multicast works something like broadcast on demand: end users “tune in” to a stream via their home routers, and the network of routers all the way back to the origin of content determines how many end users receive the same stream. This affords less congestion, better optimization, and ultimately reduction in costs for everyone along the pipeline.

Most Internet streaming is done through unicast, where each end user receives one video stream, or in the case of 10,000 end users, 10,000 video streams. When the content is different for each user – like it would be for, say, watching Netflix, or YouTube – the advantages of unicast are obvious. But what about when, in the case of the Super Bowl last weekend, hundreds of thousands of people are watching the same piece of content at the same time, and all are demanding video streams at the exact same moment to do so?

Last weekend’s Super Bowl game was also delivered to Verizon smartphones as part of a mobile pact Verizon made with NFL. Accessing live content on cellular networks presents even more of a congestion issue. In preparation for last weekend’s Super Bowl, Verizon added “hundreds” of cell sites in and around San Francisco, where the game was played, in order to accommodate increased demand during the game. Verizon CEO Lowell McAdam predicted Verizon would see a whopping 6 terabytes of throughput during the three-hour game.

Verizon, which is angling to deliver more live video content to its 100 million mobile customers, has been experimenting with an LTE multicast solution to address this congestion issue – also known as LTE Broadcast, or evolved multimedia broadcast multicast service (eMBMS).