While our friends at ThinkAnalytics and TiVo will both testify to the opposite, it is harder now to be in the video recommendations software business than ever, and to our mind it is likely to get substantially worse as machine learning takes a hand – offering cloud-based start-ups the chance to make inroads to the market, at the expense of these two and other established players.
The other issue is that recommendations were launched into the era when there was little VoD, but there were 500 channel services – it is definitely needed as a tool over and above the EPG, to navigate that many channels. Today the problem has reversed – there are now skinny bundles making up the bulk of the fresh offerings where recommendation software may be first harnessed, and they each have a multitude of VoD options – the problem is far more like that of Netflix than the older MSOs.
This problem is perhaps better solved by teaching a machine learning program and among live skinny bundles it may well be better to have access to social media trends on video than anything else and indeed chairman Eddie Young has talked up machine learning and AI in the ThinkAnalytics platform, although there have been no specific announcements or explanations about how this has been added.
In February, ThinkAnalytics pushed out two key releases – one that it had a new CEO, Gabriel Berger, who made his name among other appointments, driving sales for great rival DigitalSmiths, now owned by TiVo, along with news that it serves 2 billion recommendations a day to 200 million subscribers. This month it has added to that with the arrival of Rob Sowers as SVP of sales reporting to Berger. Sowers was the right hand sales man at DigitalSmiths when Berger was there – a time when about 7 out of the top 10 pay TV accounts in the US went with DigitalSmiths, leaving just crumbs in the US for ThinkAnalytics – the acknowledged market leader around the rest of the world.
It may be that these two believe they can “unhook” a number of the US majors – Comcast aside, which seem to have opted for an in-house system – which means that as they explore skinny bundles, AT&T, Charter, Dish and Altice – may all be searching for new recommendation options. So far, the largest ThinkAnalytics deal in the US is with cableco Cox.
In March, ThinkAnalytics also added a new SVP for EMEA and Asia Pacific who had been the European director of thePlatform, and previously worked at SeaChange International.
To put this all into context, in June 2016 our research arm Rethink TV forecast that the recommendation software market for pay TV would reach some $318 million by 2020 and extra big data and analytics applications would eat up some $135 million of that. By now those numbers should be around $200 million and $80 million respectively. We put ThinkAnalytics on around 23% of the market back then, and it could have grown to 30% by now, giving it revenues of something close to $60 million, by our count. ThinkAnalytics never reveals these numbers and jealously guards any clues to them.
But another overwhelming conclusion of that report was that around 50% of all recommendation opportunities were in the US in pay TV, but that in OTT video services, where operators were happier to play with recommendation strategies, this would be closer to 82%.
So, if you are not strong in the US, you are not strong in recommendations. Thus, one of two things seems to be happening at ThinkAnalytics – either it is merely bringing in management which will help it crack the American market. If this was the case, it would risk putting out of joint the noses of the long term ThinkAnalytics team, who got it this far.
Or ThinkAnalytics could be preparing for an exit and knowing that these two guys opened the door to a sale of DigitalSmiths at $135 million to TiVo some 4 years ago, they believe that over the coming one or two years, a similar exit can be had in the US – either IPO or more likely a trade sale.
The clue can be found in the chairman and co-founder Eddie Young who by reputation likes businesses where he can see them, in the UK primarily. We think it is likely that he would only countenance the US becoming the headquarters if the company was being prepared for sale and clearly these new leaders are US based. Another founder is Peter Docherty, operating as CTO, and there is no problem having a development team to a US firm living in Scotland.