Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

26 April 2018

Amazon’s Best Buy deal: surprise success story or nail in TV coffin?

Amazon has ousted Roku as the TV adaptor of choice to go in Best Buy’s in-house TV brand, Insignia, as well as in other Toshiba smart TVs sold in the Best Buy stores. It all comes as part of a deal for Best Buy to sell on Amazon, and for Amazon to gain a valuable retail footprint in its war to keep Alexa ahead of Google Assistant in the US high street. The Insignia and Toshiba TVs at Best Buy include Fire TV technology built in.

Insignia and Toshiba-branded Fire OS TV sets, called Fire TV Edition, will retail at Best Buy for something close to $400, with an Alexa-powered voice remote, and 4K UHD support – significantly undercutting most voice-powered TV sets which sit around the $1,000 mark.

On the surface this is Amazon giving Best Buy a lifeline with Alexa and Fire TV, which are selling like hotcakes, in order to stay ahead of Google’s Android TV onslaught into the voice assistant market Amazon currently dominates.

With the smart voice assistant battle becoming fiercer by the day, it would make sense for Amazon to exploit Alexa’s increasingly favorable position in the market by cutting out the middle man – and partnering with as many TV makers as possible to head off those cutting deals with Google Assistant. This may have been triggered by the rising popularity of Android TV among pay TV operators (see our forecast for Android TV out next week in Rethink TV).

First of all, Amazon must establish a respectable footprint for its Fire TV OS, for which Toshiba and Best Buy’s Insignia brand are the latest partners, following two previously failed ventures with US electronics makers Element and Westinghouse. The exclusive deal with Best Buy, coupled with CEO Jeff Bezos revealing Amazon Prime’s subscriber numbers for the first time (100 million globally of which the majority are estimated to be in the US), certainly had the desired effect – stirring up quite a media storm.

Insignia is a Best Buy brand in its own right, but in the past LG and Toshiba have actually built those TVs, and Samsung has been a partner for manufacturing in the past. Judging from the involvement of Toshiba in this deal, it looks like this is Toshiba mounting a comeback at the low end of TVs via Best Buy and Amazon.

Amazon has certainly learned from its smartphone flop, by entering the TV market first as a cheap dongle device, the Fire TV Stick, and then partnering with TV manufacturers to deploy its OS – here it is following the example of Roku and trying to put pressure on the brand, so that it can steal all its thunder.

We feel that even this collaboration may not guarantee Insignia and Toshiba will steal away a large share of the US retail TV market – and may well leave Insignia out on its own if, for instance, Amazon decided to go it alone and launch a TV under its own brand. If Amazon feels the main TV set offers it the best chance of owning the connected home, then it could either acquire a TV maker or go it alone, offering a central point of focus for Alexa to complement its Echo smart speaker devices. But this would be a major shift of focus for Amazon, which is both shifting from low margin businesses such as retail electronics, towards higher margin businesses – cloud and content; as well as its plan to push Alexa into most US homes, resulting in TV makers queueing to partner with Amazon on voice.

By shifting to Fire OS, Best Buy has allowed Amazon to oust Roku from Insignia and Roku’s stock price has suffered as a result. Insignia will cease making Roku-powered TV sets as part of the Amazon deal, however, TV sets from TCL running the Roku OS have taken a much larger market share than those from Insignia, giving the Best Buy brand no choice but to differentiate – where taking the hand of Amazon was the easiest option.

Voice-powered TV sets are however a weak way into the voice market – and most of them lack real metadata integration with TV services, so they look like pale imitations of Google Assistant and Alexa. Perhaps this is the lack of meta data integration or it is due to the weak natural language system choices of smart TV markers. The largest uptake of voice in the US is through the well-integrated Comcast Xfinity service, passing 13 million voice remotes and counting last year.

Currently in the North American market Samsung is pushing its Bixby smart assistant, while Sony has gone with Google, and China’s Hisense, which owns the Toshiba TV brand, has opted for Alexa. Then there are the hybrids, with LG and Vizio remaining impartial – using Alexa for TV functionality control but Google for searches. Voice technologies are one of the most hotly watched markets right now, with all eyes on whether this fragmentation across TV manufacturers will worsen, or whether a crossover of smart assistants within the TV ecosystem will become commonplace.

On one hand, the deal is about Amazon harnessing a physical retail store simply to accelerate uptake of Fire OS and Alexa, but of course the tie up really boils down to collecting more data from new consumer homes – in turn powering targeted product campaigns for Best Buy and Amazon on the e-commerce side, as well as boosting Amazon’s content business. It has the potential to be one of the most unlikely success stories in history, although others have argued the partnership has been over-hyped – pointing to the commoditization of TVs and the huge push required to overturn Roku’s success in the market running on TCL TVs.

A recent report from Faultline Online Reporter’s research arm, Rethink TV, anticipates North America to dominate the global voice TV remote market among pay TV operators, with 49% of instances installed in North America by 2022, from around 143 million devices globally.

“Our partnership with Amazon is exciting because we believe Fire TV Edition delivers an incredible user experience and further strengthens the growing connection between home theater, home automation and voice control,” said Best Buy Chairman and CEO Hubert Joly.

“These Fire Edition smart TVs by Insignia and Toshiba deliver beautiful visuals and all the movies and TV shows you love, with an experience that gets better every day with Alexa,” said Bezos.