Debates over whether public service broadcasting should be consigned to history raged long before Internet video and the dawn of OTT. They even predate pay TV going back to the first advertising funded commercial broadcasting services which accused their public competitors of having an unfair advantage through public subsidies.
The arguments have ebbed and flowed each way ever since, but so far public service broadcasting has held out with hardly any privatizations. If anything the tide has gone the other way as a few despotic governments have taken control of privately owned broadcasters. That even happened to an extent recently inside the European Union when in January 2016 the Polish government enacted controversial laws giving it power to appoint the heads of Telewizja Polska (TVP), which was semi-commercial, funded partly by advertising as well as a license fee. There have since been moves to bring TVP completely under state control and it has been criticized for slavishly toeing the line of the ruling Law and Justice (PiS) party.
Most recently the arguments have flared up again, this time in Australia where briefly it looked like state broadcaster ABC would finally be privatized after the Liberal Party, the largest member of the ruling national coalition, voted to sell it off on the grounds that it would save the tax payer $1 billion a year in license fees. This vote was part of the Liberal Party’s annual federal council in Sydney, with young members of the party loudest in their call for the “full privatization of the Australian Broadcasting Corporation, except for services into regional areas”.
That last phrase was an olive branch to opponents of privatization who had argued that it would result in loss of programming catering for regions and minorities. But opposition to privatization runs much deeper than that and the vote prompted a backlash both within the Liberal Party and outside which led to its leader and the country’s Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull revoking the vote with the statement: “The ABC will always be in public hands. It will never be sold. That is my commitment. It is a public broadcaster. It always has been, and it always will be.”
By the same breath Turnbull blocked attempts by the federal opposition to commit the country’s parliament to keeping ABC in public hands indefinitely. This was quite right for it is ludicrous to make such a pledge at a time when the future of public service broadcasting is unclear amid renewed debate in many countries. The rise of online distribution means that it is now possible to satisfy demands for local and niche content OTT through a mixture of free and paid for services. It is decreasingly the case that people in remote areas or who prefer less popular long tail content have to rely on public funding for their viewing.
This derails the longstanding argument that privatization of public broadcasters would diminish choice because commercial service providers race to the bottom and produce only content for the mass market. This argument has surfaced at various times almost throughout the history of TV, for example in a well cited 2009 paper entitled “The paradox of television privatization: When more is less” by Harvey B. Feigenbaum. This paper trotted out that familiar line that commercial broadcasters had little incentive to meet local or minority tastes. There was even then some truth in that argument at the very beginning of the OTT era, but that has been evaporating since and will continue to do so as high-speed broadband reach continues to extend.
The case for privatization was being made in the days of modem data communication, well before DSL based broadband started to roll out. A book called The Decline and Fall of Public Service Broadcasting by Michael Tracey, Director of the Center for Mass Media Research, was doing the rounds in the late 1990s after its publication in 1998. It argued that advancing technology, at that time satellite and cable TV, was conspiring with a crisis in liberal democracies to render public service broadcasting increasingly irrelevant. It was one of the first such publications to argue that commercial operators such as Sky were showing it was possible to thrive without relying on a compulsorily imposed charge, while acknowledging that public service broadcasting had played a crucial societal role up till then.
This argument has raged particularly strongly in the UK given the status of the BBC as the world’s second largest public service broadcaster by turnover and number of staff, just behind Germany’s ARD. Its position there was likened to the National Health Service or third-party motor insurance but with the difference that it is not a matter of life and death if people cannot access the BBC’s content. This idea of broadcasting being an essential service that might be subject to mutual security like healthcare was becoming extinct.
Meanwhile in France the country’s public broadcaster France Télévisions is on President Macron’s list for privatization, but he will have his work cut out tackling the primary targets such as the country’s rail network SNCF as the unions dig in for resistance.
Germany is an interesting case because it would seem most ripe for privatization given how expensive and inefficient public service broadcasting has become there. Its household license fee is about $250 a year compared with $200 in the UK, one of the next most expensive. This equates to about $110 per head per year in Germany compared with $84 in the UK and $60 in France.
Furthermore Germany’s two main public broadcasters ARD and ZDF are held in much lower esteem than the BBC or France Télévisions, regarded as peddling very low-quality content such as folk music shows and trashy love films, compared with the pay TV alternatives such as Sky Deutschland. Like public service broadcasters elsewhere they are struggling to compete for premium content such as live football and blockbuster movies.
Yet there is a historical resistance to paying for TV in Germany that has only been overcome partially over the last decade and all major political parties have been wary of confronting the issue so far. It is becoming clear that in Germany as elsewhere the combination of major pay TV providers and the emerging SVoD and SLin brigade are making public broadcasting increasingly redundant by providing a more diverse range of content. The BBC has hit back by pointing out that it was a pioneer in OTT with its iPlayer which is more popular that most commercial OTT services in the UK. But iPlayer could and should have become a huge and fast-growing source of revenue for the BBC and enable it to compete with big SVoD players – something it was reluctant to do, for fear it would lose its license fee.
There may be a way of softening opposition that was suggested in a German report by economist Justus Haucap, depositing the proceeds of privatization into a foundation that would buy selected programs of public interest and the required airtime. But that sounds like it would just prolong the death throes of public service broadcasting and continue wasting money. It does seem now it is just a matter of time begore the license fee cord finally starts being cut.