Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 June 2018

Politics and diplomacy mix with piracy over FIFA World Cup

The 2018 FIFA World Cup has stood out from other recent major sporting events when it comes to online piracy by dragging in countries rather than just rogue satellite operators and multiple small-time players.

India and Saudi Arabia are at the center of the storm for different reasons, with the former still shaking off accusations it does not do enough to curtail the rampant piracy afflicting movie as well as live sports content there in the face of explosive growth in broadband access.

The case of Saudi Arabia is more specific, resulting from its diplomatic spat with gas-rich Qatar, which also involves Egypt, Bahrain and UAE (United Arab Emirates). These four states cut diplomatic relations with Qatar in 2017 over alleged support for Iranian-backed terrorist groups in the region, while also imposing blockades on trade. The stand-off has its origins in regional conflict between Saudi Arabia and Iran in the light of Qatar’s good relations with the latter.

Qatar denied the allegations, but this has not reduced the tensions. The piracy angle is that Qatar’s BeIn Sport holds exclusive live rights to all 2018 World Cup games in the Middle East and North Africa, which meant it would have been providing access to Saudi Arabia. But after the latter imposed the trade ban there was no legal way for Saudi Arabians to watch their team at the World Cup, having qualified for the finals.

Before the trade war BeIn had 900,000 subscribers in Saudi Arabia representing about 40% of its customer base. Instead Saudi viewers were offered access to an illegal feed provided by Saudi operator BeoutQ, which has been effectively redistributing the BeIn content. In fact this surfaced before the World Cup in early May 2018 when BeoutQ retransmitted beIN Sports’ streams of the European Champions League semifinal between A.S. Roma and Liverpool with just 10 seconds additional latency.

This has become such a hot potato because the Saudi Arabian government has been accused both by FIFA itself and also EUFA, Europe’s governing football body, of being complicit in the pirated streaming in order to provide its citizens with access to the games. After the illegal streaming of Champions League games for which it is responsible, EUFA threatened the Saudi government with legal action given that BeoutQ’s illicit streams were airing on Riyadh-based satellite provider Arabsat. EUFA also suggested that BeoutQ was actually based in Saudi Arabia which the government denies.

The call for action against Saudi Arabia has also been supported by NBCUniversal’s Telemundo which said that BeoutQ had been illicitly redistributing its live feed as well. NBCUniversal paid FIFA $600 million for the US Spanish language rights for both the 2018 and 2022 World Cup tournaments.

After the World Cup kicked off BeIn inserted in its broadcasts FIFA’s statement warning BeoutQ customers they were watching a stolen feed of the World Cup, but BeoutQ just blotted this out with its own information bar. However the ante has been raised with another broadcaster outside the region piling in, UK-based group of sports channels Eleven Sports Networks. It does not have World Cup rights but said that other sports content had been pirated by BeoutQ.

There were signs this week of Saudi Arabia caving in to the pressure and acting to block the streams although they were still quite widely available. With Saudi Arabia exiting the World Cup at the group stage the incentive for keeping the pictures available has been reduced anyway. The country’s not so football mad that its people will be watching the remaining games in large numbers, except perhaps the final.

In the case of India there is no suggestion the government has been implicit in any piracy, but just negligent in tackling it. Sony holds World Cup rights there and was particularly concerned over the piracy threat in the run up to the tournament, working with the country’s anti-piracy group Markscan over both technical and legal measures. This included Markscan sending out pre-emptive warnings to piracy websites, although early feedback indicates these have not been effective at curtailing the activity. That is hardly surprising since naming and shaming cuts little ice with piracy sites unless backed up by legal and technical force.

The Indian situation was exacerbated by some disputes between Sony as rights holder and one or two local cable operators over carriage rights, which made World Cup pictures temporarily unavailable in some regions and so stimulated piracy. Sony blocked Indian MSO Manthan in Kolkatta at the start of the tournament until it paid up $148,000 in part payment of outstanding fees. This meant that opening matches were not shown causing civil riots and arrests in some areas. A final balance of $370,000 was due on or before July 5th to clear the debt with the lingering threat of further blackouts.

At least one other Indian MSO, Ortel Communications, was also cut by Sony for alleged non-payment of dues during the World Cup, reminding us that there is still something of the wild west about pay TV in the country. This has been embarrassing for India given its pariah status in the US which has placed the country on its blacklist of those failing to protect US copyrights and patents properly. India was accorded the ‘priority foreign country’ label, which is the lowest level on an annual score of how well countries protect US patents, copyrights and intellectual property rights generally.

Africa has also experienced its fair share of piracy during this World Cup, with regional DTH operator MultiChoice the primary victim as holder of the rights across multiple Sub Saharan countries. Ghana’s Fly TV owned by Nour Vision Ghana was one of the more supposedly respectable outfits accused of pirating the Multichoice signals via its SuperSport suite of channels. MultiChoice has obtained an injunction against Fly TV after it established the Ghanaian operator had not acquired the rights either for pay TV or Free to Air distribution.

Over in the UK some fans were turning to pirated streams for a different reason, the ineptitude of commercial broadcaster ITV’s online streaming service. It had suffered from glitches or failed to cope with the heavy traffic during opening matches of the 2010 and 2014 World Cups but with streaming technology now more mature a repeat was not expected. With ITV sharing the rights with non-commercial state broadcaster BBC, this opening fiasco led to a spike in viewing of pirated streams.