Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 June 2018

EU content reform provokes every emotion from outrage to disgust

While the US seeks to stifle start-ups in the internet era by unraveling net neutrality, European regulators have a plan in place to similar effect, but with every intention of benefiting content owners. A new censorship reform could potentially harm OTT industry players – in what opposers have coined a “vote for mass internet censorship”.

The controversial approval, made by the European Parliament late last week, did not sit well with industry groups including the EBU (European Broadcasting Union), which has declared the move an outrage, while publishers have applauded the decision. It means publishers can now wave legal tools for online copyright claims in the same manner as used in offline content in the broadcast, movie and music businesses, spelling bad news for Google and Facebook who are now required to prevent users uploading copyrighted content onto their platforms.

The reform will help control content scraping and, as a result, we suspect help stamp out fake news in the process, although the European Parliament has not specified if the recent events stemming from fake news contributed to reform votes.

Google, among other US internet titans and anti-copyright campaigners, has slammed the decision, claiming violations against free speech and also wrongly suggesting it will prevent social media and content platform users from sharing links, which is not the case. Don’t be surprised if Google stops allowing YouTube users to share links and then proceeds to point the finger at the European Parliament.

Specifically, Google is arguing against Article 13 which means it must block copyrighted content, while Article 11 means any content such as news which does appear on platforms like Facebook, means a fee must be paid by the platform owner to the original content publisher.

Internet pioneers have rallied together, including Wikipedia founder Jimmy Wales, to tell European Parliament President Antonio Tajani he was making “an unprecedented step towards the transformation of the internet from an open platform for sharing and innovation, into a tool for the automated surveillance and control of its users”.

The EBU wrote in a separate statement: “The European Parliament has failed to strike a reasonable balance between providing transparency and information to authors and performers while, at the same time, ensuring the workability and pragmatism to do so.”

Parliament will decide for itself in July if its reform has missed mark and if it needs a more balanced approach to copyright, as internet warriors claim.

EU rapporteur Axel Voss said: “This vote marks the first step of the parliamentary procedure to adopt copyright laws fit to meet the challenges of the internet. The last laws to address copyright in the information society date back 17 years and the internet of today is fundamentally different to what it was in 2001.”

“Creators and news publishers must adapt to the new world of the internet as it works today. There are opportunities, but there are also important drawbacks. Notably, news publishers and artists, especially the smaller ones, are not getting paid due to the practices of powerful online content-sharing platforms and news aggregators. This is wrong, and we aim to redress it. The principle of fair pay for work done should apply to everyone, everywhere, whether in the physical or online world. The committee position aims to ensure that widely recognized and observed copyright principles apply to the online world, too. A world which certainly must remain a champion of freedom of expression, but in which our rules-based society should also be reflected,” added Voss.