Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 July 2018

Broadcom merger with CA – bizarre and unexplainable – we think

Broadcom has announced a merger with CA Technologies, the once infamous Computer Associates, which is embedded in the mainframe era, which has flat revenues, and which doesn’t make chips at all. Broadcom CEO, Hock Tan, will have a lot of explaining to do to make this deal work – it is a million miles from the deal he sought in buying Qualcomm, and unless there is some unholy marriage between agile development and DevOps and chip architectures, he is paying 4.5 times revenues for a dying company from the last century.

CA is described as one of the world’s leading providers of information technology management software – it came out of the ancient art of Systems Management, back when hardware servers needed constant monitoring to keep afloat. It has shifted into software development through acquisitions which have included SourceClear, Runscope and Veracode during the past 18 months alone. It is the Cisco of software acquisitions with probably 100 deals in the past 10 years.

Broadcom says it will pay $44.50 per share in an all-cash transaction with an enterprise value of $18.4 billion.

The market does not agree with Hock Tan that CA will add to mission critical technology and while the markets were only awake long enough to cut 2.5% off the company’s value, overnight trading was showing a fall closer to 8.5% and rising – close to a $10 billion fall in its value.

Our worry in the Faultline market is the move at Broadcom away from media – full band capture tuners, set top chips and technologies like MoCA – where it may sense it lacks sufficient margin for its CEO’s liking, which will mean ceding control of these technologies out of the US, and probably in to Chinese hands.

Our guess is that the fall in value will make Tan think again about this transaction, or at least he will have to explain it with some fairly radical ideas, about how he is going to extract $18 billion of value out of a boring old mainframe business. CA at least has predictable and recurring revenues, operates across 40 countries and holds 1,500 patents.

CA runs in three segments – Enterprise Solutions, Mainframe Solutions and Services. Enterprise Solutions is software for planning, development, and management, the Mainframe segment is based entirely on IBM z Systems platform and includes DevOps and enterprise security. There may be a play here for Broadcom, placing key roots of trust onto chips to support enterprise cyber-security. Services is simply implementation contracts with low margins.