Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

19 July 2018

Sinclair Tribune hits likely legal roadblock, Pai changes course

Earlier this week, FCC chairman Ajit Pai seemed to experience an about turn on the subject of US broadcaster Sinclair buying Tribune and ending up with control of local news to around 72% of Americans.

Sinclair is widely understood to have been instrumental in Donald Trump’s presidential success, with senior management and ultimately the controlling Smith family, telling employees to push the Trump agenda throughout the election. The understanding was that in return Donald Trump would allow the owners of Sinclair to bypass the 39% rule in buying out Tribune. This rule says you cannot own TV stations that reach more than 39% of all Americans.

Now despite making statements about the FCC getting back to its old job, and not trying to police America’s media, FCC chairman Ajit Pai has palmed off the merger to an administrative judge, saying that the move whereby Sinclair bypassed the 39% rule, was to sell off the TV stations to friends and family, but in effect to continue to control them.

Pai made a statement this week saying, “Based on a thorough review of the record, I have serious concerns about the Sinclair/Tribune transaction. The evidence we’ve received suggests that certain station divestitures that have been proposed to the FCC would allow Sinclair to control those stations in practice, even if not in name, in violation of the law. When the FCC confronts disputed issues like these, the Communications Act does not allow it to approve a transaction. Instead, the law requires the FCC to designate the transaction for a hearing in order to get to the bottom of those disputed issues. For these reasons, I have shared with my colleagues a draft order that would designate issues involving certain proposed divestitures for a hearing in front of an administrative law judge.”

By pushing this away to a court, Pai can say that he was not the one who blocked the deal, and Trump can insist that he has not reneged on any secret promise to push the deal through (if there ever was such an agreement). We would not be too surprised to see tweets criticizing Pai’s move, although there is a good chance that Trump just does not want to be stained by association with what is starting to look like a “back-scratching” deal that may impose a political powerbroker that Trump has to kowtow to.

This looks like an about turn by Pai and is at odds with the statements he has previously made publicly about Sinclair. The interesting thing is that TV is losing its political clout and social media is beginning to take on the mantle of the media which can get a man elected or not.

As broadcast TV stations, and in particular local news, become less relevant to American lives, the power to win elections will fall to services like Facebook. Can you imagine if Mark Zuckerberg had been found asking staff to alter Facebook comments to be in favor of Trump? Oh, that’s right, he has pretty much been accused of something very similar and spent time in front of a government committee.

In the past, Congress has been very aggressive about individuals like Rupert Murdoch, who wanted to get around the 39% rule and defended the limit with votes in Congress which were not far short of unanimous. Had Sinclair breached this rule, we are pretty sure the rule would have been changed by Congress.

An administrative judge cannot be instructed to find against the merger but may well kill the deal or impose such limitations on what the merged company can do, and what it has to dispose of, and how it must go about the process, that Sinclair will no longer be interested in acquiring Tribune.

As the power of TV stations reduces, through less eyeballs being attracted to broadcast TV, it is likely to lose its control of local and national sports to OTT services. At that point, broadcasters end up little more than aggregators of other people’s content and locally made news service, which for the most part are also in decline. It could be argued that all the TV stations in the US may one day get a court’s blessing to be merged into one, because so few people still view them, but that is not likely to pass muster during any Trump administration.