Is the mobile industry going to make the same mistake in cellular TV as broadcast and cable TV appears to be making now ‘ and try to drive it through advertising alone?
There are multiple ways to deliver video content to a mobile phone, most of them really just different business models, and the chances are that all of them will be tried.
The biggest segment of cellular consumers, those that use the mobile phone the most often and most lovingly, are the young. And there is every reason to think that the young don’t have an awful lot of free cash to spend on anything but they will in the future. It seems logical then to let advertisers pay for the services that will bring TV to the mobile phone?
There are many arguments that support this and at the National Cable TV show in San Francisco last week, speakers said boldly and clearly that they needed to get into the mobile telephony act, and that they saw that some content would be paid by advertising, some by subscription and some a bite at a time.
All the high ground of late has been taken up, on mobile TV, by the DVB-H technology that is backed by most European equipment makers, and a few other similar technologies. Whether this technology is DVB-H, or Qualcomm’s MediFLO, or Digital Multimedia Broadcasting, or some other variant, they all operate virtually the same way conceptually.
A second broadcasting network needs to be build to work alongside the existing mobile base stations, using a different frequency band, and the two signals, cellular and datacasting, both feed the phone. These networks are relatively cheap to build compared to cellular base stations, likely to operate anywhere from 450 Megahertz to 1.6 Gigahertz, frequencies mostly below cellular frequencies which means they penetrate further, and can be sustained with less power and just 40 or so broadcasting towers can cover a country the size of the UK compared to thousands of cellular base stations. It’s still a cost, but in terms of the stakes we are discussing, it’s a manageable one.
The questions immediately arise, who builds these networks? Is it the mobile operator? The telecom equipment or handset maker, or is it the content owners or broadcasters?
Each one leads to a different business model.
The mobile operator simply assumes that it has the responsibility because this will give them a chance to differentiate their services. What’s the point of offering a phone, which is more expensive to build which has an extra radio built in, and which the cellular operator has to pay for, unless the cellular operator gets something out of it. Anyway, TV that relies on advertising will want registration, demographic and viewing data and that can only be collected by the cellco, since it is the only one that can identify who is receiving the signal.
Cell phone TV is a natural place for the cellular operator to differentiate its offerings from other cellular operators. They can show off their content buying power, secure the best content deals and take all their cash in advertising revenue, and hardly raise their prices for the new special phones. The cellular operator is used to dealing for spectrum and understands the radio issues involved.
But at the same time a network run by an equipment operator can be used far more efficiently. It can offer one set of channels to one cellular operator and another set to another, centralizing the advertising buying power across any number of networks. They might also be better able to integrate the TV signal with their devices if they are handset makers.
There is a case that companies like Crown Castle, a UK company which owns cellular towers, and which is operating a DVB-H trial in the US, could just as easily act as a conduit to bring together cellular TV.
It could operate the infrastructure for multiple cellular operators and ensure that one, rather than several, DVB-H networks were built in each territory, which could be shared by the bigger and more ambitious cellular operators.
In the US, CDMA intellectual property house and chip maker, Qualcomm, has already gone ahead and bought its own spectrum so that it can offer these services using its MediaFLO technology.
The very idea of content owners operating any kind of network is anathema, but content operators (multiple service operators) like the US cable TV companies or US broadcasting networks, would find that operating a DVB-H or other type of cellular TV broadcasting network, would make a lot of sense.
It would be a first step into cellular revenues, and the TV companies already have a negotiating position with the broadcast networks which offer channels and who sell yet more advertising. They can lump together phone content negotiations with the broadcast/cable networks, with their existing deals, for best results. The cable companies already have, in many instances, direct content deals with the major content holders.
Content companies wouldn’t even need to negotiate directly with cellular companies in this instance, and yet they all, to a man, already have solid content deals with cellcos.
In the end the best way to get ALL of these benefits, brand differentiation at the cellco, technical integration at the device level, good transmitter coverage and RF know how and cheap access to existing channels, is for each of these clusters of companies to join together and jointly fund the experience and then those companies that are making the most money from the process, gradually buy out the others. This is how many industries are initiated.
In Europe and the US almost all of the trials for TV to cellphones are being managed by consortia, so this logic appears to be sound.
The mistake, as we see it, is that really the cellcos appear to be ready to ape broadcasting and cable TV operators, just as the advertising driven business models begin to show their age.
Already cable operators also offer HDTV, Video on Demand and Pay per view, so can these also be offered on a cellular broadcasting system? The short answer is that only broadcasting can be offered (technically it’s datacasting), which means that using digital rights management or conditional access systems, broadcast content can be delivered to only those that pay extra. Advertising business models can live side by side with pay per view and paid subscription models.
But to deliver video on demand over a cellular network is tough. Even with the reduced screen size of a mobile phone, the dedicated data path needs to be about 20% of the data that is sent to support a full digital TV screen, say 280 kbps to 380 kbps. And that stretches the capability of data services offered on Cellular networks now, and into the near future.
But several of the DVB-H experiments and technology, have focused on using the same or neighboring spectrum to send full images alongside those that are delivering mobile TV. So a DVB-T signal is sent for your TV, and the same programs are sent using DVB-H for your handset, meaning that you can watch the same things whether or not you are at a mobile phone or at a TV.
Now that business model leaves even more to be desired. People that want to watch TV on their mobiles want to watch things that they cannot get on their TV. The great bulk of content effort here has been about either creating specialized short form content for the mobile or bringing live sporting events to people that are on the move.
So if you have the same content on digital terrestrial TV as your mobile, there will be less desire generated by the mobile public. We have already seen from a research report this week that cell phone users are not requesting TV services on their phones (see separate story).
And as we have said, if this needs to be a paid video on demand service, i.e. a small amount of the viewing audience wants to watch some TV events, but at varying times, then the problem of sending TV to a phone using the cellular carrier will have to be solved and it’s not trivial. There are many moves afoot to reduce the entire process to an IP delivery, but as we shall see when we explore that (hopefully next week) IP which relies on fixed addressing, doesn’t sit well with mobility.
With the addition of hard disks for mobile phones and with the prospect of these rising to 5 or 10 Gigabytes almost immediately and to 60 or 100 GB in the not too distant future, we have the very real prospect of huge content libraries appearing on mobile phones stored under the control of DVR software. The problem with this is that if a phone viewer stores a program, they may want to play it back at a later date on a better screen than is available on the phone, like their TV set.
If only 350 Kbps is available to download a signal, then that’s all that you’re going to see on a bigger screen. It would look awful. Instead the option of viewing a program there and then on your phone, but storing it at ‘full’ TV density HAS to be solved.
There are a number of ways of solving this problem. Either a) Ramp up the bandwidth for each phone and download the full definition program to your phone, and downgrade it on the way to the phone’s screen. When you plug your phone into a TV later, it can play out at full definition.
But that won’t be possible any time soon with a cellular carrier and it would use up way too much of a phone’s battery to absorb a DVB-T program and play it back later (one of the key reason for DVB-H and all its competing variants being invented).
This is why WIMAX starts to look enviable to a carrier that wants this type of service. A WiMAX network can be built where VoD can easily happen, at speeds (2 Mbps) that can keep up with the FULL TV screen definition and play out in lower definition on the phone screen.
A hybrid of this is rather complex. We can initiate the recording of a VoD program using our mobile phone, but the real signal can be dropped down to our own home DVR automatically over a fixed broadband line. The phone can either take a downgraded data stream so that the customer can view it now, and the program can be saved for the customer at home o view in full definition later. Another way would be for the phone’s version can be streamed from your home over your own broadband line to your cellphone.
So a system could be built where customers buy with their phones, store on their home DVR, play back on their phone.
This last version works also if you want to take video on the road with you and play it, say, in your hotel room. Your phone can become to key to access such a service.
But it does require a lot more technology, co-ordination between your DVR and your phone, and VoD servers that can serve both your phone and your home through a converged network.
Exploring WiMAX we can see that it could be used to offer VoD experiences to customers on cellular phones on home phones, over the internet and on a set top. The same type of video file can be used in each instance, a full H.264 file perhaps, dropped into IP packets and either streamed or buffered.
The central server can mark the film down as ‘purchased’ or ‘rented’ once a cellular transaction is committed. Play out or rendering can then be over a broadband wireless service to any device, anywhere within the service’s range and it doesn’t need to know or care what the device is. Your phone can throw away the packets it doesn’t need for smooth viewing on the phone, but just as easily you can plug in your phone into a screen on a TV and use the phone as a set top or DVR or both. Battery will remain an issue, when viewing on a phone which is not plugged in as it is an issue with DVB-H.
Right now TV viewing is being decimated by other electronics distractions, VoD, internet use, DVRs, DVDs and gaming devices. These markets are all fighting for the attention of consumer eyeballs and the one that is missing out the most is advertising driven broadcast (and eventually cable) TV.
So if cellular companies opt to invest in free to air DVB-H class models, they will begin as gimmicks but rapidly be driven lower down the ‘desirability’ stack, as other cellular TV services which use the cellular carrier, begin to become more popular.
The worst of all of these is any service that is delivered by open Internet Protocol. As phones open up to IP, then the way a piece of video or TV gets onto a phone is going to become complex.
Content can then be downloaded to PC and transferred to a phone; customers could record a TV program on a DVR then transfer it; they might buy content as a DVD or Sony UMD and transfer it; they could download from the internet and put it on the phone; buy from their cellco and store it, or view a broadcast DVB-H program and store it’ all these and more routes will appear as methods to get video content onto phones.
And it is the service that caters for all of these routes and makes them all appear much the same in terms of value, that will win.
In a very short time frame, Faultline suspects as little as five years, a value hierarchy for video content on cellphones, which is integrated into the existing value hierarchy for video content everywhere, will emerge and it will take roughly the same shape that conventional TV is taking. That is, free to air advertising driven content will be the least desirable for a phone owner, and a fully integrated buy to keep, and store strategy with and play back across multiple devices, will be the most highly valued.
Anyone that bets their shirt ONLY on new broadcasting networks for cell phones, which rely entirely on advertising, will be missing the point and losing their shirt.