Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 April 2005

Confident Cable still has a nervous tic about the Telco onslaught

The US cable TV companies are rapidly moving to solidify their market share lead over the phone companies in broadband. That as the easiest message to divine at last week’s NCTA (National Cable Television Association trade show).

They’re snazzing up their TV offerings to compete with the coming onslaught from the telcos. They’re beefing up their video-on-demand (VOD) and interactive TV (ITV) offerings to make life tougher for the two satellite TV companies. And they’re accelerating their rollout of telephony service to take revenue from the phone companies. The only area they seem to have a weakness in is wireless phone and media services, something the US phone companies have a chokehold on – Verizon with Verizon Wireless and the SBC-BellSouth duo with Cingular and its recent acquisition of AT&T Wireless.

Cell phone dominance shouldn’t be discounted in the bundling wars. After all, “everyone” has one. If bundling success comes from having a “grand slam” quartet of services – voice (telephony), data (broadband), video (TV and Internet-delivered) plus mobile (phone and data), then the cable TV companies would come up one card short. The cablecos acknowledge their need for a wireless pipe to consumers, but no consensus has coalesced as to what moves they should make to fill their missing piece. The need for a wireless pipe and the kind of devices that are needed is obvious when talking about voice, less clear when talking about wireless delivery of instant messaging, gaming, music, video and information.

Various “buy” or “build” solutions were bandied about:
-Buy a cell phone company. There aren’t many left. Sprint-Nextel is the largest remaining wireless service that might be a purchasable candidate. As it is, the telcos already run some 85% of the cell phone services that US mobile phone customers use.
-Build a network. It’s not certain whether that should be a next-generation traditional phone service or some sort of WiMAX network – the kind of thing Craig McCaw is working on with his wireless broadband company Clearwire.

Nevertheless, the cable TV companies and their suppliers are very positive about where they stand vis-‘-vis the telcos. All their public announcements and panel discussions exuded their belief that the recently completed upgrades of their coax wire network gives them a major advantage over the phone companies and their century old copper wires. ‘We have the fattest pipe to the home’ was their frequent cheer. The proof was the assertion that the recently completed upgrade to their network permitted delivery of digital content and the offering of broadband and telephony. The cost of the upgrade was cited variously at between $60 billion and $100 billion, and it was said often during the NCTA.

It was only in a few backrooms that concern was heard about recent phone company moves on two fronts. One is the telcos’ highly publicized move to fiber optic. Particularly alarming is that Verizon is reportedly seeing a 20% take-up of homes in the areas that it passes with its fiber optic cable. Even assuming that some of those 20% are not switching from cable TV but rather from satellite TV or upgrading from over-the-air broadcasts, that would still be a major revenue blow to the cablecos. The second concern comes from the possibility that the telcos are quietly rolling out ADSL2+ in a few places where 15 Mbps up and 2 Mbps down are being offered unexpectedly.

Consequently, the cable companies are pushing a DOCSIS 3.0 initiative that could increase their broadband speed to as high as 200Mbps down/100 Mbps up by 2006. The DOCSIS 3.0 spec is being anticipated by Cisco, which, by using chips from start-up BroadLogic, could have head-end gear and a new generation of DOCSIS 3.0-based gear being deployed by 2007.

The speedier gear is reportedly already in field tests in Japan, where the cable TV companies have experienced the debilitating impact of both ADSL2+ and fiber-optic-to-the-premises. The cable TV companies in South Korea, where the phone company runs fiber optic to high-rise residential buildings and CAT5e Ethernet cable from there to the residence; France, Britain and Scandinavia have also felt the impact that occurs when the phone company offers higher broadband speeds.

The cable companies have a number of advantages the phone companies will be hard pressed to match, however. They already have:
– Content deals in place
– TV bundles worked out
– High-speed wire to the home
– Less bureaucratic management
– More technology-centric workforce – the phone companies still have hundreds of thousands of employees that belong to the Communications Workers of America union.
– Back office and IT operations that are more modern and have fewer diverse systems.
Remember all the horror stories that came out recently about the problems WorldCom, now MCI, experienced with back-office systems when it made acquisitions. The phone companies have made acquisitions of companies with widely diverse IT and back-office operations on a much larger scale than WorldCom.

One area that seems a weakness for both cablecos and telcos is customer service. Neither has done much to shine in that area, but the cablecos have a more decentralized, less bureaucratic management structure that could give them an edge in taking care of the end-user.

One other major advantage the cable companies have is the toughness that has come from being in a competitive environment. The two US satellite companies have forced the cablecos to improve in a number of areas; customer service, DVRs, VOD and service bundling and pricing.
Setting the wireless issue aside for the moment, the question becomes whether it’ll be easier for the cable TV companies to add telephony than it’ll be for the telcos to upgrade their networks and add TV programming.

Comcast COO and NCTA convention chairman Steve Burke welcomed the huge and enthusiastic opening crowd by saying that two changes had been made to the 2005 NCTA show. One was that there would be less focus on deal making, content deals had been a highlight of prior shows, with more focus on thinking about cable TV’s future. The other was inviting in leaders from other industries whose future would likely be intertwined with the cable TV industry.

Additionally, the show was billed as ‘the most important 64 hours in cable TV,’ with a full day having been lopped off the show’s traditional three-and-a-half-day duration.

Burke said the industry is focused on delivering new products and services, from analog to digital. With a show theme of ‘Cable Puts You in Control,’ Burke said that VOD and DVRs would let subscribers see what they want, when they want. He said he invited outsiders such as Electronics Arts chief creative officer Bing Gordon and Yahoo co-founder and Yahoo’s Jerry Yang because the industry is becoming more closely involved with high tech, Hollywood and telephony.

Outlining the industry’s ‘on-demand’ future, Burke forecast that Comcast would have one billion VOD transactions this year and that the cable TV companies would account for 44% of the US DVR market in three years, and do both with good copyright schemes and good business models.

As for broadband, Burke calculated that cable TV already accounts for one-third of all US Internet users, even including dial-up subscribers. In telephony, Burke said that the industry already has three million customers and would, in five years, have one out of every five US residential phone customers. Acknowledging the industry’s wireless shortcoming, Burke said that the cable TV industry wants to add wireless for a ‘quadruple play.’

Newly hired NCTA CEO Kyle McSlarrow, who’s only held the position for five weeks, cited the industry’s ability to move into new business such as its 20 million broadband users and three million telephony customers. As the industry’s chief lobbyist, McSlarrow said the cable TV industry wants a free market rather than a government-regulated one. He said that in such an environment the industry had built a broadband network that passed 90% of American homes and that the government should not apply traditional regulations to the cable industry’s telephony efforts.

McSlarrow added that the industry does recognize that its telephony efforts also have public service responsibilities, including 911 emergency phone service, contribution to the universal service fund that makes phone service possible in rural areas and to provide the US law enforcement agencies with access to phone calls that threaten the country’s security. He also emphasized that the phone companies had a public service responsibility to make all TV channels available to all households in every neighborhood. The cable industry lately has expressed concern that the phone companies would lower their costs and maximize their profits by ‘cherry picking’ only affluent neighborhoods to provide TV service to.

Financial TV channel CNBC’s Ron Insana hosted the ‘Baud to Broadband’ panel, which included Paul Allen of Vulcan Ventures and Charter Communications, Electronic Arts’ Gordon, Cablevision COO Tom Rutledge and Yahoos’ Yang.

Visuals preceding the panel showed cable TV with a 60% market share of the broadband market, a forecast of 12.1 million telephony customers by 2009 and Jupitermedia’s statement that the cable industry is ‘best positioned to package data, voice and TV.’

Allen said that coming technology would impact the platforms of both set-top boxes (STB) and consumer electronics (CE). Set-tops, he said, are a huge business opportunity for the cable TV companies. Products like Digeo’s Moxi, in which Allen’s Vulcan is an investor, shows how set-tops can stream media to other devices in other rooms and provide interoperability with devices such as the iPod. STBs, he said, could be the nexus for the home’s entertainment and computing network. They can be used to ‘trickle’ down content to other devices and be used for after-hours downloads of video and music. They could burn a CD or transfer tracks to an iPod. Cable TV companies, he said, have to connect to many more devices – and solve the problem of doing those connections in ways that are easy for the consumer.

STBs cannot be an island, Allen said, they have to interoperate with other digital media devices. ‘It’s incumbent for us to become a focal point for interactivity of different devices than become an island isolated from those media types,’ he said.

Cable TV’s broadband is still the best pipe into the home, Allen said again this year.

Displaying ‘ticklers’ on TV, instant messaging on TV, bringing niche communities together such as online gamers are some of the applications Allen said could be added to STBs. Adding DVR and VOD capability means that watching TV is becoming much more customized, he said. One challenge that those two capabilities bring is search – the ability to find TV shows.

As to bundling, Allen said customers want a unified billing experience like the one that Cablevision, with its $99 all-in-one bundle, has sold so successfully.

Allen, whose first money was made in the PC industry, said that cable TV and its set-top box platform in the home have advantages. It is the STB, he said, that people ‘touch’ in the home, ‘touch’ with a remote control, of course.

The industry, he said, has to look at alliances with cell phone services.
Allen predicts that there will be an evolution in the STB platform, continued growth in the industry’s broadband business and large revenues from telephony. He said he expects more industry deals with CE companies.

Yahoo’s Yang said that broadband growth brings an opportunity for content providers. Convergence is happening, he said. The things people talked about five years ago are happening now. Noting that three-fourths of Yahoo users have a broadband connection, Yang said there is a need for a ‘MyMedia’ portal and it is a market the cable TV companies can hit head on. MyMedia, Yang said, used to be TV. Now it means much more, he said, asking which device people would give up first: TV, PC, iPod or cell phone. Most people, he said, want their cell phone the most because it has mobility and can access data and music. He talked about a continuing proliferation of devices that would cause the need for a centrally stored MyMedia that could be accessed with various devices.
Yang compared broadband to highways. ‘You build freeways that are wider and faster, and you never get anyone complaining that it’s too fast,’ he said.

Young people, Yang said, use the Net as their medium of choice. Directly challenging the TV industry, Yang said that the young don’t want ‘linear media.’ He addressed one issue that the ad-dependent cable TV folks didn’t talk about very much – the impact that services like digital video recording, with its ad-skipping ability would have on advertising revenue. He said that there will be a shift in advertising spend from inefficient channels to more efficient spend on the Net where ads can be better targeted.

He said that Yahoo is working on interactive TV services for delivery over the Net. ‘The cable industry has done a great job in the last 20 years in going from broadcast to digital. I wouldn’t be here if I didn’t want to do business with cable,’ Yang said.

Cablevision’s Rutledge said that the $100 billion the industry spent upgrading its networks gives it an opportunity to ‘rebrand,’ resulting in much more upside than had been reached. Now, he said, the industry is looking for applications that use the ‘fat pipes’ that have been built.

Much of the network, he said, was used for delivering analog content, but, as that switches to digital, it would free up lots of the pipes’ capacity.
Acknowledging that cellular would be a big business opportunity for delivering content, Rutledge cautioned that it will be a long time before mobile technology will have the bandwidth to replace cable. He said that the industry’s bundling of all their services has to be better than the competition. As to telephony, Rutledge said that copper wire is a very expensive competitor to Internet telephony.

Electronic Arts’ Gordon was the most disruptive force on the panel. He admonished moderator Insana for his lengthy questions. He called the recent cable TV network upgrade version 1.0 and called for a faster network that would have much higher speeds by 2010. ‘My message to all of you is not good news – you have finished build out 1.0, and in 2010 you need to go with building 2.0 or we will go wireless or some other connection,’ he said.

He calculated how the file size that Internet users were willing to download has grown:
Year Gigabytes
2000 0.5
2005 5
2008 20
2010 40

Entertainment and communities go together, Gordon said. High schools where laptops are required and that have ‘chat hubs’ found that students felt closer together.

People, he said, are not likely to go back to their PCs for home entertainment after spending big bucks on enhancing their entertainment gear, for instance big screens and home theater systems, rather than on upgrading their PCs. They are also spending on videogame consoles. The Net, he said, is three times as valuable to young people as their TVs. Consequently, he said, many would spend as much as $150 a month on their Internet experience. Who would have thought, he said, that people would pay for Internet-delivered streaming music when they could have it free on the radio?

Gordon said that Internet telephony will have a major impact on online gaming. ‘It’s nice to reach out and touch someone, but you’ll pay money to reach out and kill someone,’ he said.

A panel of financial officers at the NCTA show this week said they expect double-digit cash flow increases with capital expenditures declining and the revenue from new services such as broadband and VoIP flowing in. Comcast CFO John Alchin said the average revenue per subscriber has gone from $42 a month six years ago to $77 a month now. He said that most of the increase comes from new products and that the growth rate will continue even without the company’s system-wide Internet telephony rollout by year-end. Revenue from broadband grew 28% in 2004, about $800 million, he said. The company is ‘very confident’ it can sustain the almost 10% growth rate that will convert into a low double digit number for cash flow and a 20%-30% growth for free cash flow.

Alchin said the company could be interested in some ‘bite-size’ acquisitions – in the $500 million to $2 billion size.

Time Warner Cable CFO Landel Hobbs said his company sees double-digit revenue growth and cash flow for the foreseeable future. He said that Time Warner had 25% growth rates each in digital, VOD, subscription VOD and DVRs. He said the company now has 220,000 Internet telephony subscribers.

The phone and cable TV companies, striving to sell broadband to American consumers, have poorly rated customer care operations. They might learn a thing or two from Time Warner Cable’s Los Angeles operation, which in 2001 was among the company’s lowest rated for customer loyalty and satisfaction. Surveys showed customers believed the company did not care about them. The LA division reversed its standings by:
– Reducing the rate for digital TV
– Tying employee incentives to productivity and revenue, not just sales.
– Sending anniversary cards to subscribers, thanking them for their loyalty.
– Admitting mistakes and giving impacted subscribers a box of cookies and an apology.
Geez! That wasn’t too hard, was it?

This coverage was contributed by Charlie Hall, editor of The Online Reporter at Rider Research.