Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 April 2005

Cablecos, ISPs and VoIP specialists join virtual network fray

The coming year will see an explosion of non-wireless companies launching mobile services through MVNO (Mobile Virtual Network Operator) agreements, under which they lease capacity from a network owner. As these deals start to have impact well beyond mobile voice and data, and spread into converged services, many dilemmas will face the communications industry, as epitomized in two particularly interesting MNVO projects from contrasting quarters ‘ those of Time Warner Cable and VoIP start-up Vonage.

In the US, in particular, there is the prospect of a painful shake-out in 2006 onwards, with the market failing to sustain all the proposed launches. As in the early internet era, there is a growing belief among companies in many sectors that it will be ‘de rigeur’ to launch a wireless service. As with the early ISPs, few of these will survive, and those that do will either be extremely well targeted to a defined base, like the successful Virgin Mobile among US 15-25-year olds, or will score on a mixture of strong brand, breadth of applications and high levels of customer service.

Customer service is something that communications providers in most countries have failed to deliver, and so the door remains wide open for companies that are more used to providing such benefits, albeit it outside the telecoms space, to leap in.

The companies that will win either way are, of course, the network owners that create a successful business model based on leasing their newly upgraded systems, with Sprint the best positioned.

Converged services are those that deliver virtually the same services whether it is delivered over wireline, Wi-Fi or mobile networks, so anyone offering any of those services now, specifically the US Cable companies, are likely to jump in. Some companies will seek to build up converged networks of their own, while others will create an infrastructure suitable for leasing to a multi-network MVNO via partnerships. The mutual exchange of network capacity between British Telecom and Vodafone, currently dedicated to their own-branded services, shows how companies that lack any piece of the converged jigsaw can fill in the gap through a third party, and then potentially offer the whole combined system for lease.

Many companies are facing a critical dilemma over the triple play of voice, video and high speed data, offered seamlessly (in theory) over wired, wireless and mobile networks and devices. Should they offer this whole complex bundle over their own infrastructure and under their own brand; create and own the combined network but derive much of the revenue from third parties, avoiding the costs and risks of marketing, branding and service delivery; or opt for own-branded services, but renting any or all of the infrastructure?

For no group is the complex issue as urgent as for the US cable operators. Their wireless moves to date have been half-hearted and patchy but, as a body, they are fixed on adding wireless and mobile capabilities to their existing broadband and television portfolios.

This became clear last November when most of the leading cablecos Comcast, Time Warner Cable, Cox, Charter Communications and Advance/Newhouse, held talks with a view to formulating a common strategy for attacking wireless and even launching a national mobile offering under a combined brand.

Three potential routes to market were on the table: to acquire a major carrier; to sign one or more MVNO (mobile virtual network operator) deals, leasing networks from the established players; or adopt a non-cellular technology such as WiMAX. The talks continue, with the most likely outcome, medium term, being that the cablecos sign an MVNO deal that supports both cellular and broadband wireless capabilities. This would make Sprint-Nextel, or a mooted combination of Sprint and pre-WiMAX network builder Clearwire, the most likely partners, with T-Mobile a possibility in certain regions. The other cellcos would see the competition from cable to the DSL operations of their parents as too great a conflict of interest.

The intense interest of the cablecos in wireless and the move to all-IP networks, and the pivotal role of Sprint as the strongest infrastructure partner for both trends, was demonstrated at this week’s National Cable and Telecommunications Association (NCTA) conference. In a panel debate on IP that included Time Warner Cable president Glenn Britt, RealNetworks’ president Rob Glaser, Sprint president and COO Lynn Lauer and Cox president James Robbins, Britt stressed that a ‘third screen’ ‘ the cellphone ‘ was coming into play, and that the whole industry was moving towards offering services over a single phone, at home and on the move.

The critical issue, of course, is who owns the carrier of that phone?

Increasingly, Sprint is abdicating that ownership in favor of dominating the MVNO sector. Even after its merger with Nextel, it will be in clear third place to Verizon Wireless and Cingular Wireless in terms of cellular revenues. By defocusing on its own services and the operating costs associated with those, and by introducing new competition to Verizon and Cingular, indirectly, by supporting MVNOs, it has a far better chance of catching up with the two giants, in profitability even if not in revenue.

Lauer was pointed in telling the cable audience that his company shares something with the cablecos ‘ the telcos are the biggest competitors of both. Sprint is already serving more than 250,000 wireless voice customers through cable partnerships.

Adding some urgency to his pitch that Sprint and the cable TV industry should work together, Lauer said there is a window for them to bring convergence to life, but that the incumbent phone companies would soon close that window.

So far, the quickest moving of the cable operators has been Time Warner Cable, itself, of course, a company that has entered the communications market from a heritage in a very different sector, like the emerging new breed of MVNOs. Though not ruling out participation in a collective cable wireless venture, TWC has already launched its cellular service, using the Sprint network, in its first territory, Kansas City, Missouri. TWC also offers the Road Runner Speed Zone public WLan services in certain areas and a VoIP offering over its cable network. These early, and currently disjointed, elements show the intention to build a common platform where one device can hand off between the cable, Wi-Fi and cellular networks.

Sprint has also signed new leasing deals with three smaller cablecos – Ohio-based Massillon Cable TV, Pennsylvania-based Blue Ridge Communications and West Coast-based Wave Broadband. These are currently local and long distance voice services over Sprint’s wireline network but are likely to be expanded to cellular connections early next year.

There is a long way for cablecos to go, though. They have some in-built advantages in the move to converged services, notably their content partnerships, but in some areas their reputation for customer service and general brand quality is not impressive. Non-communications consumer companies often have far stronger brand identification in their more closely targeted bases than telcos and cablecos, which could help them market a wireless service more effectively once they have leased the network capacity. So far, the names have been relatively small, but there is always the prospect of Wal-Mart or some other retail giant following the UK’s Tesco supermarket chain into the MVNO fray, or of the major ISPs taking up the challenge, with the likes of AOL and MSN already well used to forming delivery partnerships with telcos.

The cablecos, then, need to move quickly and also to do some work on their quality of service. So far, their efforts to offer Wi-Fi integrated into their cable packages do not bode well for their ability to be converged providers. Comcast merely partners with T-Mobile to discount the T-Mobile HotSpot service, but the rates are still higher than for T-Mobile cellular customers, and the combination is not heavily marketed. TWC’s Road Runner exists only in a few hundred locations, and the benefits to its cable subscribers are variable according to area. Meanwhile, Charter is reselling WLan access from RemotePipes, one of the smallest aggregators. None of this looks impressive as a first step to wireless triple play, especially when compared to SBC’s simple-to-understand deal – $20 flat rate for combined DSL and Wi-Fi at its rapidly expanding chain of hotspots, with cellular from Cingular Wireless to be offered on other bundles soon.

In addition to the power of the DSL/telco incumbents, which already own converged networks, and the likely threat of the big consumer brands, there is also the push from non-traditional communications providers. There is the potential disruption from broadband wireless operators delivering the triple play over a single new network ‘ Clearwire, NextWeb and so on ‘ and also from the independent VoIP specialists, led by Vonage.

Well aware that they will face hefty competition from telco and cableco VoIP services, and that voice will rapidly become a discounted or loss leading offering, not a premium service, the VoIP start-ups need to expand into the triple play themselves, building on brands that have become fairly powerful among heavy communications users, in particular.

As a first step, Vonage is to launch a dual-mode Wi-Fi/GSM device by the end of this year, and will consider selling a cellular service as MVNO from early next year.

Michael Tribolet, executive vice president at Vonage, said the company was still in negotiations for its new device with several potential vendors, but that it hoped to release one by the fourth quarter of this year. He said Vonage would only sell a dual-mode device if it could combine both the Wi-Fi and cellular costs into one bill, agreeing that offering its own cellular service via an MVNO deal was a strong option.

Tribolet stressed that its core VoIP offering, like future IP services it might launch, were both device and network agnostic, and so could travel over high speed wireless networks like WiMAX and even modern cellular systems like HSDPA . Indeed, Vonage has demonstrated its voice service running over Verizon’s CDMA EV-DO network, which has recently been enhanced to support IP as well as traditional circuit switching. EV-DO will still need to increase its rates to support full Vonage service, which mandates 100Kbps on the uplink and downlink (EV-DO can do 300-500Kbps on downlink, but only up to 80Kbps on downlink).

The opportunities to deliver bundled triple play services over converged wireline/wireless all-IP networks, whether owned or leased, are the most attractive thing since the birth of the internet for communications providers (established or new) and their shareholders. The attractiveness of the market, though, will pull in a host of new players, and only a few of those will be able to survive in the developed markets in the US and Europe beyond 2008, the probable tipping point year for mobilized triple play.

This report ran originally in our sister paper Wireless Watch and includes contributions from Charles Hall at Rider Research who attended the NCTA.